High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2079/2015dismissed

Hardev Singh v. Gram Panchayat And ORS

2015-11-30Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri6 pages

!"##$%&%'()

!! " #$% &'( )*"+, !- ". . ". /// ( *+

0""12 ' ".2!3 "

"

."4 5.6 0""3 "" " "45.6

,#&#'"( ("-

,!

-!+)" " !! " ---

.

.-. 2!) !

!3* !! " !

" "."8 !! "9 ' 2

12 ' " ) " ; ..

< ! 2 "

: = 3*! < !>2 >2

, +? !+

".2 ' ' "*

!3* !!

."

. ". ".&'( )*" ".

" " ."8. ".9+- )-.2 !3*"

." !!"<2" 12 ' )" ;

7! )"..2 .2 " ' "

.@

" ."

" . ". '

"

. ) 2! ....

'

))

2 . 2. )2.

3."2)"

)

." -!! .2..) )-.

" " " !

"-.

!3*" !! " * ..2 ) "*

)"

". ".") ."2)""-!! !! !!*

) 3!*'!

.3*"' : = -.!.'7 !! !"""2.

A2."

..

"2"-

"!

B! " !! . )."! "* " .32 *-!!

2 "2.2 ""

" 3 ""

)""!

".'7. "."@

2 " .""2.+3

" ) ( )+3 ""

"*

"

.2.3* !! !!*)2.

3."2)"

"." -!!

!. ) 3!*'!

."32 *-!! : = = "- "" .""'

!3*". ".+"* . 2.! ! )"2! !

'

*31)"

.))

""'+" "*

. 2" .)' .

D-"6D"

==;6:+D. = 6 & 2'@

3 ) 0.

, . " - .2 ") "! "&'( )*" = + " !! "

!.2

."&2'"

!!

" "*. .2"2. .2

.") "

+32"

".-

".2 " "*. !"

".

" !

E- "" !

"

= : = +> !

!

.> !

. "3*"@

2 " . !

)!!

@. "

."F ."C

'"

"

=;": = )"

;+==+=;+ ;G+ ;

"C

( !<"(!

)""

7

."". ". .'" . .3*) ))"

!.."*+-+". FC-.) )!! "

A2 *-.) 2)"7. ".!..23'

""""2 " 3 "+" !! "- "." "* 7 !! "

! !

)"

) ""

" 31)"

.3*". ". .."

.)! ' " !) " " "

.+ !!-

..2.- ' 0" !

. "!""!

'

. * 4(( 0" !

. !)2.." )2. )"

"

!" . "4(, = 0"" !

. ")'"")2"- )! .4(, = 0" !

. "!""!

"*

. * 4(( ; !

?"" "

.2) )

.2 " !

) " . <

")2! )2' "* ) 2)3* " "

. ".23'

.' 3!

+! " !<2"

""" !! " !" .- .

A2".2 "* ..".2 "

;

!! " !

.""12 ' ) " ; ..3*! " !<2"- )-. ..3* ! , ." )">2 +? ! 12 ' )" ; G F!

+" !! ".

!"

." " 2! ) !

7.23'

.'3*("-

,!

-!+ ! )2 .! .

"3

B )2 .! " !! " 2 "" " " .

!"

"".2 " "*

" 2) !)"""

")!2'

- .

* . "

")!2'

))2 "

"* .

. " . $E, + " D. = 6 . ) " !

) " .' 7 !! ..

H3 (""

1H.3

....

" !".

)""

' "..'

""3*,0 ?!

) ,0

+ " !! " ) ."2)" 32 *-!!2 " !"- )-.'!

.3*&'( )*" F'". )".+ ....

" "*." .

" ")" . ....

. "!""!

'

. !

.+ "

-.' 3*" !!

)"

" "*C "") "E" !*"") " ! "" !

" "" +". ".)" )!!* ' """.2 " "* .)' .

D-"6D"

==;6 :+D.= 6 - )-.).H3 (""

1HC

">'3 $E, "* G

")!2'

)2!"

"

-.).H@31!@ H. "

. !

."

!!"<2"+(0

'

""""" . 2" "*

.0.

,."""" " .

" 2)A2".2 "*

" ' "32" .2))-. 2) (0

'

""

.)..E'

"

"" . " " "

....

"*!.'

"""" ". " ....

*" . " !! "! .- .H@31!@ H

2)

C" . !. "-"* "" .

. !

."

!!"<2"+F ."C

'"

"=;": = )"

;+==+=;+ ;G+ ;

"C ( !<-. "

." 3*> !

!

.> !

. "+"(!

)""

7 $E,: .") * "F ."C

'"

"-

> !

!! ""= 6?

.-. .2 " "*3 2).3* "

"*

' > "

+.

, !- .

)" "*

22. ....

".'?2"

").+" !!

. !

. !.

.

$E(0=6 )! ' "" " .2 " "* . . )."! ) ) * "*)" )!!*

"" 2).".' '

> "

!.

.)..E'

"

+" !! ".""""

!" . ""." "( )*" ')

"

7 . )". " !*

)"""" !! ") )!"'" !6

: "2 )".3*

-

!.+ .!. """" !*

"

" !! ."." "( )*" ')

) . 2"!* . "3

" 23!

)"! 0 '

""!*+".2 "! .- 3*3 (""

1 " !! " 2) )" ..

@31 !@ " ""+"

' ' ".

)- 3

....

" "*+ ".3

"!*!3*!

."

!!"<2"""".2 " "* . " ! 3

3*"&'( )*" " !! ". ) ) "".'C"

.""3*)

32 *-!!" !! "-. !*"*

" " "* 72.+"3

'

" !+ .3* ..

)