High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24826/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Madhu Sooden Sadyal And Another

2024-11-21Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

!"# $% &

!

$ '$(# $%

!"

)% *+ ) , ,, - *+ ), , , ,) $% &' " ( )$*+

*

#% )$*+

),

"# $ , )$*+

)

( )$*+

) ---- ,, - .

.

%

, #

)

#

#

%

/0 /12$ 3 # &

$( 4+ .& ++ ),

&

, %

%)

+(# %

& ( * * & # /(0'/1 /(23!

'$#

"

, * 5//0

6 , + % ( *+ , 5/0 / 7 8 + % (

*+ )

, %

,% & & %,

4 /541406 17$0

#4 /541406 8$ 4 $ 9

! 14 : ;:

5 $

0 )

$)&

.& ++

% & % & ( ; </= % /= .

##+ , , *

/0 /12$ 3.

# * #

+

!

"

# "$ %

& ' !(&" ")('

% %% (

)

#

%

,

,'574 4 $

0< 1/!$# ( '$ 1

! 0< 80404 $!

< $

)

+

23* >%( &

?@& $# 7 ),

&)

?

&(

* ,

&

# ,(

)

.& ++ +

%

6 ) + 8 & ( # % # < 6

&

?@& $# 7 +

*$ "

+!!)!!&" ,-.&*' + ()( / 0 1

,) + 5/1 //1.

# % # < 6 & +( +

!

"

#

$

%

&

%

#

'

$

(

'

( ) *

(

+ $

,+

(

) *

,+

$

$

- 0 $ %# % # <

2# 3+ +

+

+ + ( &

*+ +

)

(

+ %

##

*

& %

8

(# )& % # (

# # )

&)

+ ()

& +(% %

, > +

) 8 & , )& ,

# & % +

# #

#

%

,

1

+ # % # 6

)

$# 7

+

?% 7 , > +

# +* % # 6

,

.

* , ##

++ #

>%( %*$ "

+232&" ,-.

&*$ '+4' ,$5 1 / 0 2 .

* # % # ,

+

. $

=

"

$

* 6

) * $

,/ $

) *

$

$

!"

0

$ ) *

,'574 4 $

0< 1/!$# ( '$ 1

! 0< ! 8 $#$0

/

)

+

&(

>%( ##+ &

+ )

( (&

+ +(& & ( , + #

& #

,(

##

+

% ( A%%23)

, > & + # ## %( )

# + +

B% C + >%( # &

?@& $# 7 )

// /6)+ /"4$#! ,4$3< > $4 $

$#4/ /$# 0<! ) , + 4"41 88/1

??

% .

* # % #

* +

1

/2,,3/,, & 4

#

* 5 ,36.

3/,,

/,/,,..+

$

!

7 8 0

/,/,,..+ 96:

!

/,/,,..+ /,/;3//.$

5

- $ !$(

0<4 '!0

.

% )*&+ ( &

%% ,

& + % + +% # &

++

#)

% ( & ( A

( & &

*+ +

?, )

+ #

&* #+# )

% + &

$# 7 + / 0 1

,& ' + ,$5 1 / 0 & '

)

+ ++ )& +(%

@

# * * ()& ,

& +

#

(

%

5

( )

+ #

#

+

# % # ) ++

2# 3 &

$# 7 )

)

+ & %

+(

%%

#)

* ( & %

%%

, +% + + + * *

%% "

)

&

% + ()

,

+

& (

& ##

*+ +

, + * + (&%&+A %

% %

%% 4

(%,

+ + , + ++ * *

#

, +% + + + &

(%,

+ # ) & %

# )

&) + & (

+ (

)

* + + ++

# )#)

( A% * &

?@& $# 7 + *$4 $

$#4/ > /7 "0/!@) #

, $14$ @ ) + / / ),

) + (

)

%)

& +( ,

++ .

*

# % # ++

2# 3 +

2#

(

%

* 5 , '.;'< = %* >

< ?

$ @,/,3//,

& =

& =

!

+!

%

;

"

) *

< .

)+

& %

+ (

# )#)

( A%

&

$# 7 )+ *$4 $

$#4/ > /7 "0/! A '8!/B 8 )

+ ,(

2# 3),

+ * %

+( , * *

++

& "

)

,(

%

)* *

++ )

& +(

+

(

?

(%) ,

#(# 8

#

+ () ) (

,

6 +

* 2# 3 & + ( #+ / /

(

* )

( &

.& ++ )

/1.

% )

(

2# 3 #(# ( # +

)& (

& 5 D A% # + ?, ) ,

,( (

* *

# )& + & %

8 ( .

) ,

& %

*

#

% 2# 3&

++( + + +% + + 8

# "

& %

+ (

#

A%8

##

%& %( * 0 *

, +

+ , ( 2# 3( A

+ & # , ()

&)

# , () ( *

2# 3 ( A

+ & * *

+ # ++ ) )

)

++

( )

A

% %

,( (

)

)

+(# ( ) #

)& # + *

& +

4$/1 !#!

0<4 '!0

1

(

)

7 (

,

,

& * )

( ( .

(#% ( ( +

( + &

+

)

# % ##+ 23) ) 23# A,, -B A, ,)B

<0<! 8/24$3C!/ $# %

C

<0<! !8 !0/51 %

C