Ram Kishan v. Joginder Singh & ANR

  

           

"#$%$&'(')*

 +

",-'(.") //$00")# 1$2(3( 4')%$2')4.")%")#.$2  $(/)%$)#(

 *  56   - 6  2$($)#*7 22'#","')'8%9&"#$8 2"//$00")# 2 "):"28%9&"#$8 22$(/)%$)#(

 ;.$#.$2#.$ $/2#$2(0&"0)$:(/"/$2,"<=$"00:$%# ($$#.$>3%4,$)#?

 =$2$$22$%##.$ $/2#$22)#

 ;.$#.$2#.$>3%4,$)#(.30%=$2$/2#$%')#.$%'4$(#? 77 77 - 6 

6!

,/34)$%')/2$($)#$&)%//$"0"4"')(# 2%$2'(>3%4,$)# %"#$%    


8  /"(($%  =<  0$"2)$%  %%'#')"0  '(#2'&#   3%4$8 -323@(.$#2"89'%$:.'&.:.'0$.$"2')4"//$"0"4"')(#>3%4,$)#")%%$&2$$ %"#$%
A


8/"(($%=<0$"2)$%%%'#')"0 '9'03%4$ $)'2'9'(')!8 -323@(.$#2"8&"($:"(2$,")%$%="&@##2'"0 32#')#.$0'4.#>3%4,$)# %"#$%A


A8/"(($%=<#.'( 32#')  A

A8#'#0$%"(
 

 

    

8:.'0$.0%')4#."##.$2$'( )(3=(#")#'"0&,/0'")&$#.'( 32# ."9$.$"2%0$"2)$%&3)($0(2=#.#.$/"2#'$(")%."9$"0( &"2$300<4)$#.234.#.$'0$ #  &,$(  3#  #."#  /0"')#'(  ."%  '0$%  "  (3'#  2  /(($((') &0"',')4#."#0")%,$"(32')4,"20"(3###"00")%,$"(32')4
,"20"( ."(=$$)$)&2"&.$%3/)=<%$$)%")#"20'$2(3'#:"(%'(,'(($%=<#.$)

7
7

'9'03%4$ 3)'2'9'(')!8-323@(.$#2"8)
+ 
")%"//$"0:"( "0(  %'(,'(($%  )   
A  =<  0$"2)$%  %%'#')"0  '(#2'&#  3%4$8 -323@(.$#2"8"4"')(#:.'&.  A

A8#'#0$%"(
 

 

    

8 :"('0$%=$2$#.'( 32#.'( 32#8 :.'0$%$&'%')4  A

A)A


A8=($29$%"(3)%$2*7
 .$6&"0 ,,'((')$28:.%$,"2&"#$% #.$0")%8:"($B",')$%8=<#.$/0"')#'("//$00")#(8=3# .'( 2$/2#8%'%)#')%"932#.$ 32#(=$0:8)#.$423)% #."##.$(",$8:"()#8')"&&2%")&$:'#.#.$2$0$9")# 230$( ")%2$430"#')(8"(#.2$$/$2,")$)#/')#(8."%)#=$$)'B$% =<#.$6&"0 ,,'((')$2 ),<&)('%$2$%/')')8)&$8 #.$  32#(  =$0:8  %'%  )#   "&&$/#  #.$  2$/2#    #.$  6&"0

,,'((')$28  '#  :"(  #.$'2  %3#<8  #  "//')#  "  2$(.  6&"0

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

;.'0$2$,")%')4="&@#.$&"($##2'"0 32#2"//')#,$)# "6&"0 ,,'((')$2#.$2")@$.('0%"2

$9$)3$!800:')4 %'2$&#'):"(4'9$)*7  2  #.$  2$"()(8  2$&2%$%  "=9$8  #.$  "//$"0  '( "&&$/#$%8:'#.)2%$28"(#&(#(.$>3%4,$)#(")%%$&2$$( #.$ 32#(=$0:8"2$($#"('%$.$&"($'(2$,'##$%="&@8# #.$  #2'"0  32#8  :'#.  "  %'2$&#')8  #  "//')#  "  6&"0

,,'((')$2    #.$  2")@    $.('0%"2 

$9$)3$!8  2  #.$ /32/($%$,"2&"#')#.$0")%8')%'(/3#$8')"&&2%")&$ :'#.#.$2$0$9")#230$(")%2$430"#')(8")%#.$')(#23&#')(8 '((3$%=<#.$')")&'"0 ,,'((')$2# 9$2),$)#"2<")"8 2,#',$##',$#$2#.$2$/2##.$6&"0 ,,'((')$28 '(  2$&$'9$%8  =>$&#')(  #  #.$  (",$8  (."00   =$  '0$%  =<  #.$ "442'$9$%/"2#</"2#'$(8")%#.$2$"#$28.$(."00=$$B",')$% #$2  #.$  $B",')"#')    #.$  6&"0  ,,'((')$28  ") //2#3)'#<8(."00=$"2%$%8##.$%$$)%")#2$(/)%$)#8# 0$"%.'($9'%$)&$8') 2$=3##"08#.$2$# .$2$"#$28#.$#2'"0

32#8(."00%$&'%$#.$&"($"2$(.8)#.$="('(#.$2$/2#8 #.$ $9'%$)&$  #.$ 6&"0  ,,'((')$28 ")%  #.$ $9'%$)&$ "02$"%<2$&2%$%.$$$(#.$6&"0 ,,'((')$28(."00=$ =2)$8=<#.$/0"')#'("//$00")#(.$/"2#'$("2$%'2$&#$%# "//$"2')#.$#2'"0 32#)
A8"# * ."2/82 32#.$2/2&$$%')4(5 &&2%')40<86&"0 ,,'((')$2:"("//')#$%.$ 32# 0$"2)$%  %%'#')"0  '9'0  3%4$  $)'2  '9'(')!8  -323@(.$#2"8  9'%$ >3%4,$)#%"#$%
A


8"4"')%'(,'(($%(3'#)"//$"080$"2)$%

77 %%'#')"0  '(#2'&#  3%4$8  -323@(.$#2"8  :"(    #.$  9'$:  #."#  )&$  #.$ %$,"2&"#') B;D!:"()#3)%#=$/2/$2=<#2'"0 32#")%:"( )#3)%#=$"(/$2')(#23&#')(')")&'"0 ,,'((')$28(",$:"( )&)($C3$)&$=$&"3($6&"0 ,,'((')$2%'%)#"'B/3&&"/')#"( 2$C3'2$%3)%$2230$(.$2$2$8'#:"(.$0%#."#)&$#.$2$/2#6&"0

,,'((')$2'()# "&&$/#$%8'#:"(#.$%3#<#2'"0 32##"//')# 2$(.")#.$26&"0 ,,'((')$2 ."9$$B",')$%2$/2#6&"0 ,,'((')$2 B;D!

%"#$%


 )#.$2$/2#8#.$2$'(",$)#')#."#"00#.$32/')#( @."(2"  
:$2$"'B$% .$/'00"2(:$2$"'B$% &&2%')40<8 6&"0 ,,'((')$23)%#."#%$$)%")#$)&2"&.$%3/)(C<"2%( "//2B',"#$0<
E,"20"("(/$2('#$/0") B;D ! .$0$"2)$%&3)($0(2/"2#'$(."9$)# %'(/3#$%#."#0")% '(')"="%'")%#.$2$'("&)(#23&#'))#.$('%$(#.$/2/$2#<)#.$($ &'2&3,(#")&$(8#2'"0 32#:"(2$C3'2$%#&)('%$2:.$#.$2'#:"(/(('=0$ #')%/3&&"/')#()"#0$"(##.2$$('%$(? )0<#.$)'#&")=$.$0%#."#("'% /3&&"/')#(."9$)#=$$)"'B$%'#'(')"="%'8'#,"<)#=$/(('=0$ 2")<6&"0  ,,'((')$2# ')% #.2$$/3&&"/')#( # &)%3&# #.$ %$,"2&"#'))#.$($&'2&3,(#")&$(8 32#:"(#"00="&@3/)#.

$2"0 $9'%$)&$8  ('#$  /0")  ")%  %&3,$)#(  "##"&.$%  :'#.  #.$  '0$   )  #.$($ &'2&3,(#")&$(82%$22$,")%'(.$0%#=$="%')0":")%'(($#"('%$.$ ,"##$2'(2$,")%$%="&@##.$(3&&$((2 32#0$"2)$% %%'#')"0 '(#2'&#3%4$78-323@(.$#2"8:'#."%'2$&#')#2$.$"2#.$"//$"0),$2'#(8 #"@$')#&)('%$2"#')#.$$)#'2$$9'%$)&$8%&3,$)#("##"&.$%:'#.'0$8 2$/2#    =#.  6&"0  ,,'((')$2(  ")%  2$"//2$&'"#$  (",$  ")%  2$&2% ')%')4(#.$2$)),$2'#()$"&.'((3$#')%3#"(#:.$#.

7D7 0:$2 32#"2$>3(#''$%2"2$0'="0$#=$2$9$2($%? )($C3$)#0<8"//$"0 '("00:$%##.$"=9$)#$%$B#$)# #./"2#'$("2$%'2$&#$%#/3#') "//$"2")&$  =$2$  0$"2)$%  %%'#')"0  '(#2'&#  3%4$78  -323@(.$#2"8  )

D
 +"# *  6:$2"//$00"#$ 32#'(%'2$&#$%#%$&'%$#.$ "//$"0:'#.')#.2$$,)#.(2,#.$%"#$2$&$'/#&$2#''$%&/<#.'( 2%$2 $4'(#2<'(%'2$&#$%#2$,'#="&@#.$2'4')"0'0$#0:$2"//$00"#$

32#"0)4:'#.&/<#.'(2%$2 ')&$  ,"')  &"($  ."(  =$$)  "00:$%8 #.$2$2$8/$)%')4"//0'&"#')8'")<8"0((#")%(%'(/($%

- 6 !

   

 + (>@( ;.$#.$2(/$"@')42$"()$% * $( ;.$#.$2 $/2#"=0$ * $(