High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3418/2016dismissed

Ohm Value Services Ltd v. Janta Land Promoters Ltd And Another

2017-09-12Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal9 pages

! " # $%&'

() * ++ &&

% (' , *-(.

(* +

! " # $%&'

() * ++ &&

% (' 0 1/2/ +

! " # $%&'

() * ++ &&

% (' , *-(.

(* +

-( !

($(.0 1/

)

(

/'

)

( ++ &&

3&& /(

++ & (4/ )5'+ )

(( +

3

(( + 3

(5'(), & )

(( + 3

(( + 3

!"

#$% & '"

7( (

++& 8/ / '&9 '++(

49 )

++& &&8

'.

:'( - -

( ;

( ( '40

&&0' )$%)*+* 29 / .. 0'1.

3 /&& 4 + 1

&& ++ &( '

.

'

-& ++ & 1 0'1.

+ 49

& ,'1

1( /& -& / & '

( &(

+& '

&&

+& .

'( 1 <'(

9(

( 1( /& &'1/

( (

'. 1 +& &/&& 1 '( && )'( )

(

-& 8&&

' ( &+& .

'( 1 <'( 9()

(

# =:- & >/

& )

(. ( ' (!

! "#$##

%

& '

( (

)

(

##

' ( "###

' ( "*

$ , '

((

( -

(

(

.

'

/&%, 0 ()

1*

2

( 3 ,

(

- 1"$* "* 1

1 1

( (

( "4 ,'

(

5

6 (#

( ' 1

(

! !

1 " 1 '

(

#

( '

(

(

( 1 '

1

11

+

2 (

( 1

(

( 2 -

7 ' 0

2 07

8

9 /

: 1 :

'

( ' ;

((

1

(

-

#

2 (

-

1

(

2 $ '

;

(

(

6 (5 " (&

(

61 (<3$

( .

'

/& '

, /

#

/&.

';

(

/ 2

( = +'

&+9.

( &&.

.

'

# "

( . )

(

" =: (( 1 +9.

-& ) &

(

" =: (

(

(+9.

&&.

(+ ( /(

. />/ . 49 8

/(

. /

81(

.;

+9.

'+ # "

)

(

">/

.;

+9.

4'

((

; 1 :. /.( )

"=: (>/ ( (

8 +& 81(

'+ "8 & ( +'& ) ('

.' +

49 "

+& 8'&4 && && +9.

8

. '+ "

8(

&

( "

(

1 & ( ) ('

+9.

49 " & 1 8/ / + &+(

18 &&4

&&+9.

8. >/

(.?&'

&&

( '

/8'

(&& 1'+

.;

+9.

'+ " & 18/ /

+& /&&4 && 8 /'

9'( (

=)

/ &

+& .;

+9.

(/8'

81 )

+& )

(

=:

(3 /

+& 8;

++ ( / 8 ++( ' 94 1/ ( @& .

&9

( 1 / ++ ( 4 /& .+9 &&

'

A +

.'

B (8( 4& .' /('1// *

&9 & /&& 1

(

( ? ) &?'( >/ ( ? ) &,'1

( 1 & /8 '

81 ) &9 / & ( 4. .'. 9

8( <' ( & * ( 7 ( ++

?'(

( ( ++( 1

) ) &4& &

++ & & 49

'4

+& <'

)

(

.9'( (4 1

/ 8 &&

8+& +& #+& -& +'('

)( '

'& .

&9. +9.

8 /( 1( +& # 4'

/ /&& 1 '.+ +& 4989 +(

'

* ( ' & ( ++ && / . &&8 1 '4. ! 9& (

8 1 ) /8'

81 ) ( ( 8 + +

(.

5) (.

8( <' ( '&

4 ( +& (

84 8+( . '( 4 ' + (?&'

8

& &9 +9.

'+ 9 ( :. / ) >/ 8 + /) +

+(+ 9 (

8/&&9(4 ((9 (/ ( ' &( + / '4.

'

& 49 . 4&

+& 8( <' ( & '

(+ + ((. $ /'( '++(

0'1.

7 ( ++

?'(

++ && 81 )

""=:

&

9 ( '

(. 9'4

=:

# ' (& (

$ /'( '4.

( 7 ( ++

?'( / '

) 1 8/ / 4

( 8 /

( 0'( ++ &

>/ (1'.

& ( ' & '&&9 ((

'

""

1( 3 8 9& /8'

C/ & 1 ) 1++( ' 9

+ .' 49 "

8 + &&9 +

'

.'

+

+& /&&4 && 8 /'

9'(

>/

8'&9(

) 49 /

/4

1 ) '4

84) '&9 ' +( ) '

"">/ (

( 7 ( ++

?'( 8((

( ( 1 1 .+&

/ ?&'

/8'

98 1 )

!

"

"

"

3 / ( 1( ( ' &/( (( ?&'

&&

'&&94 ( '& 8 /

-'043.9+ (1'.

/'

94 ?&' (

4) & 18 / ) '& 8/

& ( ..

( &+('

>/ ( ?&' &8 /+9.

&&.

+9.

&&.

' (?&'

(3?&'

+() ('& 8 / 5) (.

#

"

$ %

&

* ( ?' & 8/ & (9 1

(+(

?&' / '4.

8+( . '( + (?&'

D9 (+() 4 ( + &+(

1 &' 1 4

3.9 ) ' & 1?&' & ?&'

( ( 8 4 ) &' ?&'

+ &&9+() (( +

) 9 (?&'

+(

1( ( '.+ 4

&&'( & ((. 1 )( '&

( 8(

49 +& ++ && +& / 4

&89 1(

3

(+(

4 1'1/

+(0

8

(

&&

( D9 ($8 ) -& / +

&&.

+& 4 ( 1# / . & / +

.'

.'

/ + 8+( . '( '

"

" 3 / ( 1(

( +() +9.

&&.

/&&4 . &98/

( 9 & ) + &&

( (.

( 4

+(

>/ / '& (+9.

/4

+ &&9 +() ?&' 1(

?' & (

++ && / 4('1/

/ ?'( 9?&'

&&

(8/ /+() &'( & ) + 8'&4 11('(

8 //& +9.

3) 8 ' . 4)

3 91 1('

( 8 / 1 (( ) 49 7 ( ++

?'( && /(

++ & ( . 8 / + &

B +

8 /* 1& () '

/( -'04 && + 1. && '++& ( +

(. 4) 0'1.

# ,

- / ./+0/+1*2+)3$%451+)*%+6!

+*5 ./+0/+11+210)78+!

+*5