← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/204/2015dismissed

Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd v. J.P. Makol, Deputy Chief Accounts Officer (Retd)

2016-11-18Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri5 pages



   

 



 !"#$%$&$'( &&)) *$  +,) &(       ---- $ $!.)/$0(. $/&&)) $)),0(. $/$&( ----

  



1/&&)0/&&))/2 (/.)(3 &&))% $$($(( 4

&(%.)&&) 54



&&))/(()(&$6)$6/$&( 6&)    7  3$    $.   

    1  /  $8$(0  / $&( )(  $()$  #($( . $ / $&( 9)888$.("3/$($ /($0&&))/

)(&&):/&&))% $$!(/&&):/ 0/&$ &&)/" )(  ;$  /$//$&(#&&( <&&$.%)$, 7 45 =/$(&$6/&

.)  =.8&(>60/ #&&( 

454/) 

?

 9 $/$/# &$6(/&

$





/) 

 )3 /@.$68$ $66&)3#//.8(&$ )$& $40

(73$:/$&(6&)(43$ $.

0

3$

(73$

 )3 /&$6 // 

$# )("66((/>  A /&

$ /3$&$6(/&

& 3%/

$ =#.$0 $($ $/&

& 3  %/     

$       

$?$    

$(6()3&

$&$(&$) / ) $$ 61/$#$(0/& $  

$# )(" ))( &68 

$/>  A #/(()&3 7 9$/& $& 8$8"  7 3$  $. &$6$6# )("/ $()/$&(! " /  &38/&

$$$ ) $$(0 .(/$ 

$&&$6)&#//  (& (:/$ $0/$&(/)(8&

$ #   

 (  /  (   &           #

4541 /( &,($ $/& $&  873$$.0/)(73$$6

 1/6#/)0&$#&($  

$7 # :/$&(#&$6(/ & & 3%/

$4 

1  /  ",8$ (0  /  9  &$6  %$ )$  ? (( 5  $/& $& 8$8

(73$  /(/   

  

!   "#$  % &'( ) !

*   % &+B/$0 /&$0/( & (>&$6 & 

$(/& 3%/

$:/ 0 /  $&(  /  $(  #  &$6  $6  /  (   & :/$ $0/$&()($6 $6&)873$

$.

'$( ) $/&&)) "6(/( &   

$ :/$ $0/$&(/$(/$ &$606)30 

$0$ 

$(& 3 %/

$ $(8/6. 68/ $  

$&$6)& 

$" )) .# / &$6% $(/          &$ / &$6 % $  /  /)(  /    &$  #/  8  /8/$  &3  )  6    &$6:/$ $0/$&(/$(/$&$6 $6/ ( &06)30  

$0$  

$( & 3%/   

$  

0  7  ( 4 $&.)3:/$ $0/$&()( $$6 $ 6&) 73$ $.:$)% $$$(($8/  //$&(/$(/8/$)7 ( $/$/# &$6(    /  &    & 3  %/     

$    4 =0/)( $/$6 $6&)873$

$.

(6()3  /  &    $     

$       &$6)&:/$&("3.$  $3(/&)3

/&$6//"&(#// A2 /&

$ 

$(//$(/8/$)//&

 

$/(6//#&$6(:/9 %$ )$ ? (( 5 .$3& / $/& $&

$8$6 $6&)873$ $.6 /. $(/$(&$6/$8 )$$.B/$0/$&(/ $(#$8 )$&$6 :/ 8///)(/&   

$0$ 

$(& 3%/

$0/ &

$&$6)& /  &$6% $/6$)388/8/$&3)6 &$6   (8 /")    /  &$    $  /  $  /  9 &$6%$ )$.$3& //$(&$6/ )(/. "$( $/& $& 8$8$6 $6&)873$ $.:/ &$6% $/   

  

&$

/)(//#/ )$ $2 $("$&$(8/(

$ $6C>$

&$

$( ($

  ,

     -%       &# *  *  % 

      %

"

 % . ( $$'%$

$"    '*  &#$ -%    % $*& # $ %   #/    0#  &

(     (  

   % 1 0# #$

2 & 3#

& $     

 (     #$          &$ $$"$ *  /  #

  &

' '*#$  '*     -%    #

  

   

*  

$$"$ *. &4 "0# & ( "$* $$( "    5

  6    5     &$ $*    

      4 "  0#     $&    ( "



  $%#$+ :/$ $0  /   )  $  $ )$  #//  $  $2 $(    " $&$(/&$)3/9%$ )$ ? (( 5 ((6()3/&

$ &$6)& 

$ :/$ $0/&&))/ 6( $ $#//&&))% $$($ 5 &&)((6(  

    !"#!$%&'$( 

   B//$&,8?$(

D? B//$&$")

D?