← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/776/2013dismissed

Balinder Singh v. Improvement Trust Karnal

2015-05-19Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram7 pages

  

       

!"##$%&%'()**  

 ! "#"

$% &% '

#" ()  "  (+  ,-  

 

.#&#'"(  * % 

(&+ 

    &  #(&+ 

"  ////

 0 "+    " , 

 ,-   

.

." 

,   /#  "

 1 

"",-  /&2#  3&"() &.

""# .""%"". +" " 0#  4

"",-    3"

+ 2# () &.

,-   "

,&"0#  1 

."""%"".

+" "

 +"      

,     /# # "

." # " #"+"

#+  #  5" #   /-() 

%%'

"% # " "  5" #   /-( ) .

.",#  # / - 64'

("

"#,%   #+/%% ()  " +"

#+ 

 

"  #"& ,&" "(.

.""+  -

61'

("

"+"

#+ & " "  " . ".""   

& "  "7 ", ++#  "#  #""+ - 65'

 +."" & # %   65,- #+/%%   

+    %"# 4 89 18 ",+ # -.

%"

# /'

 +&"#  0#+  .

."

"%"" ,- % "++ ."""%""  #+/%%  : """"   

% % %&  + % "#,";#   ( #+ /%% " "%,-+&   "&, ", "4   6$ ." #

+"  

  ,+:" ""& , "(  - % "  

,"

.,-

% &%  #" '

(  +   

."" & # %.

 + #  % 

:

1545"

. ,  # /  

"(   . ""  "<   . ""# "'

" +."

 ,-  

    +  + % %  ." %     +    65$ ."

#

"+"    60  -  

".,-  $"

% +.""" &  %,- $% &% #" .

+&"#  .

."+  &# 

  + .""%"".( "+  "   ."" 

% +" &   "# "  #   " + $"

  %(&+ ( ."+  + %  -  , 1545 ,% + "  "# 

   +( "  .

."  ,

  /# .

 "  % $ ."  

:

  1545  ."    % +   ,-       =  #"     % + ( ." #  

+ #  %"#  5   . "" ( 5   . "." (<   . ""#

   . "

":

#%,  "%    

" +.""    

## <+ % .

 "#  0#+ .

.""%"",- /#  

"++ ."""%""'

  + % ."

%&$ ." #

    "#,";# - 

 $"

%  + #  1545 .

+ "+ -" ,"



% % +  " +%  

( # " 65";# - "

%%& ",#   "  """"" %     # ",- %& ""'

,&"$"

%  "+ # 1545%   ""   ,  & ( "  

+# , %   :&   % +&"#    $"

  %"+ +%;# "# " ,  % -



 ""." &+ #+,- % 4   /#  +#" ,

 " #" "."%"" "#   

.

+" " &   %# 0#   1 

  

,-  

 "0# ."""%"",-

  3"

+ 2# () &0#   4

1  

&

%  " ,-,

4 /# ",.& %# 0# % "+ "(   

 ,-  "   "+ > +#"   " .

 "&, ."" #"  >   +#"          %  

#% " " " " +  " ,""  "

"# 

,-   

  $ " #

"+  

    "% -  " #   "#    ,-  $"

 /    %  

"  $% &% '

#" () ."+ ,-    /#    /# ."

"%",-   /# $ " #

""#,%"   ,"" % "+ """ $"

%(

"  "# ."" ,+ (,# , ",. &.

 - "%"" "#    . #  :  +"   ,&"0# % "+ " 5 .($.  "+#"" &+ ,  "   "" .

,&+  " ",-  +#"

  +

+    $ ." +%  ,    /# # "+"

#+  #"# 

% %& "  "  . ","""" "%$ " #

"+    %-+ % # , 1545"   ,,  # /  "+" "." ," &+&.

"    -# " "#   -

% " &#".

%(,#     #+ "% -"  #  +"(& " +", , . %

1 .

   "  ,"  +    &+     %      + & "-

+ &-  -'

  

%#  "+" ,"" % "+ "&    "#    " +    $"

 /    %(  &+    "  $% &%  '

#" ( ) '

 ."" "+     -"#   "  "#  "$"

%.",   :

1545#  "  ." " ,"

".+""

" "",- &+"#   - &    "# "   , ,-$"

/ %(&+ " , :"0# %  " 0# %  %""#+ "%+ , -   "   "  "#  & ( "0#  " ,+%

"+ "+ "%.""  (.

 "  "# .""  #  *?%)#% )%,0(3 "% & " @9*4.

   "+  "#   -"

""  % ( "#   -" ) 14  " "   "+ ""9%  % + :

"14 1545 " ,#  " " %-" " -+ + "

". ""   -% +     - 

% 7;* .  )#    % " % +  , :

#%, " 3?4 ,

()#  & % + 

@934 . +  +- " @931 

(     ,  - % + 

   + & % +  @934", #

  ,- "  "  %  3?4 ,

    3?1   (  '

#"  @   "  % +  ) "154514 ."%



"  3# -/%%"" () % + ( ." #  

+ # 1545 5   . "

" ( 5   . "." (<   . ""#    . "

 "" #%  &,

  # +- "+

$"

%(   !:" (&+ "+ +%%"" +

-#  % +  , "1545 14 "++%%"""#,%   1

  "

/# " !:" (&+ ."9%,-   "3?

.

 & % +  ;# ,&", :

#%, ""@93  . " @93 6    % 

#% " (+- 0# %  &   ,- "  /#      14  

    5

4  "  

     ."

, #

   + * 5 "0# % "  ,

&    % %  ""# "  .

""

# A  

 

        

       

       

          



  

!"    

 

 

     

  

    

     

     

                           

       #   

          



     

    

 



            

  $  #          

%

+(            B)  $% &% '

#"  ",++ 14

+  "# """#+ 0# % "+ "&  &# $"

  %,- , ",." "#   ," ""

 "#   ( "  "  , ,"%""

$ 

 ,&"+#""( ",

%  """ ""%"". +" """ ++  - +    %    "  ,  ""   (  %"+#"+ ( -("" "# % +-"" &

,  

#+ ##" )**

  .%1  

 ',

   "  CD"B

 ?

% "

#,  3 " CD"B