Inderjit Singh v. Bahal Singh And Another









 

 




  




 






  !"#"









 


$ 

"

$"

!

"#$%&

'()* &
'
"
*+"

"%
&
 #
 ' (
)$* 
+$

&


  (
)$* 


+$


  ,,,

     -./ + 
$ .
"

# 
"*$

 
 "

*$*#
#'"

*"
""
01
 
$#"
0$2 -3/

 ++
+

"#
+$
*  $
$
 
++*


 ++
2 "
$2

$""""$
$+
 
 
"
"

$2



 

 $2
$+
$1
 
43 3446
1
7*#
01
  ++

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ .

 
" 

 
4.

3446
7*#
01
+ 
$ .

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ 3

"

*
$+
"#
 
2
 (
#

)$ *
+$
' 
#*$
2 "
"$
"$# (
" 
 + "
+$'
+

  *+#
*#) 
$""""$
$+
  ++
$)
 
"#
  -8/ 
2 "
 
01
  ++
 
+ "
2
#
 
0#"""
$+
+ *
#
 
 '

"1
$+

$" 
 $"$"

) *"
) 
9'

$" 

 *
$ $ $
: ;

+ 
$ 3
* '
'"+
$
0
&  
*$
$+
 
+$" 
) 
'
*$'

1

 ++
2 "

 

$+
'$1
+$
 
 '
$+
"
2+ 
4.

3446(


 
+ "
+$
 <
$ 
$+
34(444=>
+ "
$$<
" #"

 #'0
'

""$"
$+
  ++
$
0 <

"
"
2
"
$
0 <
" '

"

"$
$0 
+$#
0 <
* ?#"
 2
$

# 0
 $ 
 <(
     +(
+ "
$$<


 ++
$
 "
*$'

7
$
43 3446

$
7*#
  
$2
$+
$1

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ .
01
""#
 ++
 $2
$+
$1
2
' 
2
  *
$'

1
"
"*#1
$+
 
+$" 
$ 

 
$** "$
 

 
'$
$+
 # 1
344@(
  ++
$0 
$ 
$+

@
 *"
+$'
 
+ "
 $#
 
+$" 
*$'

1

 
+ "
"$
$0 
 
" #"
$+
  ++
$
") 
" '

"

+ 
$ .

$
7*#
 

$2
$+
$1
 
.8 4.

344@
"
$
.A 4.

344@ 
" 
 
$2
$+
$1
2 "
< 
01
 
+ "
"
"*#1
+$
 
+$" 
$ 
$+
@
 *"

+ "
"$
$
" #"
$+
  ++
$
' 1
0 <

"

+ "
< 
" 

"
"
"*#1
2

""# *

" '
2$#
0
#
$
 1'
$+
$ 
'$# 
 1'
$+
$ 
'$#
$+
@
 *"
2
"(
+ "
#
 
" 
'
$
"
 
45 344B


 
$2
$+
$1
 
.8 4.

344@
"
$
.A 4.

344@
$

+ "
$
 
 
$2
$+
$1
 
.A 4.

344@  ++
< 
 
" 
'
 
45 344B
2 '

-@/

 ++
+# 
 
 
 
+ "

*$)
 
" #"
$
0 <
" '

"
$
'
$
"
2 $#
1
 
$
 
" '


$+
844=>
1

#* "
$
.3 4.

344@
2
 
$
" 
$ 
$+
@
 *"

 ++
"$
 
 
 $"
+ 
$
 
+ "

 <
$ 
$+
34(444=>
$
4.

3446


"$
7*#
 
$2
$+
$1
 
43 3446

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ .
"
2 "
$

 "
+ "
""#


 ++
 
" '
2
$
0
'"#"

 
" '
2$#
0
< 
"
"*#1
+$
 
$ 


 
+ "
$
 1
 
$ 
$+
34(444=>
$
.3 34.6
+ "
+#"
$
*)
 
'$#

$
  ++
 
+ 
$ .

7*#
 
" 


+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ 3

"

*
$+
"#
 
$
..

+ "

$
#
 $*#'"
2
2
$0 
01
 '

 
'
$+
) *'
$+
$ 
$+
34(444=>
$

 

 
4.

34.6
7*#
01
+ 
$ .

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ 3
2 "
* '
$
0
#

)$
01



+$" 
0 *<$#(
 
"#
2 "
+ -B/ 
"#
2 "
*$"
01
 
+ "

-A/ 
2 "
"#0'
 
 '"+
2 
$
" 
"
$ 1



$
'
$
"

"

*
$+
A
<  "
.
' 
$+
 
+$

$ 
*$" $
$+

C(A4(444=>

+
*)
 
+#

+ 
*$" $(
7*#
 
 
$2
$+
$1
 
43 3446

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$.

)
$""""$
$+
 
"#

$ 1 
" 
 
$2
$+
$1
2 "
"
2 
#0
" (
    
*$* 
 
+ *

"

*
$+
 <
$ 
+$'
 
   
' 1
$>$

 )
 <
9'


$
* 
 
'$#
+$
7*#$
$+
 
" 
(
+ 
$ .
* '
$
<$2
 

'$#
$+
3(@6(.55=>
2 "
$#" 

?#"


 ++
$
* 
 
" '  ++
?#"
+ 
$ .
$
 1
 
" 
'$#
$
"
0 +
2

""# *
 2

 
" '
'0#"
$
+ 
$ .

+ 
$ .
* 
 
$ 
'$#
$
4.

3446

 
" '
2 "
"$
7*#
"

'
$
"  +(
  ++
+ 
$
1
 
" 
'$#
$
+ 
$ .
"


") 
' "

"
+
 
"#

?#"$

$
$

""#D
 
+ "(
$
$
' 
 
" 
'$# -6/ $
 "
2
$
 
$
"

*+*
""#"

-5/ 
$#"
0$2
)

* 
 
)*

01
 "

"

*
$+
"
 " *$
$+
 
1 
344@>4B

 
 <

$ 
$+
@
 *"
+$'


+ "

+ "

< 
 
"
$*#'"
"
"*#1

 
+ )$#

 $2
$+
$1
2
2 "
7*#
$
.8 4.

344@
7

B
2 "
#
+
 1'
$+
$ 
$
 
+ "

 
$ 
$+
 
+$" 
$*#'
* '
+$'
 $""""$
$+
  ++
2
2 "
*$"
$
0

#
$*#'

"

*
$+
"
 " *$
02
"(
2
* 1
$)
 
+ *
 
+
'0#"

$ 
'$#
$+
@
 *"
01
  ++
$
 
+ "


1 
344@(
 
+ "

#
 
" 
$2
$+
$1
$
 
"*$
$*#'
2
* '
+$'
$""""$
$+
  ++
2 "
7

A
2
2 "

'
$
"
7*#
$
45 344B

 
'
$+
 <
$ 
$+
@
 *"
01

 
'
$
"
2 "
7*#

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ .

 
$*#'
2 "
< 01
+ "
"
"*#1

 
'
$+
7*#$
$+
' 7

6
2 "
 
 
$ 
$*#'
2
* '
+$'


$""""$
$+
  ++
2
2 "
'
$
"
 

7*#
01
  ++

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ .

 
1 
344B -C/

#" 
$+
 
+$" 
$*#'"
2$#
"

$2
 

"
$*#'"(
 
'$#
$+
 "
'$1
2 "
'$
"
@
 *"

 "
$*#'"
2$#
"

$2
 
2
' 1
 " *$"
02
  ++

+ "

2 "
# 1
) 
 
$ 
+$'
+ 
 *
$'

1

"

2 
 
$ 
2 "
#(
 
$ 
$*#'"

7"

B
$
7

6
2
2
 <
01
 
+ "
"
"*#1

#
$+
$ 
2
#
$
 -.4/ 
 
"
$+
+$" 
$*#'"(

2 "


+ "
$0 
+ 
$+
  ++

  +(

 ++
 


 
+ "

 
1 
3446
+$
 <
$ 
$ 
$+
34(444=>
+$
 '
$+
"
2+

 
7*#
$2
$+
$1
$
43 3446
2
2 "
 <
01
 
+ "
"
"*#1
$*#'
  +(
2 


 ++
2
$
 
+ "
$
 1
 
'$#
$+

34(444=>(
 

* '
$
<$2
 
+ 
$ .

*$) *
2
+ 
$ 3

'  
2"""

7*#

 
" 

7

8
01
'"#"
 $2
$+
$1
7

@ 
" 

2 "
7*#

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ -../ 
$#"
0$2
)
"$
*$*#

+ )$#
$+


 ++
2
+*
$
)*
$
*$
 1(
+ "



 
+ *#'
$+
0
"

$" 
 *
$'

1

* '
 
7*#
 $2
$+
$1

"
)# 
* *1(
0#
 
+ *
2 "
$)
$
 *$ 1

 
*$""
7 ' $
$+
 
+ 
 
+
$ 
*$'

 "
$
0 +
$+
$" 
 *
$'

1
0
"
"

 
 $
$+
$" 
 *
$'

1
2 "



 
$)
 
*+
*$ 1
$+

"



$+
$" 
 *
$'

1
"
7 E(

2 + 
$ .
2 "
"

$2
"


" 
$ 6


+ 
$ 3

" 
$ .


2 "
$)
$
*$
 + "
$ .

3
2
"
$+
$" 
 *
$'

1
+ "
#"
$

$2
$+
$1"
$+


 ++
7*#

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ .

)1
'$1
 " *$
2 
 <
 *

 "

 
" '
2
< 
"
"*#1

 1'
$+
 
$ 
'$# )$#"

$2
$+
$1"

'"
$
"
2
* '
$
*$
+$'
 
*#"$1
$+


 
 " *$"(
+
 1'
$+
 
$ (
$*#'"
2
#
$
 
 
1 
3446(
 ++
 


 
+ "
+$
 <

$ 
$+
34(444=>
+$
 
 '
$+
"
2+

 + "
"
#"# 
 
$0 
 $2
$+
$1
7

@

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ .

 
" '
2 "
< 
01
+ 
$ .
"
"*#1

 1'
$+
 
$  
$)

0+$
 1'
$+
 
$ 
'$#(
+ 
$ .

*$) *
2
+ 
$ 3

'  
2"""
+"1
'"#"
 $2
$+
$1
2
2 "
7*#
01
 
+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ .
$
43 3446
"
"*#1
$*#'

  +(
$
 
0 ""
$+
" 
$2
$+
$1(
+ 
$ .
$
7*#
" 

 
7

8

+ )$#
$+
+ 
$ 3
$
4.

-.3/ 
+"
$+
+ *
)
0
*$
01
 
$#"
0$2
$
 
0 ""
$+
+$" 
)*
$
*$
 
" 

 
4.

3446
$
 
0 ""
$+
$2
$+
$1
 

3446
2 "
 

*  $
2 "
 

+ )$#
$+
-.8/ 
 
0 ""
$+
'  
$
*$(
 
"#
$+


 ++
+$
*  $

*$"?# 
+
$+
' 
#*$
2 "
*
01
 
 
$#
)
#'

*
 
.A 34.@

 
" '
2 "
#


01
 
9$2


 
$#
)
#'

*
 
4C 34.B -.@/ 
+"
$+
+ *"
*$
01
 
$#"
0$2
*$''"# 
+$'
 
*$
2

* 
01
 
$#"
0$2


 2+#
'  >

* $
$+
 $"
+"
$

0 ""
$+
" '
)*
* $
0
' 
"#0*
' 
$+
# 
"*$

 
0+$
 "
$#
 
+"
*$
01
 
$#"
0$2
2
+*
$
"
 " *$"
02
"

 1'
$+
$ 
* $
0
+ #
2

* $
0
" 
$
0
)"
$
 
"#
$+
'" 
$+
)*

1
' 
$
 2
$
2$
*$" $
"
)$)

 "
# 
"*$


 "
# 
"*$

 
"
+$#
$
0
$ 1
)$
$+
'"


" '
"
**$1
"'""












'
"
*+"










'(+&
4C 34.5

*
 
 "$=  <

"=$
 
 $ 0

"=$