Inder Singh Etc v. Hatti Singh & ORS




    
    
  

  !"" #   $ %

'( !

(&)'(("*


( & ++ ,,

- &) .

""

'(

( & 
+

 
  

  !"" #   $ /""

'( ++ ,,

- &)   .

&0

( & 
+

1 

  !"" #   $ .

""

'(

( &  "" & - &)   .

&0

( & 
+

    



 &  # &2 '& 3 4!

 &(  ++ ,,

% 


   &5&"/

&6 )("73 4!

 &( + "" & %   && +

 % 
   && +

1 % 
   & )& 8(2"& &323.

&0

&& +

 1%   && +

 

% 


   &5( '"

'(3 4!

 && +

 %   


 

50("/) ':

3


  

  ( ,,

"+  ( + &" (  "+) 

,:!::

"+) ""

!

!



  !" #$!!% &

:+ "

'  "

 &     ;   +)&!(  &3    ;( +)&!( ( 0 &

 !

;(+)&!( ( 0 & $ & <)"& 8 

/) "!

)+ =( + "" &( 4 ", (";&"+ ""  7"

'")

! 

 ;&"    ! &"& &"  &  <) ("

'    & &  +   80  (   , :

::"" !):

+)0::"" &3:8

  

,  &

  1

>)& 

 3& + !"4 ,0 5 &  "!)"

'( : &"

: &"( !:+ "

+ &" 3";), 8  ++&+&"

  "!  8&" 8 !7'&)

( !

 

"+, !

 & :+


( 8","

!3 ( &  & 8 &  && ?( ! @;

!

& , :

( !, ":

;((

:"'&

%

&:(  ;("!( ;&:+ &  7"

* '", )& +&4"

( + & ;(( 4 ,( "&,

& ( &"::4 8, +&+ &0 !!) :"'& ;), 8 &  , A& 8  & &! :

( !3(  ,24 & :

:

( 
), "  (  "+, !

  &   :+


( 8","

 
), 3   ( & "

 &8 &  && ?( 
),  @":),

),03(  :"

"& B4 !) &+ &0!3 ;

,

!

3 !, &"

! & +&+ &" 8  4 !) ;("!(;

;

80+ & ;((

:"'&

 7"

&:(  ;("!( ;&:+ &%

, 

!,  4 !) +&+ &03; &  ,, (  "+, !

+ & ;((

:"'&

&:(  ;("!( ;&:( + &  7"

 &(  , :

( !, ":(  "+, !

+ & 3(

)&+,)+&+ &0;("!(;

, );

'"4 (   24 & :

)

&(  !7 ' 

,=("+&+ &0;

,7 ;

( )&+,) !) +&+ &0A&( :

' :

(  &  )&+,) 4 !) +&+ &03( +,"!0 !"" ;

( "

&)!" ; & ") 80 (   ) / 83( ( /"

) / 83;("!("

!,)   ) / .

&0

3.":

!( ,

,("=(  ; & 7 ;

( 
), A& ,  )&+,)
)& ,&+ &" 3 ( & "

 &8 &  && ?( 
), 

@ + &( 
),  3(  7+, ! "

( 0

%

'( & +

( & "

;

!, ("'( 8"

;"(& + !( ,

:

)&"

'7

, :

&, "

!,) '( ,

!:+&" 
!

', 36( &  C1& 7

,:

&,  )&)

(  &  3%

'( +"

(  "&  ! "

" 
3 C

(  , ;

! "&:

 &! "&:

(  , 3( ;

&&

+ " ; & ")

%

'(;

+) + " ( +&+ &0, 

",0 &0
+& ;

&"

  $  8 &  (   ": 0    (   :   .; 4 &3  (   ! &""!

 ;

") 80(  )(&"" ;("!("( :

&  ;(0 (",""'

&" =("+&+ &0" !:+&" 
!

', 3 6( &  C17

,:

&, ;

 !  +) , ';"( ! & ( &,

( ;&"+ "" &.

""

'(

( &;( &  ,,  (D ""

'(+)&!( + ( , ( 0 & $ =(

;

! "&:

(  , ! &""!

 ;

,")  4)& .

""

'( !



=(  "+)  &   ( 

3%

'(!, ":

( ( 8  &&"'(8 "

' +)&!(  &+&"&"

+"

": 3;( & 

( ( &(

3.

""

'( !;&"+ "" &!, ":

( 0( +)&!( ( +&+ &0 , 80(   "!"

,

 , ! &""!

") ( "& 4)&.

""

'( ! ,!, ":

( 0( 4 8

,"4 & + " ( ,

! ("! &4 &0!

: (  "! ( "!"

,3( 0 ):)&  && ( :

 &(  , :

::"" !):

+)0 ::"" &3:8 &

/) "!

=(  , :

::"" &4"

& &

  ( ( , %

'(( 8  &&"'(8 "

'+&"&

+)&!(  &

3( & & 3: & ,08 !

) (  , ! &""!

") &+&+ & &0(  , ( 8 :

( & 4 ) & !& 3( &"'(%

'( & )+ &"&( &"'(.

""

'( ! =("& &")

&!( ,, ' "

( +&  ;&"+ "" =(")&( ( ( ,

!)  ,&( + &" 

'(

;"(( "& 8,  "

! ' (&)'(( + + &87

& , 4

+&4"" ( !

( 
), 3 ,( +,"!0 !"" *

!)  , ++ &"

' 8 ( ,( + "" &;(", :

7"

'&  & ! ( )8
),  
),  ( 
),  3( )8:"

 ! (  , ! &""!

8 ") 3 , "

 4)& %

'(;

!:+,  . ( ,&  && ( 4 &")/) ':

+  80( )&"

 &+& "

' ;( ( ", +  )

&( 
),   . )&( &)8:"

+ &( 
),  ( 
),  3 (  , :

80+)8,"! !), 8 <) "

;"("

0&:(

 (  !! +

! ( 8"

( +&  !

 3( +; &(



 > &!" 80(  , :

::"" &  & + &"  0 & .

! 3( & &","

8, 8   "

. )&( &)8:"

%

"

'((

!( ,, ( 

3( & & 3(  + &:

"!"

,

(

0,!)

". )&( &)8:"

 "! 8 & + "

'( ":+)'

& &;

+ &

,,0 &4 )+ ( + "" &.

)8:"

(  "! " ,, '

( 4 8 ") .

""

'( ,0

;"()")"

' "! ( & +)&!(  &3( & &( 8

+  %"( !

 .

""

'( ,(  "! ;

& ! "4 ( ( &(

3,

!)  , ++ &"

' 8 ( ,( +&"4  & +

%

'(( ;

( 

( )&( & &+  80(  , :

::"" &;("!(& !& ( ( ( 8(( + &" . )&( &)8:"

( +&  !

 3(
),  ;), 4   ++,"!

( +&+ &0;

( )&+,) 4 !) +&+ &0)

&( "

&)!" ;("!( & 7 ;

),  . )&( &)8:"

( +&  !

 3( & "

"+) ( ( +&+ &0;

+) 80;

0+)8,"!

%

&  "

'(  ;

  !,  ("'(   8"

&  =(   ,  "

 ("   4)&  ;

++&4 80( !:+ )(&"0

%

'( +"

(  "&

:)   .  )8:"

 (   ( &  &  4  (  + "  ;

,"4 & .

! 3( )8:"

( ")

! (  , ! &""!

 ;

,0(  > !)"4  ! + &( +&!

)& , ;

( 
),    ),",,

", +   %

'( *

  )  ,( ,

+ (  &'):

(

!)  ,& +&  '( +&"4  & +

%

'( %  (  +&    !

 3  ( &  "    "+)  (   %

&  "

'(



+)&!( ( +&+ &0"

"+) 80;

0+)8,"! %"( !

  (  ( +&+ &0" )&+,) 4 !) +&+ &0

3( & & 3( +&!

)&  +& !&"8 ( 
),  ;), 8  ++,"!

8, 

( )&( 8 ;

( 
),  $( 
),  ;("!( :+; &(  !& &0
( 8","

+ &:

!

,,&& !& 

!

 

0": +

'& !"

+ )!(& & ( :

0 :"

!!&

! ;"(; ,, , , ;
),  $( 
),   " >& !

)

&#

  

 





      

     

  



 



 



    

   



 

  



    ! 



    

 ! 

    "

%:

08  "!

( + "" &( 4  ", +&4 (

(  ;

!

)!

)

&(  
), 

)

&( ) /  !7 ' 

,&+ &"  "+ ,
), 3 ",,)&( &3 + & !"

( ! 3("  , :

::"" & ,( ":", +; & % ( +&  !

 3 ") 8 !&

)  &&& ( ! ! &

"!"

,

;+ & ;(( 4 +)&!( (  :

+&+ &0 & 8 "

':

&) &( "&&"'("

( +&+ &080,""'

'"

)&.; 4 &3"

( +&  !

 3( )&"!

,, )+  !"

;( ( 8  &&"'()+ &"&&"'(.

! 3, '(0 &'):

&  80 ( ,

!)  ,&( + "" &  !( "!

,"" , ;  

":+& (")&+ &( 
),  3( +&!

)& & , ( +&+ &080+)8,"! 8 +& !&"8 
), ( 
),   8&  ,0

,;"(( +&!

)& & , ( +&+ &03! "&:

( &  !! +

! ( ("'( 8"

( &  &")

! (  ! &""!

 .; 4 &3( ")

! (  , ! &""!

 "

 > !)"4  !

(  )(&"0

8 ! (  , ! &""!

 3";), 8 !&& !

! !,) ", ( +  =( ", 3"

( ! "

+"

 ( )&+  (  +)&!(  & (  ++&4 , , 80+)8,"!

+"(  , ! "

 ! 3", (

+  %

"

'(3

0)8 <) ) , (  , "

 4)&%

'((

!

! ,, 3;), 

4 & ,0  !( &"'(%

'(=( &"'(.

""

'( !;), 8 )8 &4"

( &"'(%

'( =( +&!

)&  +& !&"8 
), 

$( 
),   >& !

)

&#

  



 

   

 # 

         $%     

             

  )!

  



 &'

  *



  



     

     

    



          

     

     

        

  * !   *       + 

 ,      

    ,          

  &'

    



 ! 

-      



!   



   

     

                      



$

     

 

     

 

 

    

           *

  



 +      

  . 

     !  & '       



 )

) /

  0

 

         

  

!  

 



   





   &'





 1      .

 

              

  &'

2!        

  ,  

 !   . 

    

 !  

    &'

  +           

 

     



    



  &'

+    



 

   

    ,  



   

 



   





     ,

  

 !   

    

  ,       .     

 

 

          

   



 

    

  

         . -334%

  . 

  

 5 6-      

    0

  

  





    %   ( 

 

    %  

!    ! 

 

    

 



 

 

    ,      

!

        *



 



    ! 

  

    

 .

             



  

  7&'(    *

 + 

        

  



     



 2! 

  

 



          

    (     *

       



 0     

            *

          

    (

 &  '

  

    *

    

              

    

    



   *



      

  

  

  8   + &  '

  !





.   

  -       .   





1    *



 .  



   

  

  

       .

    

   

  







 9 0  

  

     

   

   %

6

8 ! 

 

  

 

 

!



   :     

 

       )!

   

  

      !    

'   ()*+(,-  #  .

//(//* 0  102  *//3(  #  /1)(  2((2   0+(-104(  2((25 #      

   

    ;    

 





     !

 

  

 1



    

<         

 4 !

 

     +       



     "

=(")&  &! "

( :

 &"

( : & ,0 8 !

) (  , ! &""!

8 ")  4)&%

'( !

8  '&)

"'

& (  , "

 4)&%

'( & '

,":"

3
),  $( 
),  !, &,0 +&4"

( !:+ )(&"0( +; &!

,,&( & !& 

!

 +

'&

/) "!

!"

(  : "

!!&

! ;"(, ; & '

(  &'):

( ,

!)  ,(  "!

8  &4 ( + "" &3":

08  ,,( + "" &  D ""

'(& "

-",, ' 6&;

6()& 3= (", &(3

"&"!:8

+ &( & +&)8:"

80( "!"

,;(4""

( 4",, ' "

& & &4  "!  ( + "" &3+ "" & ;

)

& "

' ( -",, ' 6&;

6

"

-",, ' 6&;

6()&

( ;

 &4  "!  .

""

'(;(  &&

'(  :

& )  7 (  "! 

3( & & ( ;

!:+ ,, +  (

"!  ( () .

""

'(=( & +&)8:"

80( "!"

,;( 4""

( " " >& !

)

&#

 

  0!

 =   > > 

 5  

  4?



 

 

 

     !  

>  > 

  0       =    >  > 





  * 1  >



!

    

  4?



     

   1         * 1   0

         

      @(0>



 4%& >

'  * 1  6338 +4(

 &  '<   ",,  )&( &3    "!

84 3  ,

  , :

::"" &"

( ":+)'

& &( + !""!

,,0& !&

8(( + &" ( 4 8 =(")&3"

0!

 3( '"4 ++&) "0 ( + "" &  8,"(( "&)+ &"&&"'( !:+ ( %

"

'(;("!(( 0( 4  ",   8,"(.

! 3(")&   "

( + "" &( 4 )+ &"&&"'( !:+ %

'( *  &'):

( ,

!)  ,&( + "" &";"( & + !( ,!)

"( "!"

,& +

%

; &

4" ;( 
),  $( 
),   =(")&"! !")(  !( ( + "" & &  

),=( 0( 4 +)&!( ( +&+ &0"

+ +)8,"! % )!( !"&!):

! 3 "& !" "") ( !:+ )(&"0"

"0 ( )&+,) 4 !) +&+ &03" ", 8, 3 ,:(  <)"4 4 ,)

,,(  : ( + "" &.; 4 &3" <)"4 ,

"

", 8, 3  (  "!"

,  & +

  ( ,,  8  ,"

8,   & )

 (  :)

& +&  '( +&"! ( ,

3 ;( & ( 8 !

! ,, " 

:

)&"

'7

,:

&, ( + "" & , ';"("

 &    E+ &:( 

 + 0:

",,& ,"F =(" > &!" 8



!:+, ;"("

+ &" (& : (&:( 

 & ! "+ ! &""

!+0( & & % 4" ;;( 8 8 &4 84 3( +&  ;&"

+ "" 

"+ 

 6 6 #$!67 &

%

'(""

++ , ( /) ':

+  80(

A"&++ ,,  )&& 4 &"

'( /) ':

( &"

,)&

(  '&)

 (   (  ;&"  + ""  !( ,, '"

'  (  & &  +   80 (  , :

  ::"" !):

+)0  ::"" &3  :8

  "+

' ! (  &  ;&"+ "" 8 !"

3 ,0'&)

&& 4 & ,( /) ':

+  80( A"&++ ,,  )&( !

  >"%

'(( 8 ( , ", ( ,

!:+&" 
!

', 36( &  C17

,:

&,  =( /) ':

( A"&++ ,,  )&"  "

  (  &"

,  )&  "  & &   .

! 3  (  &  ++ ,  "  ,,;

!!& ',0

 %6! #$!67 &

=(" ++ ,( 8 +&  && 80+, " /""

'( /""

'(!, ":( ( ( )+ &"&&"'(8 !

) ( 

8 & (":3(" ( &;

"

+ " ( +&+ &0

3( & & 3( , ( +&+ &080;

0+)8,"! !

&&"

)80( +)8,"!

)(&"" "

 4)&

1 "",, '

, *

&"

,)&  & ++& !"

'(  4"

! 3 ":"

( )"<) !, ", 80+, "!, ":( ;

&("+

+ " 3(; 4 &3,

&"

,)&'&

,":"

& ," (

;",, "+  +, ""

) !)& , ;8 "

'"

+ " *

A"&++ ,,  )&(  4 & 4 & ( + &"

& ," '&

+, " ( ")

8 ( 4"

' &"'(3", &  & "

( +&+ &0 *

!)  ,&(  ++ ,,

/""

'((

:

"

! &

 :++)&)

(")&+& !( "

 & +, " /"

"

'(

++ ,,

( & "

(" ++ ,3(; 4 &3,

!)  ,!), 8,"(( + & ;(""

)

)(&"F + " ( +)8,"!

+&+ &0( )+ &"&&"'((

(  +)&!(  &+ & ;((

 + " )

)(&"F ,0"

 +)8,"! +&+ &0!

 !, ":

)+ &"&&"'((

(  +)&!(  & .

! 3(" ++ ," !!& ',0 ":" ,,( +

':"! ,,

) ++,"!

3"

03 &  "+ 3"

4" ;(  84  /) ':

6!6$$!6'






 

8(98(,/.(1:*0;<,(1/ 0(25 (/<

8(98(,,(.

,91=)(5 (/<