← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/377/2018dismissed

Ranbir Singh v. Muncipal Committee, Assandh And Others

2025-01-31Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill,Mrs. Justice Sukhvinder Kaur5 pages



        

  



!"!

#$

#%&'

 ( )

#*!& +!#,-



.

&"%"

/%#! !01  22!

( ""#3- #3

&"



/$  4 /+5 +  +

 4 /+5 +  +6.

 6



    

 

   



    !" #  $$$$ + ( 5

 %      &    ' '

   () 

 &#  

 &# +,-.)/-  &#

 0

   &       1

     (2 

 &#    3 0

  %&0 - 01-4 &0 +0     5   6 7%&0 89 4  %&0    (2



51 9

/:&  

1  2;4   '*

 1 &



/<- #  *

#  =0

 1

  

  0

  0  0&1

'1  2;    '     

 &# >?  @

 0

   2;     0 "  0



0  0 0     "   1  

 1

  # 0  # 0    ' 

1

A 

/B! " 3 0

  0 

5  67 

89 ' "  1 

 

#  0  

    &    %&0  + 1

 

?0 0&1

3 0#

 &# # 

 # &# 0

   '    1   ' '&# 0

   0#

3  1 1 1# 0  +11



&0  ' '&#0 +   4  %&0 

 



0    



 /-!  "   

 3

 '# 

    (2 1 &



/:&  1 2; 2 ''  1 0

  +,-.)/-

 '  (2 ;  '*

 0 -

C1

#

 '

0 



    

 

#  (.  #    ?

 1 1



&# 0  +0

    0'  0 # +11

     

0 +11

 



 0   1  0   +0

   

#   1 #  ' 

   

' 0  # 

'  





0     +0 &#

 '  +,  D)   ; ,     & # '



-1 0 0 1# ' 

0  +11



&#

1 % 0  +0

  

&   #   #

  & 

 #&   



(. #

 E0



'1

=0

0  "  ''   &

   4 &0+0  (2 

1



/<- +1

 10

 & &# 0  +11

 

   

 +, D) ;  ;;

 0

 

   E0

    ;;   & '     +

E0

#

  #  

0    

1

&  F / ''  1

   &  D

  

 1

# '0    



/-B! "      %&0  

# 

     (2 



 

  '  /: &  %1



 & 0 # '    =0   

   &  %  1

03   

  '0 &#  

  

/<- 1 ' '   '

  

  3 0   #    &  10'

 ()& 0 '  (2

&#  %&0  )

  

        0&1

  

 &#  

    &  & 0   ' &  



  



 1

     # 

(

,    

        0#

0 G  .   

    

  ' ' &# 0   +    

 &  (.  #  0 +11



 1

#  0  =0





   

 2; 

 (.  # 0#

"  ' 

0

 1 %   

110

 ) 0 #+11

   >?  @

 0

 5>?,<9 4 

  

0 & 

0 #

 #  3  

'  

  & 

#

E0

    %&0 ! 

0 



 ' 

 & 1   =0'1

 " 8&  01 +0

11-*3 #7 #3

&"

&"%"

6&!"-# 1 +!#,-  9 :;

+ 



# -1  "

#

 &0 & !

# &"%"

/55  "-!



9:;

+ )5  '

   '*





#

  '&  

 #&   0



E0



'1



1   +1

/<- &   &#   

 , 0 0  

 '

  

 

<-

 

/<-  10

 0

01   1 #  #   &    

1

 ()&  

 '     #  

  '01

   2  

 '# 1



&  1

  &#   '*

 9 + ;



9+6.

 6;

#%&'

 (

)



,    '< H <  ,  &H <