Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And ORS v. Asharfi Devi
! "# $ %&' (')*+*!, %-+.*! %/0%!%*12*3*&/%!*4%5&( *+%/%!( &.'/+ 66'22%!&+ 3'/+7+ +.%/ *'8* '+6!('!&
,
9 :
:
9 :
:" /'+'!&, /:!4*%;(8)%&' /&.'%66'22%!&+ <<< !&/%=)7/&%66'%2.%+>''! *2'(%4%*!+&/('/(%&'( ?.'/'>0 " # $ ?%+ %22?'( %!( *5674!'( /('/ !!'@7/' =A (%&'( B $ ?*&.(/%?*!4
*)' 5'5 (%&'( ?%+ C7%+.'(D >'+*('+; /('/ !!'@7/' =# (%&'( A B $ 6%++'(>0/'+6!('!&?%+%2++'&%+*('%!(&.')!+'C7'!&*%2>'!' *&+ &.'/'!?'/'/('/'(&>'/'2'%+'(&&.'/'+6!('!&?*&.*!+*@?''-+ /5 &.'(%&' +76620 )'/&* *'()60 &.'/('/ /*'
%)&+ &.' )%+' 2'%(*!4 & &.' *2*!4 &.' *!&/%=)7/& %66'%2 %/' &.%& &.' /'+6!('!& ?%+ '!4%4'( %+ 6%/&=&*5' :?''6'/ >0 &.' %66'22%!&+ %& *&+
*)' *! %22%>4%/. *! # %!( ?/-'( %+ +7). &*22 ')'5>'/ ; ! ?.*). (%&' .'/ +'/8*)'+ ?'/' /'472%/*E'( >0 &.' )56'&'!&%7&./*&0 ?'8'/;?*&.*! 7/5!&.+&.'/'% &'/;&.'/('/ /'472%/*E%&*! .'/+'/8*)'+?%+?*&.(/%?!!&.'4/7!(&.%&?.'!&.' /'+6!('!&?%+%66*!&'(;.'/!%5'?%+!&+6!+/'(>0&.' 56205'!&
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
/' 6%++*!4&.'*5674!'(/('/ /'8'/;*&?%+!&&.')%+' &.'%66'22%!&+ &.%&&.'?/-%!()!(7)& &.'/'+6!('!&?%+!&+%&*+ %)&/0
%8*!4 )!+*('/'( &.' +2*&%/0 +7>5*++*! 2'%/!'( )7!+'2
/&.'%66'22%!&+&.%&&.'!%5' &.'/'+6!('!&?%+!&+6!+/'(>0&.'
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
B ))/(*!420; *!(*!4 ! 5'/*& *! &.' %66'%2; &.' +%5' *+ (*+5*++'(*!2*5*!'?*&.)+&+ B;
F=&>'('6+*&'(?*&.'4*+&/0
%5*& ".'&.'/+6'%-*!4F/'%+!'( , '+F ".'&.'//'6/&%>2' , '+F