Xen Op Divisional No. 1 And 2 Dadri, Distt. Bhiwani And & ORS v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court & ANR
!" "#$%&&
!
" ##$ %
%
&$%'&
$%
()
% '
& (&(&() ' (& (
*
) * '
! +,) ,( )-(. /, '
- (( /) )-(. 1( 0
'
,( )-(. /, 0 '
-)(( )-(. 1( () ( 22222 &(&(+$",+-+.!+/& 0
,. ,(1( .()( ,((1)3(145)3 ,1,,6 , (/),-,/(1 0- 7
7), 0,. ,()!3
!( )8311,)-,
3(145)3 ,1,,6 0, .()() $'
) ), ( )(1
0
9!, .( ,) ,( (1
0 :!)67 (1 0 ) ,6 +!)6
) , ) #&01 #2 34 $ !5!6!#$+. #& +$" / +"7!/ !688& ,!-+$! +$" #8, 76 96& 7 6!"!$: 22! 7 $";687!+. 7!<;$+. ;=+<#7 #;78 +$" +$#8, 7> ).,)) ( ; <= <= 3 -, ! (1 ,) ( ) ) ,6 +!)6 7(),1,) / ) (1 8(! $(!
) <;
< <>
?! & 0?
,
)(15<@8.A&/6
(6/, 0 ,1 (1 ,
0 81, (1 8.A&/6 /
,.
(><@ 07(! (1
;A0 /0,.00)8)( )83
0) ,!
!.(1 0, ,7( ) ) )< <>/0 ( ,.(17( ,(/ ,
!), 0 /0,.00 (. 3 7?,7!7 (1,
/0,
3,6 / )/ (8 ! )
0) 83,
!,6)7)) 1
0 ( /0,.0 /,60) /, 0 ) ,6 +!)6 / 0(, (1 0/( A7 ',/ (< < B4=) 0, / ), ) /, 0 , .78 <<< 0) -) )7) ( ,. ( <C <5 <<;
?! & ) 0 1( /0, ( ,.,6 0 ((!.7 (1/83 ?$(!
,,+7+8(+$ ,+7 !:+=8"&96&,;7;=+./1?(??, / 0) (), .
-,).1( /( A,61( 53 0)81! , 0)83 0/( A7) 7(
(1 0 )(.!7
/ 8 (3 /( 3
0 )3 , , ,6 0 )7) ( ,. (1 ; 3 / ..( ),63 A , .( ,) ,(836 ,6(3><@(1 08.A&/6
;
!
(1 0 &8((A /(!) 6( ( 0(/ .,7(1 0/( A7/ (
6 0(1 0.,7 ,(1,) 0 / (, ) ', ( < < B4= 83 0 () &,67 !7 (!
( 4 A 0 1 0 / 1 ) ( (/ (!
$0 A0, ) , ) 7,) 0 , .78 <<< / .,7) 0(
(/0,.00/ /( A,6/ (1 7 ! 8!
0/ ) ),3/6 ) 0!
00)!
,7( 0>< )3 -,. , 0) (1 , 0 3( ,./ ,
!) 0,7 ( 3 .07 .(7 ,( / ,) ( 0,7 0) Page No.2
6) 0/ () 0, / ((6 9!, )/0 :!,( 0)8 ,) > 0)1. !.0(1 0 &,67/ 00) - /( A)1( ,61!)3)/ (3 ,7 / 0) /( A) , !8&
,( /0,.0 1 !) 0 :! , ),.
,( (1 ?.!
,-6, / ,) ,)(11,. 0)( 8,7)) 07(37 / 1( 4B)3 (3)1 0?, 3(1
71 0 (-) .
,(/ A/0,.0/ 1( 7 ,() 0 (,.3 (1 0 ,67 ) ) < <<< (-,)) 0,
(8), .( ,!) ( 0/ ,
0 () &/( A7 0)1,) ,. ,(/0 , 0 / ), 01.
0/
/ 8!
(, ) ,7',)0, / .( ,!) 1 (7< < B4= (; <<</, 0(!
36 & '
0 6- , ) !8&
,( 6, .
,., 3 0)8?7,) 0(/ 0/ /( A,6D
==5E& 7( 0, 03 <<<) !87,
0/ ,7
/ 0 8(! $(!
.7 0 .(.!
0 / )7,
,( !.0 6 ),6 01.
0/( A7/ /( A,6/,
0 &,67 0(!60
(8( ,7 '!
( (1 /( A7 ()!.)83 0.( )F (1 0,67 ?
&;E/ A ,7,))..( ),63/0, 3,6!( 0:!)67
), +7@+$+ #- 7 $ 7+. #7A#7+8!#$ 8"& 96& 7 6!"!$: 22! 7/ $";687!+. 7!<;$+. ;=+<#;7 #;78 +$" +$#8, 7/ 1
/ !5& +$+: 7 - $"!+ 66;7+$ #& 8"& 96& & (+$B+7.!$:+=/ 1 ( ?
) 88+7 +7@+$+ !C.! 9!87+$ Page No.3
!:+= 8"& 96& +,+";7:+7,/ !687! 8 ,+CC+7 96& $";687!+. 7!<;$+. ;=+<#;7#;78/ #,8+B+$"+$#8, 7/0 (?DD
/, / 0) ,7/( A 1,6/, 0, 0)1,, (1/( A7)0, 0)8 ),-,( ,((1 .
5&# (1 0 )!
, , !
.
B>= 1( 0( GB>= .
H )
0 1( 0, )1( ,
! 35<@8.A&/6 / (6 )1 (7 0) (1)7)( ,.) )<C <5 <<;/0, ).,),6 0 1 . =
,( $(! 1( 0 &,67'
! +,)0 ,) !( 0 :!)67
) , $ ,+7: 22! 7 +$" +$#8, 7 96& (,+$B+7(, 88@/0(D//0 ,667 (1),3 /6 0)88 (!60 (),-,( ,((1 .
,(5&#(1 0B>=
.
0 7(37 / ,, ,3 , 0 3 B=4 ) 0 /
)(<C <B B45 07
/ 1 ) 8(! $(!
/0,.0 0) ).,) ( , 1 0 ,) ( ) / ,) 83 0 )
,6+!)6(1F A,60$(!
), / 0) 0 (.)! 0)( 81((/) (-,))!) .
,(5&#(1 0B>= .
) ,
0) 8 ( ) ) 0 ,-, ,( .0 (1 0 F A ,60 $(!
0) ), 7,
0 ) ! 3 ? $(!
A,6,-,/ 0/,))(/,+:<!7(!$:,96&+7@+$+(8+8 :7! ;.8;7+. +7B 8!$:#+7"/0(?)( 0 .)
!.0 0) ,. 0 / ),3 /6 ) /( A) , 7,
3 8(!
53 8.A1 (7 0 ,()(1B=4 (B45( ) ) !7(1
A0 .(7 , , ( ( ,. , ,) . 0 /( A,6 ,() / 6,68 /5=)3 , 0,, ,3 /0,! (;;5 Page No.4
)3 , 03 B4<) 0 (.(7,6)(/ (5<)3 , 03 BB5 81( ,( ) 0 1( 0 7(! (1
A0 / / )) .(7
,7, 3 , ,+7+8 (+$ ,+7 !:+= !=!8 " 96& +$ (!$:,/( 0/( A70)/( A)/, 0 & ,67(),3/6 )! ,6 03 B4>&B45),)!
,), !
0) 8 , ) 1 5 3
! 3 !7 (1
A0 / / )) .(7 0 ()
/0,
,6 ,) 0/ ) (1 ,
/0,.0 0) 8 !0) 83 0 $(!
8(/ 66!68+$8$:!$ 7/ +C+68,+$ 5 .#A= $8#7A#7+8!#$+$"+$#8, 7 96&!8+=(!$:,/(D 0 / 667 (1),3 /6 1( 47( ) ,
).( ,!, 3(1 -,./, 05@ 8.A&/6 / 6 ) ) 7 / ,) 83 6 ,6 .(7 ,( (1
5<<<<E& / ..( ),630) 8(! $(!
0 (A,-,/ 01.
( 0 ! (17(37 ) 6 0(1 < 0 #! .0 (1 0, $(!
, ;$! !A+. #;$ !./ !$+ +:+7/ ,6!. !687! 8/ ;7"+6A;7 96& 7 6!"!$: 22! 7/ +<#;7 #;78/;7"+6A;7+$"+$#8, 7/ 1D/!
0( )83((1 !
, "
)0/,+ ( 0 1 .7)/0,.0/ ).,))83 A,6 01((/,6 0 9!
,7,)*& I , 0 0 0 ,., ,) )(/ ,
(1 F A ) ( 0 -
%7 -, ) ( 0 <<C >
$$ ,6 ((, (!8,. -,./(!)8 ,.8 /0, .( ,) ,6 ,
!)
0)!
,, !
.
B>=J Page No.5
,, 0 0 0 1,! ( 1, ! 0 !8,. (
, ..( ). /, 0 -
!
( 3 . !, ! ), /( A71( ,
J ,,, 0 0 /( A7 . 8 ,) .(7 ,( 1( / (61! ,( 11.
) , -,( ,( (1 .
,( 5& #(1 0 )!
, , !
.
B>= , ,! (1 ,
J ,). 0/( A7/ (, ) $ A ?7,,6 0:!)67
(1 ?$(!
,) ,, / 0)
0 ,
.(!) ( 8 ),) (3 ( 0 6 (!) (,
/ 7)83!8,.8(), 6,
!8,.(
)/ ( ,..( )./, 0 -
!
( 3 . !, !
1 0 0 8-,( ,((1 0 (-, (1B>= .
0 (-, (1 .
,(5& #8,67) ( 3 0 .07 / -(,) ,1, / - ,( ,( 0 1( 07(3/(!)8)7) (8.( ,!),
(/- .- / !
0 ,60 (1 ,
, ( !
(7 ,. ,60 !.0 ) - ,(!
.
0 ! (1 (, 0-,8,, 3(1(
0-,8,, 3(1/( A0 (8
0!8,.!
0( , , .(!)( .,7 ( ,77!, 3) ( .
1 (7 0 (-, (1 .
5&#)5&(1 0B>= 83 A,6 (
() 0,),6 07 - (..(! (1 01.
0(
/ ( 1,) ! , ..( ). /, 0 -
!
( 3 . !, !
! 3, / 0) (
,.
,60 :.A 1( 7!.(!)8,) )(/ 0 9!
,( / / ) ..( ),63 83 3,6 )(/ 1((/,6 ,.,
*& I>4KK 0!
01((/,6 ,., ,))(/*&
, F,6,-,/ 0 .(6, )(/ (1 0)!
, ,8! ( ), .
,
( ..(! (1 -,( ,( (1 .
,( 5&#(1 .
7 .( 8 Page No.6
),) (3( 06 (!) (,
/ 7) 83 !8,. 8(), 6,
!8,. (
) / ( , ..( )./, 0 -
!
( 3 . !, !
,, 0
) ( ,( (1 / 0 8 (!60 ( 8 ))
) 83 0, $(!
, 0 (-, (1 .
5,67) ( 3)(..(! (1-,( ,((1
7 0 .07 /(!)8-(,)8,, ,( ,1, / - ,( ,() 0 1( 07(3/(!)8 )7) (8.( ,!,6,
,,, 0 ,60 (1 ,
0(/- , ( !
(7 ,. ,60 !.0)/0,), .
,6 ,
8(! $(!
/, 0- A , ( .( ,) - ,(!
.
0 ! (1 (, -,8,, 3(1(
0-,8,, 3(1/( A/0 0 (, / ! )
!
( 3 (-, ) 0 6 0 (1 -,. ) 0 )3 , , ,6 ,)!
,), !
81( 3/ )(1 ,
.(!) 1((/,. (1 ( (, )( 0( 78 ) ),3 /6 ) /0( 0) ( /( A) 1( (6 ,()8!
(3(
6 0(10-,6.(7 )>< )3 /(!) ( 8 ) 1( ,
!.0- 0(!60 0 .07 / -(,)
,- 0 ,) .07 8,6 -(,) /(!) 0(/- ( 0/( A7 !.0 (9!,13( .,7 ,60 1( 6! ,L ,(), 0 83( ) (1 ,
0 7.3.(!)86 ,)7(3) (30/(!)80) (8 ),.( ,!(!
-,. ( 7
!
0 / /0 0, /
)
- 07(3 /(!)0- ,60 (1!
0 0,7 , ..( ). /, 0 / 83 .(73,6 /, 7) ( 3 (-, ) 0 7(3 0-,6 3 6 ,-.6,
!.0 ,(.(!).06
7,..( )./, 0/
-, 0 ), . ,( (1 0 )!
, ):!),. ( 0 0!
0- (8 .
)) ,) ):!),. ( 0 (A Page No.7
, 7,) 0 ,., ,) )(/ 83 ? $(!
( ,.)8(-
-,, )( ( !8 . ,8 0 -,/ 0 !8,. !
0( , , .(!).,7 ( ,77!, 3) ( .
,(1 (7
0 (-, (1 .
5&#)5&(1 .
83
A,6 ( () 0,),6 07 - (..(! (1 1.
0(
/ ( 1,)!,..( )./,
0 -
!
( 3 . !, ! ) 0 1(
0/( A7.(!)( .,7 ,
>B 0 1.
, 0, . )7(
0 (, / 1( 0( ,()) 0/( A70)(3/( A)1(
/(3 8!
0 ,
. /0,.0.(7 0( ,.(1
0, $(!
/( A7 0- .( ,!) 1( (6 ,() ) , (7 ,
. 1( ).)
0(!60 / ( ).,),6(7 ,
,. 0#!.0, (3 ().,) 9!
,( (1 1 . .,7) ) , !.0 ., .!7
. , .( 8 0) 7
(1 ! 7 3 8.!
(
/ ( 1,) , ..( ). /,
!
( 3 (-, 7( 3.(7 ,(/(!)8 0(3 / ) ,1 (1 ,
, ( 8 ),) (!
,60 3 0 )!
, ):!),. ( /,/3 A, (.( ,) 1.
0(!60, 0)(/ ( ,
8!
/0,,
!,6 3( 0 ), .
/0 , 6! ,L ,(, (8( ) )(
6 0(1 (7(,.3, /(!)/3 A,7,) / ,) )(/ 83 0 $(
!
,( .0 , %7 -,M .
! ) .
,3 !.0 ? ., , 0!
( 8 . ,)(!
, 01.
)., .!7
. (1.0. )(
,.
,60 :.A 1( 7! . 8 ,) )(/ ,
, (8), .
),. ( 0.( 3
( ..(! (1 -,( ,( (1 .
,( 5&#(1 .
6 ),6 0 (,
( !8,. (
.(7 /(!)8 0(3 7)3 5< -,/(1 08(- 07,/,6(8.A (M8,-, ,(.01( )., ,((7 ,
A,6, -,/ 0 ,., ,))(/8(- N Page No.8
0. (1,;7;=+.6;A7+ ( ,.)83 0 )
,6 ,(0) A.7( 03 8.A) /( A70)/( A)1( 7(
53 8!
0 / (), .
-,). ))(.!7
03 <<&<<), !.0., .!7
.
;A0 .(7 ,(/ ,)) / )(1 0 ,8!/ 7(),1,) ;
, ( ( ,.) 0 7(37 / 1( 7(
; 3 (?,7 3D
4<<E& 7( 0), 0 .(7( .( ) )7) 0) 8 , ) 1 ;O 3 1 (7 ,( ( <C <5 <<;
?! & 0 ,
6, 0 3 <>83 8(! $(!
1 ,()(13 /(!)( 8:!
,1,) ,-,/(1//0,.00 8), .!
)8(- 0 ) ,6+!)6 (1,) (A 0 1.
( , (7,)/0,7(),13,6) )!.,6
0 7(! (1 8.A&/6 0 ?
(1 ><@ , (, !.0 / ( ( 6! 8 .,7) ) , / )) 7 / ( ,7 D
4<<E& 7( 0 /0,.0 /(!)0-7( 0)(!8), !8 9! 3
> !.0 ., .!7
. A,6 , -,/ 0 (6 6 0 (1
-,. / (1 0 .( ,) ) (,,( !7 (1
=5<<<<E& /(!)8 0 ( , .(7 ,(D
C<<<<E& (?,7 3 3 A,6,-,/ 01.
)., .!7
.(1 0. ) 0/
0 ,
/(!)( 87
(1 ,60
01.
!7 /( A70,7 10)( ( ( , ,)!
,), !
1( 7(
; 3 /(!)6(( 0(/ 0/ /( A,6 /0 )! (/0,.0 0 ),) ( , 0, .,7 ?), ,(!
3 !.0 ., .!7
. Page No.9
,
0, 8
6( 7( ,( ,7),3 /6 /(!)( 8 0 ( , ,1 !.0 5 ! 3 0 , (/)) 0 & ,67, 0),8 (3
=5<<<<E& .(7 0/( A7 83/3(1)7)) 1 /, 0, ,()(17( 1 (7 0 ., (1 . ,1,).(3(1 0, ( ) . ,)7(! , ( ,)/, 0, . ,8) ,() 7 0. 3,
7 D4@ !7 1 (7 0) (1 0( ) , 0) (1.
!37 0/( A7 &(&()
*
) &&
0 0 A,6E ()* P ( 0 0 ( 8* P ( Page No.10