← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/8145/2014dismissed

Murti Devi And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-05-01Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal11 pages

 ! " #$%$&'( ) # ( "

 

 *+

( + 

 ,-(*-

..//

0 ,

1  2

 .

#+ 3'4!&$1 #! 451 !%4 % + 1%#6*

/7 1,- 6*

..// - 8 9

6::

::

  0-; #6* 1-56* %<6*

..// - = 

 1 -",.6"6 2 

    

    

 

    



    

 

 

     



 

  !    



" 

 # !   

 

 # 

  $% &'

 ( 

 )

 '

 

 & 

*

 +    # 

    ,-* 

  ./,  ) 

 & 

.

 +    # 

    ,-* 

  /, 0 !  +    # 

 1   





/2%  .-  + 

 3  4   !    )   " 0 (



 # 

  

 &  -0 0    " 0  '

6*,





 

  

  

  *     

     & 

 , 

   +  # 

 ,-*8   9,-* 9:+  # 

1   8   9+19:   

  1 8   919:!

 #     4         

     '

;  '

 "%) 

   "%&

 

  3

   #  ! +" "     

 

  



     &  4  <   '  1  

=     =   ;

      1   1  

 (  

(  &4< '  ( & 

  ( & 

)>3( & 

)31   ( & 

 "  





  

    &  (

  7?(

  &  %6

  

/ 5  " 

 #

 

   1   .

&  +1

  # 

 







     



 

 @/2% 

?00   /2%          

 !

?  

 

$% ( &)

( & ) (0 <

A (* B

 !  

                  

$% =?(  



-,6*.

=?(  



0.

=?(0  

&

*0--/ =?(*  



-*/.

=?(/  



,,0.

=?(.

 



*0/-.

=?(6  

 ,,.

=?(,  



,-./ =?(-  



0.*.

=?(  



-.-.

=?(  



/0.., =?(  



,..,06 =?(0  



/.., =?(*  



666..

=?(/  



*,..

=?(.

 

"

% 

=?(*2 

 

B

0  &? %' A 

   

     $% =?2 

 

' A 

=?  

 

2 * =?  

 

2 .

=?0  

   =?*  

 =?/  

(  =?.

 



,/, =?6  



-0/0, =?,  



-*6, =?-  



0.,*66 =?  



0/-6/6 =?  



*0/,/6 =?  



*6,,.

=?0  



*-00.

=?*  



*,600.

=?/  



,6*,/, =?.

 



-,0, =?6 & 

*     

             

 &    $% &'

=? ) &

 +  !

  (   (% *.

-,6 6A%0< .,-*/02% 02%  (% .

0 ,A%,< ./2% 02% (%0 -/ *0- A%< 66*06/2% -/2%

* (%* .

-*/ 6A%< -*/2% 02% / (%/ .

,,0 ,A%< 02% 02% .

(%.

-.

*0/ 0A%< ,,/2% 02% (%6 .

,, A%.< */6/2% 02% , (%, ./ ,- 6A%*< .//2% -/2% - (%- *.

0.

0A%< 0.2% 0*2%  (% .

-.- .A%,< .606/2% 02%  (% .., /0 A%0< .,2% ,0.-02%  (% 06 ,.., A%< *,*2% 0,62% 0 (%0 .., / A%< //,/2% ,0.0.2% * (%* ..

666 A%.< ,/2% *,**/62% / (%/ ,..

* A%,< 2% *2% 1/ ,>21+

 %.

, ,/ A%< */2% ,2%  %6 , -0/0 A%,< *6/2% ,2% %, 6, -* A%.< */2% ,2% * %- *66 0., A%< */2% ,2% / % 6/6 0/- A%< /2% ,2% .

% ,/6 *0/ 0A%-< ,,-2% ,/.2% % ,,.

*6 A%0< /,2% *0*6,2% , %0 00.

*- A%< /2% /2% - %* 00.

*,6 *A%,< /2% */*/*/2%  %/ ,/, ,6* A%.< .2% .062%  %.

00, - A%/< 062% 6/62%

:

/ !1

" 

 #    



 =?( =?(0  ? 

 ./, "  

 

=?( =?(0 !1

"   @ ,*.*002%!  /C 

  

 C 

 

D



 ! " 

@ 0-,/602%!1  " 



 



=?%. =?.   & 

/

,-* !1  

     

  

 +1# ? 



 0             

     

  0 !  4          

       

  

"



# 

  0 ! 

 

   



" @ 000/2% 

/.      # 

 &  %0 "

'

.-0

/8  !"# $%&'(  %#)*"

# $%' 

6  " 



  

@C

 

/, 5

&  %0   # 5        

             

0,  #       5  < 

=

!

   "       

    "    @ *,02%     '

0

.8++,$ &'(  %#)*"# $%' 

/ 00 ( 

      

       & 

;     

 

 &1 

$"&'(+##)"+ -../0123/       &    

 

  +1 

" 



        =?%

  

  #   

 =?,     

     

   #    D 

  +1

  " 

 #    

./,        ?   

  ./,   

    "   



     

  

  

" 

 #  *  

* ! 

 

  D   

 

   * 

 

     "  

 #   

 "

 ( 



 #  



  +%  "%)  

  &  "%&

  

    

 #  (%5

& 

0

,-* 

" 

 #  #  



 

 & 

*./,!

"





      

  

     # 

              1    

  

  

 

 

   ! ?   

  

  

           # 

        

 

"  5   !4'5'%'67 

"  

   

-C





    

 =? =?.=?0=?* =?,    

  

   ?  >

 # 

    &  %0 

 

/.  

     #  

    *2% ,2%  &=?%  6/6         

 "    



 #  5 

@ ,2%  &   



 =?%,     '

6-A '

5 

     #   ! 

  

  

 

  & 

*

,-*  

A .<  



 */2%      ,2%!



 =?.=?0 =?*

    

    # 

*0  



    

./,

  " 

 

 & 

*  

   

     "  

  



 !  =?( =?(0     

   ?  ? 



 

 & 

*

,-0   ;  

"



   

  # < 

=?( =?(0       

 0      .<



" 

  #   *,* #   ,A   "  

#   ./ # 



  



"  !&=?(    0/?0E0-0/

 

 =?(0    0/?E006/ #   ** ! #   5   

  #  */ & 

" 

0,

'

0

.

      

     #   

   

 < 

 

    



  



  

 ?   

  

"        

    *.

! &

;   

  " 

   1     

8#(29:#)-.--

*6 !1 

   & 

,%80:

,-* 

  

 & 

,  





!        

.*   

 

  1

*0*;

 

 

+1=? 

  

 & 

, 

* 

&'

0*-

*

6%&

4 &    

        



*  

*

& 

,  !    

 

     

                 

*   

   

 & 

,

.* *, 

     1



  " 

   & 

,80:

,-*  

&1  +##)"+ "# $%&'( "%%76!+"# $%'

   0//167%!%#6   --1/,   +1

1 



     

 & 

,

,-* !    

   



  1

     

  

 1

*0* /  

1(0  A        

  



/      

 

 



  451 !%4  &$("!

26

  ? .;-<@  + ) @ ?.>/ + ) @ '

,*/

* <)  

&

;   

'

,/*

* &"  

&

;   

'

*

.

&  

&

;   

'

,/.

* & 4 

&

;   

'

-0

0 3 4  



&

;   

'

../

, 3

 

&

;   

 '

..*

, &"& 

&

;   

 '

-,0

* 4&  



&

;  



'

,*-

* B @B & 

&

;  



'

,/

* & &  



&

;  



'

,*.

* '& 

&

;   

'

,-.

* <&  

&

;   

'

,*,

* &&  



&

;  



'

,/0

* B("  

&

;   

'

,/

* & A 



&

;  



'

,/

* 3  (

&

;   

'

,//

* A )  

&

;  



'

-0

* B  

&

;   

'

,*6

* < & @  

&

;   

'

6*,

 ) 

&

;   

 451 !%4  &$("!