Roshan Lal v. State Of Haryana And ORS




   
   

 ! "#$  %

 % &'()(*"+"#, -

+.&#&/  011(//&#' 2(3+4+ 5'&'(&36&#&&#)'.(3+ 00 (+1#)(#'+   ,  7  5
 5
  7  5
5$


3(+(#', 3543"#)(3849&3&&3"&:);*&'(3'.(&11(//&#' <<<
   = >
#'3&?*43'&11(&/.&+@((#"/()&A&"#+'3)(3)&'()%

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

  

  @(+")(+:&11(&/&A&"#+''.(+&9(''.(99"++"#(3 /"*(: 434A3&9B&+)"+9"++();")(3)(3)&'()F  => .( $3"' 43' .(/) '.&' 13(9&'43( 3('"3(9(#' B&+ #' & 14#"+.9(#'#3"'"#;/;()+'"A9&.("#;/;(9(#''.(&11(//&#'"#& *3"9"#&/*&+(*&+'&)&3E&#)9"#4+)4@'#."+"#'(A3"'6@("#A&9(9@(3  &)"+*"1/"#()3*(: '.(3(3(: 13(9&'43( 3('"3(9(#'3)(3() "#'(39+ 

4/( -- """!'.(&36&#&";"/5(3;"*(+ 4/(+: &#) 4/(F

!

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

B"'#(++ .&;"#A )#( & *91/('( +9(3+&4/' B."/( &11(&3"#A "# '.( B"'#(++?@G 3 B."*. '.(6 .&;( @((# 13*(()() &A&"#+'@6'.(/(&3#()))"'"#&/5(++"#+4)A(4#)(35(*'"#--'.( 3 3.&;"#AA";(#"#'(#'"#&//6&/+(+'&'(9(#'+"#43'/(&)"#A''.( &*D4"''&/  '.( &**4+() "( &11(//&#' (+")(+: '.( *91/&"#' 143+4&#' ' B."*.'.(3&")B&+*#)4*'()&#)3(*;(3"(+('*9&)(B(3("#'.(.&#) '.(*91/&"#&#'&#)'.(*91/&"#&#'&#)+.&)BB"'#(++.&)+"A#()&//'.( 3(*;(369(9+ 3(;(3:'.(*91/&"#&#'.&)A'."

  

4#)(35(*'"# -3 B"'.3(A&3)''.(*91/"*"'6'.(&**4+()"('.( &11(//&#'"#'.(*3"9(:@4'+4@+(D4(#'/63(+"/()@6)(1+"#A'.&''.(+&9( B&+#'."+;/4#'&36+'&'(9(#' => .( &11(//&#' B&+ 13*(()() &A&"#+' )(1&3'9(#'&//6 3 ."+ "#;/;(9(#' "#
   )&'() % F 3(A"+'(3() &' /"*( 5'&'"# 5'&'( 2"A"/&#*( 43(&4: 434A3&9 4#)(3 5(*'"#+ %:  &#)   '.(

3(;(#'"#3341'"#*':

.(#D4"36 "*(3.(/)'.(&11(//&#' A4"/'6'.(*.&3A(+/(;(//()&A&"#+'."9/(&)"#A'"91+"'"#+'11&A(  'B 4'43( "#*3(9(#'+ B"'. '(913&36 ((*' ;")( "*( 3)(3 )&'()   11(&/"/()@6'.(&11(//&#'''.(99"++"#(3 /"*(: 434A3&9&A&"#+''.("914A#()3)(314#"+.9(#'B&+3(C(*'();")(3)(3 )&'()F  =%>
# '.( *"3*49+'&#*(+: B( &3(  '.( *#+")(3() ;"(B '.&' '.( 3)(3 1&++() @6 '.( $3"' 43' )"+9"++"#A '.( B3"' 1('"'"# "/() @6 '.( &11(//&#')(+#'B&33&#'&#6"#'(3(3(#*( = >

(+4/'&#'/6:'.(&11(&/"+)"+9"++()"#/"9"#(  !"#
$%     
   &%'!      &%'!

-

&9"'


$.('.(3+1(&E"#AH3(&+#() , (+H 
$.('.(33(13'&@/( , (+H