← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/48/2018dismissed

Sumit Kumar And ANR v. Distt Magistrate Panchkula And ANR

2018-01-15The Taxing Officer,Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi4 pages

  



             !" #$

  $ %&' (')!*!"+    ,-.!&/-.%0%"(%"&1'0 233'44%"&* 5'0*-* !*&0!)& %6!*&0%&'7%")18-4%%"(%"&1'0  2'*3"('"&*

 +

9  , 

 , 

9  , 

,# 0'*'"&+ 01-*1%"1%&!%7(:)%&' 0&1'%33'44%"&* ;;;      <=

1%44'"6'!"&1!*!"&0%>)-0&%33'%4!*&?-(6.'"&(%&'(  $ 3%**'(@A&1'4'%0"'(,!"64'-(6'-314(!"60('0(%&'( $3%**'( @A &1' !*&0!)& %6!*&0%&'7 %")18-4% -"('0 &1' 30:!*!"*   &1' %!"&'"%")' %"( #'4 %0'   %0'"&* %"( ,'"!0 !&!C'"* )&7 

$  0 *10&DE&1')&9 <= 0!'

%)&*   &1' )%*' %0' &1%& 0'*3"('"&  !* &1' %&1'0  %33'44%"&F3'&!&!"'0  %"( !* G"'0   4%&  7 %0A%"% 5!(1%" ,%@1% 0-3 -*!"6 ,)!'&A7 ,')&0 7 %")18-4% 1%:!"6 0'&!0'( %* % 6:'0".'"& *'0:%"&  33'44%"&F3'&!&!"'0  !* 3*&'( !" &1' %0A%"% 5!(1%",%@1%%"(G%*%44G'(@A1!* %&1'00'*3"('"&&4!:'!"% 0. !" &1' % 0'*%!( 4%& G1!4' &1'0 &G 0.* G'0' 6!:'" " 0'"&



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

  !"# $    

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

!'(

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

'0!&&&1').3'&'"&%-&10!&A 0(')!*!" 1').34%!"& )%.'&@'(')!('(&1'0'% &'0"4A" $ (.!&&'(4A7 0'*3"('"& %&&%!"'(%6' @'!"6%*'"!0)!&!C'"" I  K 1'0'

0'7&1' 1A3'0>&')1"!)%4 34'% &%8'" @A &1' %33'44%"&*FG0!& 3'&!&!"'0* &1%& &1' ).34%!"&!*(%&'( 7!* "%:%!4*!")'%(.!&&'(4A&1').34%!"& G%*(')!('(!",'3&'.@'0 $@A&1'!*&0!)& %6!*&0%&'7%")18-4%!'&1' ).3'&'"&%-&10!&A")'!&!*&1'3*!&!"&1%&&1'%33'44%"&FG0!&3'&!&!"'0 G%*0'*!(!"6!"&1' 4%&!"H-'*&!"!"1!*)%3%)!&A%*%4!)'"*''71'1%* " 0!61& & 0'*!*& ':!)&!" %* *-61& @A 1!* %&1'0 %* 3'0.!**!" & %33'44%"&F3'&!&!"'0&-*'&1'30'.!*'**&(&'0.!"%&'(&1'..'"& 0'*3"('"&!'4!)'"*0)":'A'("&!)' &'0.!"%&!" &1'4!)'")' 1' 4%& %(.!&&'(4A !* 0'6!*&'0'( !" &1' "%.'   0'*3"('"&  G1 !*

%&1'0 %33'44%"&FG0!&3'&!&!"'0

 <K= " &1' )!0)-.*&%")'*7 G' !"( " .'0!& !" &1' %33'%4 G%00%"&!"6 !"&'0 '0'")' G!&1 &1' G'44 0'%*"'( 0('0 3%**'( @A &1' 4'%0"'( ,!"64' -(6' <$= ))0(!"64A7&1'30'*'"&%33'%4!*(!*.!**'(  %?'*1!"(%4  ,#%4!% -(6' -(6'    %.!&  #1'&1'0&1'0('0!**3'%8!"6F0'%*"'( + '*F  #1'&1'0&1'0('0!*0'30&%@4' + '*F