← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1935/2015allowed

Daulat Ram & ORS v. Gopal Krishan & ORS

2018-03-26Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages

      

!"# $#%&'&() *  + !,-!"!.!($"/#0'

11#--!("'

2#0',' 1!-30&'/!(!($"/#0'

#'1($#("'

)4 5 65 

 

  

658 0!-

 

    !"

!# $!%& '(  ) $& !$ $!%%  (  (   (' 

  *         

 ''%+&  , -  ./ %% $!!"  (0 % 

1 2/ %% $!!" ('   (  ((('   12( (      '0 %(  ' ''(     

3' ( 40 % %5 % $!!5   %!6%  0 $"'' 1  $6%$ 0 5/ $ $!!5  40 5'1 8 ' 0 /'9'

  1  (6

  ('  (   ( (('   . '  (   (  : '/ %% $!!"    ;

%% $!!" <  .0 %

 ')   '  

% 2/ %% $!!"  : 2  = 0 % >.4 $ 1     +. 2     +.4 & 2  (>. "

2 ' +.

2:   >.  /



?      :   '             1) ((

  2: (  (    / %% $!!";

%% $!!" :  ' 96 42 %  8'42 7  18' )  (   )    

         (  42%96 :  2 57,-@ 

  

    1               A  '(:   ' 5;@3 '((    / %% $!!";

%% $!!"   : '/ %% $!!"

1 2'    (      4               (;

%% $!!"

  B  (                  4  9 +8'

)  ('

1  0 %'   A  (       12'

    (             '     ('' 2

)    8'

) 

             (  (   8' )    ('42% 96 

  8    :    :          ':    @ ': ''  ' ': '(A    0 % 4 'A  '( :   ' 1'       1 '   / %% $!!"

@;

%% $!!"(          ( )    (A '

@   (6 '    (  

 .  

23:

4%  ('(6(  (  ' ( ((   1

 '  (  '  ( ' '

  ' 1)  ('

@ '    1

'96 :   ( '' A  '

1'        (BC(  )   !(:& !0!;!( /&02 !0!;!(!($#3!$!.  &2&-9  ' %7 %$ $!%5) 

 3!(<!-=&"3!,02 >&($#0&(>/ !$<!-$#%#!'#$"/0,>/ 5'!($"/#0' 157,-@   ( 'D,-12 ( (' ''   : 62   2 D,-(        6'              6        D,-'  2( (  '(         (    1           (((BC(

 )   , -()    

  , -'(  57,-@  A ( ' * 6( 0 5;%!  , -    

  , - 

*

                 

                       

                       !

 "   #   "   "    # 

  $     #     #  % &    #        '"

%  

   (      "

"     )      %       "*+,-       ' (*%  

  "*'(,     )    .

)  #      / 

  "               

#      "       " "#     0/ 12

12

1 2  "    #    "      "        "    3       " 

      "       .

   '

   .

'

4  #      & /%   &"                  5  #  "              " 6  7     0 4 

.   (*

  .(* 4     # 

/%       #    "# 

?

    .

'

             #     &      12"12 1 2    )       "12  #"        312  "      "                              31 2          "                          #" 

        "         "    "        *8     '

       &                       "  &             #  "    " 6   7       %             6   7"  #   &       !

       )        '     

    "          

    

#    

        & 1 2    )     %    '

      #  9      #   

     )     )  

 &  "     '     

              " &"        

#  #            6           7  %    "     '     

+        7#     

                            )     9          #    #      "       #    1 2    )" :

"

                

   "#            # "

          #   %  #        "        "     &        #          &     )        #        '

    #                                 #            &     '

   ;



   

   %          

 < = 6  ""% 

     #       >-%  

   !

  1 # ?/*@*2"9 =      "   "      %    %  9 = "  12       "    #      "            

 %    # #  / / ?/*? A   "   "        )1 2%       0/ 1 2  "    #    "      "        "

   3       " 

       "      

                          "     #  55  55        # 5555 

& # 55  55      "            55?55   "

55  55       "  "    " "

 ""   ;

1 (6( 8' )  18' ) (    ( :  '

 () 

B  @ '  8' )    (  

0 () (    (A '' ( '     (9 BC(   ) 

      !" 

 #$%&'()"'%'*E'' '#/,%-))&%  ()  %#%;' 

' (

%!!))  ( '    (A '

1) ? BC(  )  

   

  !+  ) ,

 -.   /%&&'0)""%(% (#/,%-))' &% ()  %#%;( (6

*6(  9 BC(  )  

, - 

   >*4 6 #       " :

"   *88 "          B9 A7   +1#$'23456'*374& '

89: 

    .C,( D,+E;

,( 

   ,->7  

  7  

  

>*4 67 *+*'  ! "

" F  7  %     %     4   F        '8     G       %    " *+*-"        "

    9% "         G       %    "  *+)-"     ,+, %  "7  %     " )+-"G   %  "*+)-"4 67         %    7  %    )(,1*27  %     "  ,->7  %          F  #       )(,7  %  %"  )(,1*2            F                     +(1*277 4  1  2 "*+(       >* 4 67 "     

  ;

 1@  (A 

 ''  

  8' )  )  

'

65



*  + ',(&"!

26 + F+0 2 ( F+0