High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1889/2015dismissed

Joginder Kaur v. Secretary Department Of Health And Family Welfare Punjab And ORS

2016-03-02Mrs Justice Sabina4 pages

!"# $#%&'&()!*%+

- ,

.&($#*/!0* 11#22!("

3#*'0'

#%*#"!*4,#1!*"5#(" #!2"+!($!5&246#2 !*#,

0(7!8!($"+#*'

#'1($#("'

) ) ) ) 9 : 9 : 9 : 9 :

*#'#(")

*#'#(") * #+!(,$;%!"#

*"+#!11#22!(" <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< ,

, 11#22!("+!$ &2#$'0&" *$#%2!*!"&(%+!22#(.&(.

"+#*$#*$!"#$ =

+#%!'# "+#!11#22!(",&(8*&# ,>!'"+!" '+# +!$7&(#$"+#'#*;&%#' "+#*#'1($#("'&("+#4#!* #1!*"5#("!2 1*%##$&(.' >#*# &(&"&!"#$ !.!&('" "+# !11#22!("("+#%+!*.#"+!"'+#+!$*#5!&(#$!8'#(" *5 $0"411#22!("+!$'085&""#$+#**#124""+#'+>?%!0'# ("&%#!($>!'!

*$#$1#*'(!2+#!*&(. >#;#*,"+# *$#*$!"#$ =

+!$8##(1!''#$>&"+*#;#(.# !""&"0$# #'1($#("' &( "+#&* >*&""#( '"!"#5#(" !;#**#$ "+!""+#!11#22!("+!$*#5!&(#$!8'#(" *5$0"4># -

"#* +2$&(. $#1!*"5#("!2 &(@0&*4!.!&('""+#!11#22!("!'1#*02#',"+#*$#*$!"#$

>!' 1!''#$, >+#*#84, "+# 1#*&$ !8'#(%#

*5$0"4>!'*$#*#$"8#"*#!"#$!'>&"+0"1!4!($"> !((0!2&(%*#5#("'>#*#'"11#$>&"+%0502!"&;##

#%" ("+#12#!$&(.' "+#1!*"&#', 22>&(.&''0#'

>#*# *!5#$84"+#"*&!20*")?

A 6+#"+#*"+#12!&("&

&'#("&"2#$""+#*#2&#

$#%2!*!"&(!'1*!4#$ *B

6+#"+#*"+#12!&("&

+!'%!0'# !%"&( *

&2&(."+#1*#'#("'0&"B

= 6+#"+#*"+#1*#'#("'0&"&'("5!&("!&(!82# &("+#1*#'#(" *5B

C 6+#"+#*"+#"&%#0D' &'!$5&""#$ 80"2#.!2&"4!($;!2&$&"484%+!22#(.#$B

6+#"+#*(%!0'# !%"&(!*&'#" &2#"+# 1*#'#("'0&"B

- 6+#"+#* "+# 12!&("&

+!' (" %5# &( "+# %0*">&"+%2#!(+!($'B

E 6+#"+#*"+#12!&("&

&'#'"11#$84+#*>( !%"!($%($0%"" &2#"+#1*#'#("'0&"B

#2&# F

!*"&#' 2#$ "+#&* #;&$#(%# &( '011*" "+#&* *#'1#%"&;#12#!' *&!2 0*" ;&$# 70$.5#("D$#%*## $!"#$ =

$&'5&''#$ "+# '0&" &2#$ 84 "+# !11#22!("?

12!&("&

+# '!&$70$.5#("D$#%*## 1!''#$84"+# "*&!2 0*" >#*# 01+#2$ &( !( !11#!2 &2#$ 84 "+# !11#22!("?

12!&("&

84"+#&*'"11#22!"#0*";&$#70$.5#("D*$#* $!"#$

C #(%#, "+# 1*#'#(" !11#!2 84 "+# !11#22!("?12!&("&

= +!;#+#!*$2#!*(#$%0('#2 *"+#!11#22!("!($ +!;#.(#"+*0.+"+#*#%*$!;!&2!82#("+# &2#%!*# 0224 +# '%1# 70$&%&!2 *#;&#> *#.!*$&(.

&("#* #*#(%# >&"+ 10(&'+5#(" *$#* &' ;#*4 2&5&"#$ +# 70*&'$&%"&( "+&'0*"&'(24"'##"+#5#"+$D5!((#* !>!*$&(.10(&'+5#("+#0*"&'(24%(%#*(#$>&"+ "+#1*%#$0*#!$1"#$84"+# 0(&'+&(.0"+*&"4 "+# 1*%#$0*#!$1"#$84"+# 0(&'+&(.0"+*&"4&'!%%*$&(.

"*02#'!($(!"0*!270'"&%#,"+#((&("#* #*#(%#>&"+"+# 10(&'+5#("*$#*&'%!22#$ *+&'0*"%!((".&(""+# 5#*&"' "+#%!'#(%!'#,"+# &($&(. "+#(@0&*4

&%#* &' 8!'#$ ( '5# #;&$#(%#, "+#( "+# 0*" %!((" *#? !11*#%&!"# "+# #;&$#(%# * >#&.+ "+# '!5# 2&G# "+# 11#22!"#0"+*&"42(.!'"+#*#&''5##;&$#(%#&( '011*" "+#%(%20'&(!**&;#$!"84"+#$#1!*"5#("!2 !0"+*&"4,"+#'!5#+!'"8#'0'"!&(#$5#$# #%"&("+# &(@0&*4+!'"8#1&("#$0"8# *#"+&'0*"%!(&("#* #*# >&"+ "+# 10(&'+5#(" *$#* 0*"+#* 5*#, & $# #%" &'

1&("#$0""+#("+#$#2&(@0#("#5124##+!'"'+>!'" >+!"1*#70$&%#+!'8##(%!0'#$"+&5(!%%0(" "+# '!&$ $# #%" +# 0*" #H#*%&'&(. 70*&'$&%"&( 70$&%&!2 *#;&#>&'(""&("#* #*#>&"+"+# &($&(. "+# !%"!**&;#$ !"&(!$#1!*"5#("!2&(@0&*4#H%#1"&(.&(!%!'# 5!2! &$# *1#*;#*'&"4

"+ "+# 0*"' 8#2> !

"#* !11*#%&!"&(. "+#

#;&$#(%# 2#$ 84 "+# 1!*"&#' ( *#%*$ +!;# +#2$ "+!", !2"+0.+, ( &(@0&*4 >!' 2&!82# " 8# +#2$ !.!&('" "+# !11#22!("!'5&(*1#(!2"4>!'&51'#$(+#*,80""+# *#'1($#("'+!$+#2$"+#$#1!*"5#("!2&(@0&*4!.!&('""+# !11#22!("&(!%%*$!(%#>&"+02#':#!*(#$%0('#2 *"+# !11#22!(" +!' !&2#$ " 1&(" 0" "+!" "+# $#1!*"5#("!2 1*%##$&(.'!.!&('""+#!11#22!("+!;#("8##(+#2$!' 1#*02#'("+#'#%&*%05'"!(%#',"+#0*"'8#2>*&.+"24 +#2$"+!""+#'0&" &2#$84"+#!11#22!(">!'2&!82#"8# $&'5&''#$!'0*"+!$(1>#*"*#;&#>"+#&510.(#$ *$#*1!''#$84"+#*#'1($#("'!

"#*+2$&(.&(@0&*4!'1#* 02#' '08'"!("&!2@0#'"&( 2!>!*&'#'&("+&'%!'# >!**!("&(.&("#* #*#(%#84"+&'0*" &'5&''#$ !*%+

- !*%+

- 5!+!;&*