High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/540/2018dismissed

Ram Kishan v. The Po Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court Hisar And ORS

2023-03-14Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan9 pages

!"! #$ !

" "! %!!&! #' $ !

$ !

! Decided on: 14.03.2023 !

" #"#"#$ ! #" #

$ ( )!

*+,-,./ )!

! ! ..0,-,./1 21 32 1 #' 215 2!

#' !

.00,-,./ ! ! )!1-$6 *+,-,./1 77777 "#"#&'()&*&+,&-"

*+,$.00,-,./ !! !! 8 ! 5 9 ":-6,;,-,.- ! .<1,.1-,./1 -1 5 9 ! = ! ! "! -01,/1-,., =

' !

! ! ! ' 1+* ,,,>

% !

! ! ! 16 *, ,,,> = =!

' =

!!+! 1 ! ! ?

*+,$.00,-,./$2 2 <@

! 8 =! !

! = ! =

!1 ! %

' 5 9 ! !

! =

=!,.1,61.;;.!6.1,61-,,6 ! = ! ' % ! 6.1.-1-,,*1 =!!

= ! '= = !!! !1

! )&.&/ #&'0)&. ,1&2 /(" 34" )5.52&+ #! !

! =

!% ! !"! = !!

1 61

!!3=!!! !!= =!

=!8 A = &! A

! ,.1,61.;;.1 % = !8 = ! !6.1.,1.;;; = 3 !% A%! &! B= !! !

!8 =!3 = "3 A ! ,.1,+1-,,6 = !!= ! '19 != !%

! ! '

=! ! %

! ! "!1 +1 ! 5 = !=!3 ! ! ! ! = ' = ! ! C! 1 &!

= !!

= ! ! ' = !8 ! 6.1.,1.;;; ! =!3 )!%

.;;+1 *1 !"! ! =!3

! ! ! %

*+,$.00,-,./$2 3 % !

! ! 1 ' ! ! !

! !! ! ! ' =!3 ! =!3 ! '

.;;- ! .;;+

! !

% = = ! =!

% 1 = ! = !! !'

!%! ! !

! ' ! !

! '

! 8 !

D "! &16,. #,'1) 34" &.7&'& #/&/8 1.,05+/5.8 &.98/,'1 :&.( &':/)8.-;#< #8',:.#5=8.,'/8'(8'/8+81.&=).&>>,0 ):=&+34"#&'/:4)%52&.#8&+ :/)8.4-?#< "

" #/&/8.&44*&.8:.=:.&/,:'/(" &':/)8.34" (&7&.&,' &'(&7- ?#;! !

! 1 <1 &! 3! !

=!3

! D ! ! ! 2

! !! ! !1

! 8 !

D"! "

"8++&//,34")844,4/&'/@805/,A8'1,'88.-? #?1 % !! ! 8 ( E.*1 'C ! !!

!%! ! F% ! !

' !

5 ! ., ! A 1 #!=

! ! 8 = !

'3 % = ! !!! !!= =!3 ! -+, ' % '

1 ! ' ! =!3

= !D1 ! =!3 ! %

!! ! '1

! ! ! !'= =

! !

! ! 1 =!

*+,$.00,-,./$2 4 ! !!! ' 1 ! =!3 ! ' ! !'

! !

! ! ! ! %

! !

= 1 A= !% '=!

! ! 1 ! != 3 % ! %

>=!3 = ! !

'=! =!3 ! !% =!3 ! -+,' % '

1 8 '!= !

!! ! !

=! ' !

! =!3 = !

! ! != % 1 '

8 ' !=

# "! --< ! "! ! = ! = ! ! ! ' ! ! '

% 1 =

! ! 1 .<1)!=

' ! ! !

= =!3

= !D1# ! ! ! ! ! !

!! !--1..1.;//!-,1<1.;;+1

! ! ! FD1:. !

1FD % F

1 %

! !

! 1 ! % ! !)2 !!=6)2 FD12.

FD12- FD126 ! ! !

!1 % )2 ! = FD12+ FD12* = =!3 =!3 !+6'

! -.1.1.;;+ ! -,1-1.;;+ -.161.;;+ ! -,1+1.;;+

% '1 ! ! ! !=' !

! ! != ! ! 1 !!' ! !

FD1:.1 #"! 8 ! % ! ! 1 = % = %!

! #"!! ! !% = ! ! ! ! ! ! ' 8 % !

*+,$.00,-,./$2 5 01<1-,,, =

! !1.0<6< ! -,,,1 !

= ! ! =!3 ! '! %1# ! ! %

!! 1 =!3 ==!3 5A.

FD1:.= ' ! 1 FD % F

A "! ! A%! )!1.

*;.6,+1

! = ! FD1:. !

! --1..1.;// ! -,1<1.;;+ =!3 ! =!3 '= ! '

!1 !

= ' ! ! !

! ! ! !! %

! '= =!

!! !1:

! 8 ! ! 1:

! ! = ! % 1

= % = =!3

= !D =!3 !-+,' % '

! FD1:.1 %!

! #"! = ! !1G 01 #!= ! A

! % '

= %' 3 ' ! =!3 !

!!.;;-!.;;+!= '

! !"! ===!!! !!= =!3 =!3 ! ! !2 .;;- =!3 9

.;;-15'

.;;6 =!3 &

.;;6 !=!3 2 .;;615'

= 3!9' ! .;;6 ! !

)!%

.;;61 = ! ' '

.;;+!&

'1 ! 5 != =!3 ! '6.1.-1.;;; !8

! ! 6.1.,1.;;;1 /1

= ! ! !

!D '/'

= =!3 !! =!16 *, ,,,>=

*+,$.00,-,./$2 6 8 !

! 1 ! !' ' = ! ! ! !! == !

=!8

! = !% ! 3

1 = ! ! !

! !

%! &B 5',0,=&+:5'0,+-,'&&1&.- 8)4,+ ,4/.,0/ 5.(&4=5. 34" .84,(,'1 >>,08.- &6:5. :5./- 5.(&4=5. &':/)8.- ? ! ' !

! 41515 =91 =!

% !! != ( E+/

1 !!= != (

% = ! != ! ! ! ! ! %!! !5 ! -*&! !

! ' ! !

! ! = ! ! = % !' 1 !! ! =

! !

'"! !%! !5 ! -* &

!' ! ! !%!! !

%! != !

! 1 ! != ! ! = ! "!=% !3 !! ! %!

! !

% '! ! % ' ! =!3 =

!' !%! ! '

' = ! ! !!= !

! ! ! ' = =! ! =!3 ! !

! ! ' ! !% ! -+,' =! !

*+,$.00,-,./$2 7

! ! =%!1 %

%!=! != !

=!3 !H'!! C! ' ! !

! !'

! ' =!

! ! ! == = 1 % !'

=! % ! ! = = ' ! ' = !' !%! !'

% ' % ! ! ! ==1 % ! ! 8! % !

8!!3

D"! ! 1 %:

! !

! % = ! !! ' ! ! ! !%! !5 ! -*& -*B! 3 !! % ! ! ! != ! ! = % !'

=!3 ! ! 1 +;1 !

=! !

! =!3 ! '=!3 !=!'

= ! ! ! ! "! =!3 % ! !!

! ! ! 1!= ! ! & ! ' ! H ! ! !

! '

!= ! ! = !'

!%! !

! =!

! ' = ! !

!'1

8!=='3 !! ! ! != ! = ' ! ! = C! !

! ! ! !

*+,$.00,-,./$2 8

=! =' 3

= != ' "! ! B I A %J '

! ! !83 !

!= !

!! ! ' ! ! ! %!! ! 5 ! -*& !

! ! !

! =!

! ' '1G ;1

% = !' = = !

!8 = ! ! !

! =' ! =!3 ! !% ' !

1 ! '

= !

! 5 9 8 !

! !

! ! ! =!3 ! ! / '

1 = ! !

! ! = =8

! !

= 3 ! =!3 =! ! ! ! ' ! =

== ! ! 3

5 1 .,1

! 8 !

D"!

)&.&/#&'0)&.,1&2/("34")5.52&+-#1 ! % =!

D"!! !

! !!

! &.7&'& .6&'8A8+:=28'/5/):.,/7 34" 2 &+-#= 1-* ,,,>= ! ! !

= //&.&'0)&+ :.84/ 8A8+:=28'/ :.=:.&/,:'34" "":4),-;#<< !

!!-'

!10* ,,,>= 15'

44/"'1,'88.- &B&4/)&' 8A8+:=28'/ :.=:.&/,:' &':/)8. 34" ,/&2 #,'1)- < #

*+,$.00,-,./$2 9 ?;

% ==!!= = ! =!/ ! !

! !1*, ,,,>= 15'

&'&1828'/-,'(54/&' &0),'8::+4/("34")&'4)7&2#)&.2&- # !

!!!

! !1*, ,,,>

1 %"3"',+ ,/).& &':/)8. 34" #.88 #&'9&.&0)&.7& ',A8.4,/7:>#&'49.,/ &':/)8.-# !

!! !% +'

! = =1- *, ,,,> ! 3= ! *,@ = = ! '

! 1 ..1 ! 5 ! !

! =! ' 3

% = 'C ! =!3 !!% /'

!!!= !

! !

! '! !

! ! ! ! !1 ! ' ! ! ! !

! 5 9 1 .-1

% =! !

1 "#"#$ "<"<

3 > !

( K >)! :

! ( K >)!