High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1747/2015disposed of

Krishna Rani And ORS v. Kaushal Sapra

2023-02-23Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()*++* , -.."// (!' 0"1'2' KAUSHAL SAPRA -+"'.#(3"(!

#1 4) #(56/"1+2'!&%"+ +7 /& 1"'"(!) 1+,1&'8 ( 8 14 93:#% !"$#1 '+""12 (' /93:#% !"$#1!8" ../&% (!' .."// (!'+ 1+#8&!("; 93:#% !"$#11+ 82/ 8 14 93:#% !" $#1!8"(#( ../&% (!1"'.#(3"(!+ <<< + +7 /& 9+

1 /

../&% !&#(&'$#1."14&''&#(!#./ %"#(1"%#13%#4.1#4&'"

=+ > '(("=21"? /#(@A&!8#13"13 !"3+B+. ''"36C !8" /" 1("3 1+ &:+9 42( @ 1 ! @ 381& ' (("=21"+ D" 1("3%#2('"/$#1!8"(#( ../&% (!1"'.#(3"(!'! !"'!8 ! 8" 8 ' (# #6;"%!&#( !# !8" $#1"4"(!&#("3 3#%24"(!' 6"&(@ ! E"( #( 1"%#13+ ( :&"A #$ !8" '! !"4"(! #$ /" 1("3 %#2('"/ $#1 !8" (#( ../&% (!1"'.#(3"(!9 !8" ../&% !&#( &' //#A"3+ #%24"(!' &+"+ %#4.1#4&'" =+ > (3#13"13 !"3+B+. ''"36C!8"/" 1("3

1+ &:+9 42( @ 1 ! @ 381& !! %8"3 A&!8 !8" ../&% !&#( 1"! E"(#(1"%#13 '(("=21"'? (3'26;"%!!# // ;2'!"=%".!&#('+

#1!8"1" '#(' ' 1"4"(!&#("3&(!8" ../&% !&#(9!8"' 4" &' //#A"3+ ../&% (!'93"! &/'#$A8#4 1"4"(!&#("3&(. 1 @1 .8#+ #$!8" ../&% !&#(9 1"&4./" 3"3 'D+'+#$!8"3"%" '"3 .."// (!#+9 ,1&'8( (&$#1!8".21.#'"'#$!8"&('! (! .." /#(/C+

#1!8"1" '#(' ' 1"4"(!&#("3&(!8" ../&% !&#(9!8"' 4" &' //#A"3+ ../&% (!'93"! &/'#$A8#4 1"4"(!&#("3&(. 1 @1 .8#+ #$!8" ../&% !&#(9 1"&4./" 3"3 'D+'+#$!8"3"%" '"3 .."// (!#+H "' ;$#1!8".21.#'"'#$!8"&('! (! .." /#(/C+ 4"(3"34"4##$. 1!&"'&'! E"(#(1"%#13+

D" 1("3 %#2('"/ $#1 !8" ../&% (!' 3#"' (#! .1"'' !8" &('! (! ../&% !&#(+ &'4&''"3 '(#!.1"''"3+

FG ../&% !&#(2(3"1 13"1*2/"*1" 3A&!8 "%!&#( &' $#1 3&'.#' / #$ #+ #$ &( :&"A #$ !8" %#4.1#4&'"9 (("=21"?3 !"3+B++

F*G

FG D" 1("3%#2('"/$#1!8"(#( ../&% (!1"'.#(3"(!'! !"'!8 !&( :&"A#$ 4&% 6/"'"!!/"4"(!#$!8"3&'.2!"6"!A""(!8". 1!&"'6CA C#$ %#4.1#4&'"9 (("=21" ? 3 !"3 +B+9 8" 8 ' (# #6;"%!&#( &$ !8" &('! (!1"@2/ 1'"%#(3 .." /&'3&'.#'"3#$&(!"14'!8"1"#$+ F*G &(% '"&'/&'!"3$#18" 1&(@#(?++*+#A":"19A&!8 !8"%#('"(!#$ /" 1("3 %#2('"/ $#1!8" . 1!&"'9 !8"' 4" &' .1".#("3 $1#4 ?++*!#!#3 C (3&'! E"(#(6# 13$#18" 1&(@!#3 C&!'"/$+ FG

8 //"(@" &( !8" &('! (! 1"@2/ 1 '"%#(3 .." / &' !# !8" ;23@4"(! (33"%1""3 !"3*+*+. ''"36C!8"/" 1("3&'!1&%!23@"9 42( @ 1&( &:&/.." /#+I#$*&(% '"!&!/"3 ', 2'8 /

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

! " # $ % & '"

'" ( ## #) *# "

! * #

+ ,

&-./$0' " ! 1 **22* **22* 2 "

3 (

( "

4) % ( #

" 6 " 78 - 7 9(:%;

)- 7 9(:%;# & <=$ 7 3*:9% 8> 1<>$ 7 3*:9% 8#

" ! **22* **22* 2 ?@? 6 1" '" & 6 1" 9

*# " + "!1 **22* **22* 2 A "

( #

*B (B*

1 9 (B*B2(B*

" "

* #

1 B92(B*3 " -C "

+ "

: FIG 8 !&(:&"A#$!8" 4&% 6/"'"!!/"4"(!#$!8"3&'.2!"6"!A""( !8". 1!&"'9!8"&('! (!1"@2/ 1'"%#(3 .." /&'3&'.#'"3#$&(!"14'#$!8"

%#4.1#4&'"9 (("=21" ? 3 !"3 +B+ A8&%8 '8 // 6" 1" 3 ' ( &(!"@1 / . 1! #$ !8&' #13"1+ 1!&"' '8 // 1"4 &( 6#2(3 6C !8" !"14' (3 %#(3&!&#(' ' @1""3 2.#( (3 A8&%8 $#14 . 1! #$ !8" %#4.1#4&'" (("=21"?3 !"3+B++23@4"(! (33"%1""#$!8" #21!'6"/#A '! (3'4#3&$&"3 ' 6#:"+

"#$%&

*++* 4 % ) + "2

7 21 ) 7 21