M/S Felix Infotech Private Limited And Others v. M/S Brightstar Telecommunications India Limited And Another
!"#$%$
"#"&#'
!"#$$
!
"# ( )*+$ , +, ++ * **** $ % &'
(!& # '
(!& # ,-#!
."&!/012 $ -1 +*,
# -./00 1
#
2
)!0 )*.3*4 /4/4+!
5, *5.*-/ ) 2
!( *..* + ( *..* !, 26 )* #
7 #
2 8 0( % 7 1
/94*/4/*+!
3, 268 0(% +/, # 8 0( % # 7 &
/4/ 00 #
:
%
(
/94*/4/*
# 7
1 6 & #& /4/00 +5,
& 6 # ;0 #
6(
6(
6 # # )*
1
(
- 2 - "3(3-(//<; 2 # 26 # ; #
6 # )* #
( #
*5.*-* ) ! 2
2 # 7 +-, !
2 # )*
#6 7
6 1 #& *5. ) !
&2 7 # 1 7 2 26 # )* ( #
#
2 26
2 +3,
( #6 4345/4// 2 26
'
(
# )*; #
6 7 2 6 = #6 & " 4*45/4/* +!
"*, 2 #6 # # 26 #
2 # &
& 6 2 ( # &
6 & 2
& # # #
+<, # )* 2 #
6(
6(
## # ; #
6 & # 4.**/4*9
# #(# 1
7 1 7 # 2
>
7 (
2 6
# 7 "-(54(*?(./<?-
- 3 - +?,
& #6 # &> # 6 #
& 1 1
/.43/4/*( #
& )"*955.*44?/( "*955.*4*?5( "*955.*4<4/
"*955.*4<45
# 2 26#
*.**/4/*# )*" 2
*.**/4/* +!
"5, & @
&
# ; #
67
2 ># 0 +., 26# #
26 # )* 2 6
# 54 6 2 # 7 A 2 # 0
&
&
2
26
# )*7
& 6 *<4./4/4( ( #6
% *?4./4/4 6A 7 #& /4/00
## 2 #
*5. ) !
#
7 +9, A #
+*4, ! 6( # 2
7 # #
# )-* *3**/4*9
)-/ 4.**/4*9
- 4 -
7 1 2 26 # 7 94 6 & # &6
# # # +**,
# &# 2
> #
6 4*4-/4*.5**4/4/*+!
<,
2
> +!
?,7
# 26# # )* # & ( # */ # ( & 2 #
1 & )*2 7 26
>
( & 1 "/(?5(3/(??4.;
#
26 #
1 7 2 "/(?9(4<(99<;
2
(# &
"3(3-(//<;# )* +*/, 6( # )* & 7 6 26# # # 26# #
#
26#
(# )*
: #
6
#
#
# # "/(.-(*.(<.4; & 2
:
&
#
2
"/(/9(4<(99<; 5*45/4/4 A # #
*.**/4/* 7 "/(4*(//(?.5
7 7 "/(99(*?(?-3;
7 # 2 26#
- 5 -
*.**/4/*# )* # )* ( # 3 #6( &
2 6
< &
# )-*-/7 # $; S.No.
Invoice Number & Due date (A) Reason for dishonor (E) RV19278115 having due date 16.11.2019 Invoice Amount (B) Cheque No.
(C) Cheque Amount (D) 2,12,54,718 773192 2,12,54,718 Stale RV1933810072 having due date 27.11.2019 79,67,436 265812 79,67,436 Payment stopped by Drawer RV1933810173 having due date 28.11.2019 3380124 265828 33,80,124 Payment stopped by Drawer RV1933810412 having due date 30.11.2019 4008293 265826 40,08,293 Payment stopped by Drawer RV1933810603 having due date 04.12.2019 8037774 265841 30,37,774 Payment stopped by Drawer RV1933810602 having due date 04.12.2019 3887143 265840 38,87,143 Payment stopped by Drawer +*5,
# )* # ( 2 2 # (7
>7 26 # 0 "# )* &2
&
*<!
(/4/4 #
%&
&
(# # B7> C(# )* #6
% 7 *?4./4/4
( 6
*/4./4/4 7 #
7 7 # 226%& +*-,
2 2&( ## # (
( 6 #; 1 # )*
( 2 6 # # *5.( *-**-/ ) ! 7 7 &( # ;
#
6 # #
- 6 - 1 # # # 26 # 7 7 # &
# "3(3-(//<;# )*
( ;
# )* ( #
1
6 & 2 2 "-(54(*?(./?; 2 26 #
( # & 2 # )*; #
2 # : )*; #
#; 1 26 # &
&
# 26 # # "
%
1 )* # $; ,$
"$ 3 4&
"$ 3 4& -5 6" ,$
"$
-0!"# -#7 8$ 6" * /<3./. /94//4/4 55(.4(*/-
*945/4 "
%;
AD0"3/4/445*9?34*-//4 *3(44(444 / /<3./< /94//4/4 -4(.4(/95 )E ;AD0;
).</4**45/3-359 /4(44(444 92:29 )E ;AD0;
).?/4**45./3-/3 *3(44(444 )E ;AD0;
)/49/4**9<<?*-9- /-(<4(-*? 92:29 ,$ "$ 3 4&
"$ 3 4& -5 6" ,$ "$
-0!"# -#7 8$ 6" * /<3.-4 4345/4/4 5.(.?(*-5
/34./4 "
%;
AD0"3/4/44./39-*<.9?4 5.(.?(*-5 ;%2%92; ;%2%92; ,$ "$ 3 4&
"$ 3 4& -5 6" ,$ "$
-0!"# -#7 8$ 6" * /<3.*/ /.4//4/4 ?9(<?(-5<
/-49/4 "
%;
AD0"3/4/449/-9943*/9* 34(44(444 2 4<*4/4 "
%;
AD0"3/4/4*44<34.*?*<5 /9(<?(-5< 9<2:92;: 9<2:92;:
- 7 - ,$ "$ 3 4&
"$ 3 4& -5 6" ,$ "$
-0!"# -#7 8$ 6" * /<3.-* 4345/4/4 .4(5?(??-
49*4/4 )E ;AD0;
)/.5/4*/?454-53* /4(44(444 2 )E ;AD0;
)/9?/4*/.-99<4*. *3(44(444 %2;9299 0 ) 54*4/4 *4445553. *4(9/(444 )E ;AD0;
)5*//4*54<<*?/3 *3(44(444 DD)4*.999;AD0 /3(44(444 %2<2 +*3, !# 2& 2 # 26 # "
%)E 0 )7 7 & 1 7 &2 7 "/(?5(3/(??4; 7 "/(?9(4<(99<; 7
)*
"3(3-(//<; 7
2 2 6 26# )* 1 *94//4/4 4345/4/4
26# #
#
(/4/42(/4/*
7 26 )* */4./4/4
26
#
#
7 26 )* +*<,
( # 7
# )*( #; 1 7
(#
# &
7 # ;
*?4//4/4( # 1 # )* #
#; 1 2 7 26#
- 8 - #
>
6 # &
& +*?,
*5. ! 7 # A
7
2
#
;
2 #2 2 #
##
2 2 6# #
##& 26
2 2 # #
6 & #& 1 7 ## 26
7 2 2 62 26 A7&( &6 #& ;
2 26
& 2
&& # 2 # +*.,
#& # # ( 2
( # 7 (
6 2 &
2 ;
7 #2 2 #
7
( # # 6 !#
& #& 1 7 ## 26
6 2 2 6(
6 6 #
&
# #
( 2 6 >7
- 9 - #
& 7 ## : !# 0 Kumar Exports v. Sharma Carpets, (2009) 2 SCC 513. +*9,
# (# ;
& # # #
## ( ## 2
> 4*4-/4*. 5**4/4/*+!
<,7
# #
2
> +!
?, & 2 2 6
1 7 6 26# +/4,
(
#
# *5.
*-* ) !
( 2& 26 2
7 +/*, !
6( # 7
#
2
)!0 )*.3*4 /4/4+!
5, *5.*-/ ) ! 26 # )* #
7 #
2 8 0( % 7
/94*/4/*+!
3, 268 0(% 261 4-**/4/-
,-#!
."&!/01
&!/
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No