High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/628/2018dismissed

Maruti Suzuki India Ltd v. Lal Chand And ANR

2020-03-04Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu12 pages

! " !#! $ %$&$'( )* +,, - $ ) "

!#! $ %$&$'( )* +,, - $ ) " # $ %&% ' $ % %%

!% / % + 0 !1 "!

" + "

,, !+"/ 2 '"" +

%% ' 4" 5$6* " , / )

+,,

7 7

" 6 "

** 5$6* 8/"

/ /

(

) " " " 6 "

0 / ($ 4 $ 9$*9)

$ :$6

8 $ ;<;< ($ ,$ + 8;"

=( + >< /"

" 6 "

)4 $ ,,

$ % 9;

< (+

/ ,, + ;% < "

,, *, 0 1 / '

$" .

'$, 6* / " "

?$ $ ( ;! 0 1< % ?@ $ + ;+* $" < 1 "

,, *, 0

1 / * "

, + )9. 1 / ,

*)9. )97

*)97 )98

*)98 )9 . / $ 6 6 , 6 7 *,

/ / '6 "

%, + 0 , * / + 0

, * 4 " )94"

$ / '

,, *, 0 ./ '

! $ A0 6?*,

A 8 "

?*,

A , $ 6 $ ,$ / " 6

$ *,

A * "

! 6 * 6

( " "

0 .

"/ " ,0 *

/ )

1 0 + )

** 1 0 + )

$ ** :$6 4"

! 6 "

A / $ $ 4"

,$ 0 )

$ ** :$6 $ * $ ,

$ 0 , 6 " "

6 $ " "

,, "

" ."

/ 6

:$/ " + ( 0 "

:$/ " $ "* 1 $ * " , #

7 6 " :$/ " 1 / / " " 6 "

$ $ $ *$ 0 /"""

$ * " ,0

+?B$0 / ,, +

5 "

B$0,

6 "

/ ,

6 @9, , ?B$0 / $,, "* /"""

" ,0 7+ 6 "

,0 "

/ * 7 . !

,$ ?*,

A 6 6 "

/ 0 "

% :

$ ,$ 6 " 6 )

$ 5$ 4", / ,

) / " *,

+$ "

0 '

* 4"

* # *,

+$ "

0, 6 * '

'6B$ "6 6 * '

$6, 0 " , ,$ / ($ 4 $ 78 /"" $ 9

! "# $ % & ' &()%' &

% & ' ! * +'&((,-./ +# &'

&/ * ' 0 * 1&) % (234) 5 )#* 67-& !'! 8

&% *& % **# '8 &!&# 8 & 9 & !

&:%& 8 (

) # 98 # 8 & %&0%"08 +4/+8/ 08 43 ;&% * % 8)4,<-!&& ! ! !)& 8;&% *

"%*)%'8 %&%&08 -+/ & 8&8 &&& "*#! &%":8)# 8

& %&!$!!$!88& # & %)# & 2!( #=! 0( * 1&) ) !

8#=)08 "

!'! *'** :%

&> ;

)# * *&> 0&$6 &?42(-(@337 !

* A 8 *1!!

B 8 *08

! "%& ! * ! C + 60

/ , " 6

$ $ $ 7 )

$ ,, *, 0" '

$, , " "

/"" / "

$ $ ,$ / " "

6 % ;'< ($ ,$ + 8 "

$ / '* "* $ "

+$ / '* $ ,$

0, 6 * " 6

"* * /""

/ $

$ ,$ / " "

* 6 % 9+ ( + 1

/ " "

/ * 4"

))

$ , "

,, ( , / "

6 " "

,$ /

?*,

/ / " "

$ ,$ 4"

)

$ $ " " 5$ 5$

/ 0

*,$66 "

/ )

$ 8 ( / "

, 6 * # *

7 ,$

($ 4 $ 78 "

,, ,, $ % ;<;

< (+

($ 4 $

'6 ,, "

,0 " ,, 6 " , * ,

6 "

6 0 6 "*4"

B$0"

$ / " / " "

6 0* * 4"

))

$ $ * "

,, * / 6 "

$ % ;<;< (+ " " 5$ 6 * "

$ $ ,$

*,$66 "

)

$ "

6 "

,, $ % ;<;

< (+

* 2 " "

, / , "

** *,$6 5$6* 4"

)%6 C$6 "

" * "

/ " "

?*,

A , "

$ 8 6 "

+ * / $ (

" "

$* "

/ 4"$ / " "

?*,

A " $ "

" ? "

,, ! 6 " '

" " "

?*,

A "

$ "

+ 60 / "

" "

+/ )

$ "

6 "

6 $ ?*,

A / * 0 0

/ )

$ ,

8 / 4"

+ ))

$ , "

,, $ % ;<;

< (+

6 B$ $, 6 6 6 "

6 *

/ 4"

* / *

)

8 $ % ;<;< (+

$ % ;<;

< (+ "

6 )%6 C$6 6 6 "

" 6

$ ?*,

A "

* 0 "

?*,

A , "

$ 8 6 "

$ "

* (

" "

$* *

/ "

6 $ (

/ "0 " * "

78 ; , $

< " "

* "

* ! $ A0 6?*,

A 4"

" "

A "

9 6 $ B$ $ "

* 0

* "/ $ " "

* /"

,$ / "

A / 6 ) $ "

,, " 6$

)%6

C$6 "

,, " "

/ , "

$ $ $

* * 7 "

" " 6 "* 4"

)%6 C$6

6" 0 " 0"

6 " "

/ , $

" 6

$ $ $ 0 $

" 66 "

* 4"

) )

$ $ , "

:$/ " 6 " , /"

,, 9 " , 4"

)%6 C$6 "

" "

0* "

* 0$ D$ "

/ "

,, $ % ;< ;

< (+ ,, 7*6#

* 6 "

,$ "

)

$ 78 E %$, $ ,-./0 1-2, %,3,4,0- 35- &-4,6,7489:,5.,2%3,05,'

! % ))" "

, % ;<;

<* 0"

,, *

$ % ;<;

$ "

/"" "

6 , 6 ,, '

*, " @ *

* " 6

F/"

/ / 0 *& $

$ , F /"

, / *, / " ( "

$ "

0 $ 6 ,, "

" 6 * "

, 4"

* " 6 , '6 % ;<;

< *6 " 66 *,

* "

,, 6 $ , ( ,, 6 /"

" 6 * "

, ( "

" $ 6"* "

( ,, 6 $ "

0 ", * "

* 4"

$ ; 08 77+@/+"/)8" !

%!"

'%%&8**'%') !& ( ) !":8 08 77& 89 08 77+@/+"/) " %8&

8 & & " ** 8! * & # (A%) ! * #8

08 77 % ! %& 08 74+4/ #

! ! !# 8! 9& 9! #

# 8! 9&4333# "( * ' !& % 8! * # 8&

& ( %

# ) &8&

" '!& )"

& & 8'& !

* &%& 08 77+@/+"/ " (;

! * & ="

& '&

& 8'& !

* ! * )*= "%& & 8'

'% "* ' *8& !

& ( = '8 #&

& 8'& !

* &"

! * 8 !& 8&

8 & & &%8& &)&

% & "8!! '*(; #**6 *&%* %**" 8%&%8 % *%%( 8 "& *%&& " &"

! * (8& " !& & & & 8'

& !

*!& 8 08 77+@/+"/ & (8" !

&=&' ##'( %!%"%8 %*&&8*'

* & % # 8 !& % ( 08 77+@/+"/

& 8 #=! '%& & *&' !

D & % *"% 8 8 "

! * &% ' &8 &% *& %#* "# ! *& &(! * 8" !

& % 08 77+@/+"/%#=! # %8! *

'# 8&

8 & & **'&!

8&%8 &"%88& # *& & ' &% *& %( 8

&&#=!%& & 8" =# (;

"*&& & 8' & !

* &"

! * # %8! *

'# E% ! & & ) ! * ! # ! %

& 8'& !

#=!( * 8 !&%&08 77+@/+"/ )%

" # 8 8& ' & '

* 8 = "

! * 9!

#& & !

*& 8' "

&F# #"

# !

D % *"% 8 8F#8&

8 & # 8! * &# 8(;

%' *" %* **#! * 8 %"

& & 8'& !

*& " &( & & !

* & 8' &

= ' 08 77+@/+"/ & !

' & 8'

' ! * " '& * ! * & ! * !& & !

*& 8'"%

&! 8! *&! 8 %":8 * %

%& & (; #&) * 8!&&:%* # %

' *(;

* '

) '

! E% &"&"

! * ) # ** "&!&& & 8'& !

*& " &(1E%8 ! * &!& 8 %& 8 ' !**"

*"*( " '

& 8

8& !(% &)

* '

! * '' &"

%8 *) *& !=8! * %&08 7768**'

'& ' ' * '%& *"* !( 08 776 *"** ! * & && !&%"* !%88 '#

!= 8! * " %

&% * & % *& & ' "# 8**'

'& * & != '

&% *& %) ' 8 & &:%& 8 (; #) 88 %' # & & 8' & !

8 !& 8&

8 & # * %&) #=!%*& **!=8! * %&08 776 && & !

*& 8'"8! * & &* # &%&08 776&

**%8 !%*&%

%! * ! % 8 '

08 77+@/+"/(; 88 #&

& 8' & !

* "8! "8%

8 08 77+@/+"/) 08 776

#%*& " ! '* & % *( & 8 &

% )*& &")"* ' ! * !=8! * )

'' &"

& *'&(C 0 *

/ $ '

0 ,, ($ 4 $ #)

$ 4"$

, ,

6" 6

* / * / $ "

6 $ $ $ . + 60 * "

,, "

&% !

%% !

,0<3 )'

6 "

%, '6# G "