High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/47411/2023allowed

Kamaljit Singh @ Kamal v. State Of Punjab

2023-11-06Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri9 pages

!"# !$%&%"'() ) *+,-% .%'/01*+, )))))! % %"'!2 3!2&4& . !"#4'-5 ))))) !&6"'7!'

).. . 2!&!'

2) :%'7!2%2.%'/0;7:"$ ! #"2 0!6! % %"'!2)

2)).).% ; ;4'-5) . . ;)<2,= ) 0!62!&!' %&#"42 06! % %"'#%,!74'7!2.!$ %"' >"# 0!

"7!"#2%+%',2"$!742!#"2/2' "#2!/4,25%, " 0!6! % %"'!2%'$&! 5!2%'/ ")7 !7?)) ;4'7!2.!$ %"'& ;>;"# 0! .$ ; >?;2!/%& !2!7 ",%$!. %"'.6!$%,&@"2$!; %& 2%$ .A%'/;../2< "0,%=0:%'/-42%&7%$ %"' %& 2%$ 9470%') ) 0&5!!'&45+% !75B,!2'!7$"4'&!,#"2 0!6! % %"'!2 0 0!6! % %"'!2%&%'$4& "7B&%'$!?)) '7!2,%!20!C&/2' !7 %' !2%+5%,5B"

"27%' !!'$0"# 0%&"42 C%$!'7# !2!D$,47%'/ 0! " ,6!2%"7"#%' !2%+5%,0%&$4& "7B$"+!&"4 "5!B!2&'7 +"' 0&)!#42 0!2&45+% !7 0 !2,%!2#"2 0!#%2& %+! 0!6! % %"'!2C& /2' !7%' !2%+5%,5B 0!"

"27%' !!'$0"# 0%&"42 "' 0!/2"4'7 0 0!# 0!2"# 0!6! % %"'!2C&&4##!2%'/#2"+'$!2'7'"C0%&# 0!2 0&6&&!7CB;54 0!6! % %"'!2&422!'7!2!7C!,,%' %+!)0!2!# !2;0!

C&/%'/2' !7%' !2%+5%,5B 0!"

"27%' !!'$0"# 0%&"42 "' 0!

/2"4'7 0 0%&/!7+" 0!2C&&4##!2%'/#2"+%,,'!&&'7 0!2!# !2,&"; 0!&422!'7!2!7C!,,%' %+!)!&45+% !7 0 %' 0%&CB; 0! " ,$4& "7B "# 0!6! % %"'!2$"+!&"4 "5!B!2&'7+"' 0&'7'"C 0!

62"&!$4 %"'C% '!&&!&0:!5!!'!D+%'!7 %,,7 !"4 "#$% !7C% '!&&!& 7!&6% ! 0!#$ 0 0!$02/!&C!2!#2+!7"'));C0%$0%&,+"& B!2'7 +"' 0&/") ) 9!2'!7$"4'&!,#"2 0!6! % %"'!2#42 0!2&45+% !7 0 0! 6! % %"'!20&$,!'' !$!7!' &'7%&'" %':",:!7%''B" 0!2$&!'70& 5!!'#,&!,B%+6,%$ !7%' 0!62!&!' $&!"' 0!5&%&"#6",% %$,2%:,2B) !,&"&45+% !7 0 , 0"4/00%&'+!0&#%/42!7%' 0! 0 &!$2!

%'#"2+ %"'C&2!$!%:!75B 0!6",%$! 0 0!6! % %"'!2,"'/C% 0 0! " 0!2$"

$$4&!7C!2!7!,%'/C% 0 0!54&%'!&&"#!2"%';54 &"#2& 0! 62!&!' 6! % %"'!2 %& $"'$!2'!7; 0! %& '" %':",:!7 %' 'B " 0!2 $&! C0 &"!:!2'70!0&5!!'#,&!,B%+6,%$ !7"',B5!$4&!"# 0!6",% %$, 2%:,2B) ' "27!2 " &45& ' % ! 0%& 2/4+!' &; 0! 2!#!22!7 " 0! %' !2,"$4 "2B"27!2&C0%$00:!5!!'6&&!75B 0!,!2'!7 2%,"42 '7 60" "$"6%!&"# 0!&+!0:!5!!'62"74$!75!#"2! 0%&"42 '7C0%,! 2!#!22%'/ " 0! &+!; &45+% !7 0 # !2 0! #2+%'/ "# $02/!& "' ));2!6! !7,B&4++"'&'75%,5,!C22' &C!2!%&&4!7 " 0! 62"&!$4 %"'C% '!&&!&;C0"2! 0!6",%$!"##%$!2&C0"7%7'" $2! " 7!6"&!5!#"2! 0!"42 '7#"2'4+5!2"# %+!&;5%,5,!C22' &C!2! %&&4!7/%'& 0!62"&!$4 %"'C% '!&&!&)!,&"&45+% !7 0 !:!'&!2%"4& '" !C& @!'5B 0!,!2'!7 2%,"42 & "C0B 0!62"&!$4 %"'C% '!&&!& 2!'" 66!2%'/5!#"2! 0!"42 )!#42 0!2&45+% !7 0 !:!' %,,7 !; 0!))"# 0!62!&!' $&!0&'" 5!!'!D+%'!7)

) 9!2'!7$"4'&!,#"2 0!6! % %"'!20&2!#!22!7 " 0!-47/+!' & "# 0!"'E5,!.462!+!"42 6&&!7%'F. !'7!2*4+2' %,3&)!' 2, 42!4"#':!& %/ %"''7'" 0!2G;< =. ;F "07) 4&,%+1 4&&%'3&). !<"# !,0%=G; <.= ( ?;.6!$%,9!:! "

66!,<2%+%',=")((>"# % ,!7&F 0!!2-*4+2.04@,3&) 0! . ! "# 2 27!&0G '7 .6!$%, 9!:! " 66!, <2%+%',= ") (>"# % ,!7&F 5%2@&03&)0!. !"#7%&0G'7,&" 2!#!22!7 " 0!, !& -47/+!' "# 0!"'E5,!.462!+!"42 6&&!7%' .6!$%,9!:! "66!,<2%+%',=")? ??"#F '%&0.%&"7%3&) !' 2,42!4"#':!& %/ %"'G7!$%7!7"') )'7$"' !'7!7 0 @!!6%'/%':%!C 0!#"2!&%7,"'/$4& "7B6!2%"7"# 0!6! % %"'!2C0%$0 $"+!&"4 "5!B!2&'7+"' 0&; 0!52$"' %'!74'7!2.!$ %"'"# 0! .$ C%,,'" 66,B " 0!6! % %"'!2) ) ' 0! " 0!2 0'7;

2) ).) .% ; ,!2'!7 ; 4'-5 &45+% !7 0 &"#2& 0!$4& "7B"# 0!6! % %"'!2%&$"'$!2'!7; 0!&+! %&$"22!$ )!#42 0!2&45+% !7 0 % %&,&"$"22!$ 0 !2,%!2 C%$! 0! 6! % %"'!2C&/2' !7%' !2%+5%,"' 0!/2"4'7"#%,,'!&&"#0%&62!' &'7 0!&422!'7!2!7C!,,%' %+!)!,&"&45+% !7 0 0!6! % %"'!2%&'" %':",:!7%''B" 0!2$&!&6!20%&%'& 24$ %"'&)!;0&0"C!:!2;"66"&!7 0!/2' "#2!/4,25%, " 0!6! % %"'!2"' 0!/2"4'7 0 0!2!C& 2!$":!2B"#@/&)'7 /2+&"#!2"%'#2"+ 0!6! % %"'!2'7 0!$" $$4&!7;C0%$0#,,&%' 0!$ !/"2B"#$"++!2$%,H4' % B;'7 0!2!#"2!; 0!62B!2"# 0!6! % %"'!2%&0% 5B 0!52$"' %'!74'7!2.!$ %"'"# 0! .$ ) () 0:!0!27 0!,!2'!7$"4'&!,&#"2 0!62 %!&) ) %& $&! C0!2! 0! " , $4& "7B "# 0! 6! % %"'!2 # !2

!D$,47%'/ 0!6!2%"7"#%' !2%+5%,$"+!&"4 "5!B!2&'7+"' 0&) 0!$02/!&C!2!#2+!7"'))'7&6!2 0!%' !2,"$4 "2B"27!2& &2!#!22!7 "5B 0!,!2'!7$"4'&!,#"2 0!6! % %"'!2 0 #"2'4+5!2"# %+!&;5%,5,!C22' &C!2!%&&4!7/%'& 0!62"&!$4 %"'C% '!&&!&;C0" 2! 0!6",%$!"##%$%,&'7 %,,7 !!:!' 0!))0&'" 5!!'!D+%'!7 , 0"4/0 C% '!&&!&0:!5!!'!D+%'!7%' 0!62!&!' $&!)0!6! % %"'!2 %&& !7 "5!0:%'/$,!'' !$!7!' &'7%&'" %':",:!7%''B" 0!2$&! &6!2 0!,!2'!7$"4'&!,&#"2 0!62 %!&) ?)

42%'/ 0!$"42&!"#2/4+!' &;&6!$%#%$H4!2BC&2%&!7 " 0!. !$"4'&!,& "C0 C& 0!-4& %#%$ %"'& "C0B 0! 2%,"42 C&$"'& 2%'!7 "%&&4!5%,5,!C22' &2!6! !7,B'7 @%'/& 2%$ '" ! "#'"'

7!6"&%'/"#62"&!$4 %"'C% '!&&!& "C0%$00!$"4,7'" "##!2'B !D6,' %"') >) 0!"'85,!.462!+!"42 %' . !'7!2*4+2' %,8&$&! <&462=7%&$4&&!7 0%&%&&4!C% 02!/27 "7!,B%' 2%,'7% &!##!$ "' 0! 2%/0 ",%#!4'7!22 %$,! "# 0!"'& % 4 %"'"#'7%)2") >"# 0!

#"2!&%7-47/+!' %&2!62"74$!7&4'7!2 >).45 &!$ %"'< =+'7 !&$"42 & "$"' %'4!

0!62"$!!7%'/&"'7B "

7B5&%& %,, 0!$"+6,! %"'

"# 0!!:%7!'$!)0!2!#"2!;"'$! 2%,& 2 &;% &0"4,7 2!$0 0! ,"/%$, !'7) 32%"4& 7%2!$ %"'& 0:! 5!!' %&&4!7 5B 0%& "42 '" " /%:! 4''!$!&&2B 7-"42'+!' &2!&4, %'/%' 0!C% '!&&!&5!%'/C"'":!2) "C!:!2; 0!'"'

$"+6,%'$!"#.!$ %"'>$"' %'4!& C% 0 /B 5'7"') !206& $"42 & ,"'! $''" 5! #4, !7& 0!2!2!+4, %6,!2!&"'& 0 ,!7 "&4$0 7-"42'+!' &)0"4/0 0!&!$ %"'+@!&7-"42'+!' & '7 0 ""'" #"2,"'/!2 %+!6!2%"7&'!D$!6 %"';

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

:%& 0!52$"' %'!7.!$ %"'"# 0!

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

(C0%$0%&66,%$5,! ""##!'$!&4'7!2 0! .

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

<.462= 0&7!, C% 0 0!%&&4!"#62","'/!7%'$2$!2 %"')0!2!,!:' 6"2 %"'"# 0!-47/+!' %&2!62"74$!7&5!,"C )&2!/27 " 0! C%'$"'7% %"'&$"' %'!7%'.!$ %"' "# 0! .$ ;,!2'!7$"4'&!,#"2 0!2!&6"'7!'

. !0&5!!'74,B0!27)04&; 0! & $"'7% %"'& '7& $"+6,%!7C% 0)."#2& 0!'7$"'7% %"'2!#"2+ %"' "#"6%'%"'& "C0! 0!2 0!2!2!2!&"'5,!/2"4'7& " 5!,%!:! 0 0!6! % %"'!2%&'" /4%, B; 0!&+!+B'" 5!#"2+!7 0%&& /!C0!'0!0&,2!7B&6!' +"2! 0' 02!!'70,#B!2&%'$4& "7B)0!62","'/!7 %'$2$!2 %"'; /!'!2,,B +%,% !& /%'& 0! +"& 62!$%"4&#4'7+!' ,2%/0 /42' !!74'7!22 %$,! "# 0! "'& % 4 %"' '7 %' &4$0 &% 4 %"'; 0! $"'7% %"',,%5!2 B+4& ":!22%7! 0!& 4 "2B!+52/" $2! !74'7!2.!$ %"'< =<5=<%%="# 0! .$ )G )

!$!' ,B; 0!"'E5,!.462!+!"42 %' '%&0.%&"7%E&$&!

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

0%&$&!C0!2! K &"#7!6"&% "2&0:!5!!' 7!#247!7)0!,,!/ %"'&0:! "5!!& 5,%&0!7'7 62":!')0!2%/0 "5%,%'$&!&"#7!,B;$"46,!7C% 0 %'$2$!2 %"'#"2,"'/6!2%"7;7!6!'7%'/"' 0!' 42! "# 0!,,!/ %"'&;&0"4,75!2!7%' ".!$ %"' >"# 0!

"7!'7.!$ %"' "# 0! 9$ )0!2!&"'%& 0 0!$"'& % 4 %"',+'7 !%& 0!0%/0!2,C;'7% %& 0! 5&%$2%/0 "# 0!6!2&"'$02/!7"#'"##!'$!'7'" $"':%$ !7; 0 0!5!!'&42!7'7/%:!'&6!!7B 2%,) A0!' 0! 2%, %& '" 62"$!!7%'/ #"2 2!&"'& '" 2%54 5,! " 0!$$4&!7; 0!$"42 ;4',!&& 0!2!2! /""72!&"'&;+BC!,,5!/4%7!7 "!D!2$%&! 0!6"C!2 "/2' 5%,)0%&C"4,75! 24!2C0!2! 0! 2%,C"4,7 @!B!2&)G

) ':%!C"# 0!#"2!&%7#$ &'7$%2$4+& '$!&!&6!$%,,B $"'&%7!2%'/ 0!,"'/$4& "7B"# 0!6! % %"'!2C0%$0%&B!2&'7+"' 0&; 0! %,,'!&& "# 0! +" 0!2 "# 0! 6! % %"'!2 '7 0! #$ 0 C%$! 0! 6! % %"'!2C&/2' !7%' !2%+5%,'70!&422!'7!2!7C!,,%' %+!; 0%& "42 %&"# 0!:%!C 0 0!7!,B%' 0! 2%,C&'" 0!5!0!& "# 0! 6! % %"'!2 54 C& 5!$4&! "# 0! '"' 7!6"&% %"' "# 0! 62"&!$4 %"'

C% '!&&!&'7 0!2!#"2!; 0!52$"' %'!74'7!2.!$ %"'"# 0! .$ C%,,'" 66,B " 0!6! % %"'!2%' 0!,%/0 "#2 %$,! "# 0!"'& % 4 %"' "#'7%'7,&"%' 0!,%/0 "# 0!#"2!&%7-47/+!' &"# 0!"'E5,! .462!+!"42 "#'7%) ) "'&%7!2%'/ 0!#"2!&%7 " ,% B"# 0!$%2$4+& '$!&"# 0! 62!&!' $&!; 0%&"42 7!!+&% #% '762"6!2 "/2' 2!/4,25%, " 0! 6! % %"'!2)"'&!H4!' ,B; 0!62!&!' 6! % %"'%&,,"C!7'7 0!6! % %"'!2%& "27!2!7 "5!2!,!&!7"'2!/4,25%,"'#42'%&0%'/5%,5"'7K&42! B5"'7 " 0!& %&#$ %"'"# 0! 2%,"42 K 4 B /%& 2 !$"'$!2'!7;%#'" 2!H4%2!7

> %''B" 0!2$&!) () "C!:!2;'B 0%'/"5&!2:!70!2!%'5":!&0,,'" 5! 2! !7& '!D62!&&%"'"#"6%'%"'"'+!2% &"# 0!$&!'7%&"',B+!' #"2 0! 6426"&!"#7!$%&%"'"#62!&!' 6! % %"') () ) <. . =