State Of Haryana And Others v. Gulab Singh And Another
!
"# $% #&'('$) **+
,# -""# $% ./ ",.$01, .'&'23 -#&.#"./4
$.#("
#2."5#"4 '6'3 -#&.#".'"4 ,'1., $",#.
******22#33"( 7(* 038 -'1, $",#.
********* #(2$#"( ++9 :
,# -""# $% ./ ",.$01, .'&'23 -#&.#"./4
$.#("
#2."5#"4 '6'3 -#&.#".'"4 ,'1., $",#.
***22#33"( 6(*
$",#.
;* #(2$#"(
) < *
- *-* - = < -*
- >
=
!" ##### >
=4
* $
"% ""! ""&!!'((') !* +,-./0,.1$2 038 -'1, 6(* ,# -""# $% ./ $",#.( +,--..,.1$2 6(* ,# -""# $% ./ $",#.(4 "!
"3 $&!!' (') ((.4 .1$6" " 7 , (,% &!! 8 9)1- .1$/ * !!("3 $, (& "") 51: ,! (! ;
! !" !7 "
$-26&! !'
!$-26') .
!! ! "3 $, &% ,552,.1$0)((<, (, = >?!! & ) > !1$ 1$ .112 ( (($4 1$ .11- ="3 $, & % ,.//4,.1$6)((<, (, (" !
.6 $$ .11$ ( 10 1/ .11- <" ( (".21 " ( ( "(! ( ("" .5,>! !$-26
/
"
! (( ( "!" "!!
* "",>
"( " ( " (
+ !! ( !! (" ' 7 * (((" (! ( ! " 7 ?!! ! ("!
"" """! " ((" ! !" ( (( * !
! (( ;
% ! @(! !(.115.110! (("( .11$.112 "
$
* !
( !( ( "> "(!(!" "((" ! ( ! ! " 7!
! " (
@ ( @ !"( *
!("" !! " ( ("(! ( !" ((
.
* @ (A !(1$ 1$ .112$5 1$ .11- " " > " A ((
/
"!( ( !" !! .4 1- .1$. ! @" @(((% ( !((" ! !!! * " ;
! @(! ("!(.115.110 " (".21 (" !(* .11-" < """ ! ! * !((" ! ! ( ! "!("("" " ! .5,> ! !$-26 ", ( ,
51:
% !"", ( " ", ( (" (" ( "( ( ", (" " * ! (( ""! ( "" 7 ( " (" (".21 " !( * ! ! (( ( "% " !(51: ! ;
!
? "" ! ", ( (" * ;
!
! (!
( ( !51: , (
+ ! (" "",
* ;
! "" " "! ! ((" (" B
9 ( ! ! " "( ! ( ( !
(( (;
!( A ! " ! (("
! !" (" ;
! "" ! " " ! ! (* " !
(!!! ("( ( ( ", !
1$ 1$ .112 $4 1$ .11-", !
.6 $$ .11$10 1/ .11- ", ( (".21$.
( " ( ; ! , " ! (" (( ! ( = " " ;
( ! "@ **!#33""'
7(* ,# (('(""
?#&0"'6# 1'##. .114&$)
$14 =
8$5 C ! " !B (""" $1! 7 "
"" " "!;
(! " !"! ( ! .21
" (""@ " ( ( 7 ! ( !
!!
: ""(( " "! ! "( ( ( & () "("" ! (( ! " !""((! ! !
( "!! ! ( (!! ! (( (D ( !! (! ! " (" !.21 ;
(!
(," !( " "! "" ( ( ! ! (( % ;
( " "( ..4! ! !!! " @ " "! ! -
7 "
( "( (" ""((" " ( 7 ( A !( ( ! ! !(E ! !""( !" ! ""( " ! " !
A ! !( ! !"""(
! A ! ( 7'> < ! Municipal Council, Dina Nagar, Tehsil & District Gurdaspur vs. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Gurdaspur and another 2014 (4) SCT 514, !" "!( (" (
.5,>! " ""
, "Thus the following principles are laid down:- (i) Keeping in view the recognised power of the Industrial Tribunal to direct reinstatement on account of the violation of Section 25-F of the Act the same cannot be denied solely on the ground that appointments were made by public bodies against public posts and were not in accordance with the relevant statutory recruitment rules.
&) "! " ! .5,> ( ! !( ( ! "!(" (
&) ! ( ( ( % " !""( ! " ! ""(" " ! "
! !( ! !""" ( !" ! (" .21 "!( ( & ) (
@ ( A ! (! C!( "( (" ( ( & ) (" !
(( (" (" (" ( ( & ) !7 ;
" ;
" (" " "@ $1
F" ! !" "" " " "(" "(" ! " "( ! (" ;
! !
((
$$
7(!(! (! (" "( (" !" ! .5,>! !$-26 ( ( ( ! ! .&)! !$-26 , 8* #%''"'$( ,7 "
; @,, @@@@ @@@@ @@@@ @@@@ G&)8 (9(( ("! ! (!
"
(! ! " ,, &) (! (H &) (! ( ! " ! !("( (" ( "
!H &)(! ! ( !,! !("( (" ( @"! ( "
! HI & )(! ! ( ! ,HI9 $.
7 1#5#"4 '0(" &,'# $$3( "*
,(,/5
-,.5.1$0&$0)
01!"!1$ ("!51111D,>*7*'3 '",. $",#. -.## -A.&,./ '6#.('"/ $% -(A.'"
$",#.
.1.$&2)
2$5 ! (" !12 (" (( ("! .51111D, ( ! !( !
"! ("!/65111D, ! (, &"3 $% ,552,.1$0) ! 15 ;
A ! ( ! 541111D, ! (, &"3 $% ,.//4,.1$6) !"!
6J ;
A
$/
A "" ; ( "* .4 .1$6
(""", ("!1.
(!(! "! "! 7 ( """K0:" ( !(! ( "" !" !
*-* - =
>
=
#8.0./ 4 + +" L +=" L