High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/750/2013disposed of

Ramesh Chand v. Sandeep Kumar And ORS

2019-02-28Mr. Justice Arun Palli3 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* +

"-$(..")% //$00")# 1$2(3( ")%$$/43-"2")%#.$2( $(/)%$)#( * 5 6 6

2$($)#* 2 "7%'(.")&.")%"8%1&"#$8

2#.$"//$00")# 24 .'-")8%1&"#$8

2#.$2$(/)%$)#( 68 2"0 9,:

.37.#.$%'(/3#$;$#<$$)#.$/"2#'$('((#"#$%#."1$;$$) ($##0$%"(2$&2%$%')#.$2%$2%"#$%+

,8#.$"&&-/")=')7"//$"0 <"()#%'(/($% )#."#%"#$"(#.$0$7"0.$'2( 2$(/)%$)#)98'$ -#">$(.8."%)#;$$);237.#)2$&2%8(.$."1')7%'$%%32')7#.$ /$)%$)&= #.$"//$"0

= #.'( "//0'&"#')8 #.$ 0$7"0 2$/2$($)#"#'1$( #.$ ("'% 2$(/)%$)#8'$.$2.3(;")%")%-')2()8"2$(37.##;$'-/0$"%$%') .$2 /0"&$ "( .$2 0$7"0 2$/2$($)#"#'1$(8 <'#. #.$ .3(;")% "0( ;$')7 " ('7)"#2=##.$&-/2-'($%$$%"(."(;$$)"))$?$%<'#.

,8;=<.'&.#.$"&&-/")=')7"//$"0'((37.##;$%'(/($% #'&$')#.$"//0'&"#') 2 "7%'(.")&.")%""&&$/#()#'&$);$."0 #.$)):

"//0'&")#:"//$00")#")%%$()#;>$&##'#;$')7"00<$%

)($@3$)#0=8#.'("//0'&"#')'("00<$%")%#.$#</$2()( <.($)"-$("2$7'1$)')/"2"72"/. #.$"//0'&"#')8'$32$)%$2 43-"28.3(;")% #.$0"#$-#">$(.8")%#308-')2() 32$)%$2 43-"22$/2$($)#$%#.237..'( "#.$2")%)"#32"073"2%'")8"2$2%$2$%# ;$'-/0$"%$%"(#.$0$7"02$/2$($)#"#'1$( 2$(/)%$)#)9(3;>$&##"00 >3(#$?&$/#')("(2$7"2%(")=#.$20$7"02$/2$($)#"#'1$(8<.'&.8)@3$2=8 0$"2)$%&3)($0 2#.$"//0'&")#(#"#$(#."##.$2$'()#.$2&.'0% #.$0"#$ -#">$(.

.'("//0'&"#')'("0("00<$%8;=<.'&.#.$"&&-/")=')7 "//$"0'((37.##;$%'(/($% ')#$2-( #.$&-/2-'($2$"&.$% ;$#<$$)#.$/"2#'$(

$(/)%$)#() #.$2$')."%')(#'#3#$%#.$(3'#')#.$ /2$($)# ($$A')7 "%$&0"2"#') ##.$$

$&# #."# #.$7'

# %$$%%"#$%

"00$7$%0=$?$&3#$%;=#.$0"#$.2'32#"8')2$(/$&# #.$(3'# 0")%8;$%$&0"2$%)300")%1'%8"0)7<'#."<'00%"#$%

")%"

0$"($%$$%%"#$%

.$("'%(3'#."1')7;$$)%$&2$$%;=#.$0$"2)$%#2'"032#8 <'#. #."# >3%7-$)# ")% %$&2$$ ."1')7 ;$$) 3/.$0% ;= 0$"2)$% 0<$2 "//$00"#$32#8#.$"//$00")#%$ $)%")#) ')#.$(3'#'(')($&)% "//$"0 )1'$< #.$&-/2-'($2$"&.$%;$#<$$)#.$/"2#'$(&/= ))$?32$:

<'#.

,8<.'&.#.37.'()#($$)#;$ %"#$% ;3# '( (.<) # ;$ $?$&3#$% ;= "//$00")# "-$(. .")% ")%

2$(/)%$)#(")%$$/43-"28")>43-"284"(#32'8"-#"8".')%28

";=")%"-#<.'((#"#$%#;$"&#3"00=2$(/)%$)#)B.$2$')8#.$ "//$"0'(%'(/($% <'#.#.$'-/37)$%>3%7-$)#(")%%$&2$$(-%' '$%') #$2-( #.$("'%&-/2-'($%$$%8<.'&.(."00;$-"%$"/"2# #.$%$&2$$ (.$$#8;')%')7)"00('7)"#2'$(#.$2$# #'(#;$(/$&'

'&"00=)#'&$%#."#2$(/)%$)#),$> "0 %$ $)%")#)')#.$(3'#'()#"('7)"#2=##.$&-/2-'($%$$%8<'#. 0$"2)$%&3)($0 2#.$/"2#'$((#"#')7#."#.$<"()#') "&#";$)$ '&'"2=') #.$(3'#/2/$2#="#32"00=8)#.')7#.$2$ 2$<30%"

$&#")=$?'(#')7 2'7.#( '

"# "00 #.$2$ "2$ ")= @3" 2$(/)%$)# ), ') #$2-( #.$ &-/2-'($%$$%8<'#.'##;$ 32#.$2)#'&$%#."##.$"

2$-$)#')$% 4"(#32'8 ".')%28 "-#" ")% ")) C "-#" "2$ (.<) # ."1$ "//$)%$% #.$'2 #.3-; '-/2$((')( ) #.$ &-/2-'($ %$$%8 #.$ #.$2 /"2#'$(#'#."1')7('7)$%#.$("-$ '(/($% ')#.$"

2$("'%#$2-(

/A D.$#.$2(/$"A')7E2$"()$% $(E D.$#.$2$/2#";0$ $(E