High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/209/2015dismissed

Balbir Singh v. Jaswant Singh And Another

2019-05-21Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh8 pages

!"#$%& ""'

&%%!

! ""## $%#&&

& !%& '()

# ! " ((((( "'

&%%!)# * & " ""# + &! & !!( *( % +, (& &# +, "-"#&&

"!& &!" )! )##

.%!+, &#*( &( )!

/ ""#" +,((!! (# -""##& & (%& &&#0&&!1( 2

&+ "-"#&&

&# (& %& ## & ""## ## &"( # & )

-4"!!& /

-4 % ), 3 # % + 5!( (" . 3 5!(& && # % 5 (" 6 . 7 & "-"#&&

#%,)&,%&##& " ) &" ) +( -""## &#5!( #8! (& ""##- &# %&) !#&)& &#%&5!#(& "& #&&"(8 & ## ## & %& ) # !&" ), &#&+&#&,5!( #8& "# ## )& +&! !+, " + &#3 ""##(## &!"

-9 &

9 & & - 9 &

9 & & )+#:)"""& !( )( !+, ) , +#: )" "" "-"#&&

#%""%& #" %&1%&

;"#&&

&#+ 9 &

## )&# ) "#&%&%& ", &)&# (& "#&!&% &#+, "-"#&&

4& &:& "#&% &#! & )&& %&) &#*( )&( "(!&#" < ( )3 "&%")&(! &!&("" &"!& !&8 & !(# "&& #&

)&#! &#*(!!" # # &#) "-"#&&

: "!& &! " )! !!%& &!& "#&&

"& +#! # !&& %& & ) "& & )( ""## ##5!( #%& &"& % ) 7 ! &# 5!( # & %#

" "-"#&&

#5!(

"! *( + &! &+ ( ) ! " +, &#*( %

&) & ""# & ""## *( !!( %& &# *( %& ( , &! ""##% &#4& !"# && %&)%(# ( )## + "" +#: & ( ""## 7& ( 1% &

"#&&

% 5)& & ! 7 & ! 5)&& )& 9#+&&

8+&

& %& ) && & &## $(#% &

& (!# & 9#+& &

8 ( )& $(#%&

" !))&& !,9 ("&&

& 8+&

#+ 9#+&&

& %&7&

( ( 9#+&&

8+&

& %& # & "& #& &!5)&& 5" && ! $(#%&

&& !))&& !, +(&8& 9 ("&&

9#+&&

=4% " -$(#%&

*)",7 #" & ! 5)&& )& & + 9 ("& &

%" -$(#%&

*)",+( , 7& )#, ( 9#+&&

=4&!!#

!() &!!&%& &)-$(#%&

*)", %& !#& !"#&+, ""##%& +#:& (+& +&+, !))&& ),!)

7&& && ( "(# #%(# # "!& &+% #& &" !" "&!(##, # (#& !" && (# %& )%!)"# +,%&& (" &" % &!

& ( 9#+&&

;""##%+& % ""%#,& +#:7& ( ( " &5)&,& %& !()>56 &% &!

5!(& # % ## #, 5 (" .

" &##! ! &!& &!" !()>56 ""## (+)& (& "!, ""# &# ""#&!& )) %& ) )%&)&+, &#*( &

""#&!& % &# (!& &&# &!+( )%#&)& &.

7 & ( & &""#" + 0&&!1( 2

&+ ""##!

&% +,""#&!& )) %&)&&# &!%&)& +, &#*(7& ( &""##*( # %& !

& ( )"+, ""##*(&#&+#+& &!#) )&! ""##*( !&& ""# #& %& !

"+, &#*(&)&& &""#&!& #(+)&&)+,!(#& " ) # #% +#

-4"!+(

& #(

+"(!+,%, &&# &! # % # .

-4 " ! (

&!& ! (+ & !! (& # *(#"& "-"#&&

("" !!( !+, *(7& ( &&"

*(&!""#4""!& &!& %& !!( ")& &

&%&"&+#7 & )#, ( ""## &#):(! !& *( (

) " &, ?(& #%& )&&+, &*( 7 !(# "& "( ""4+: ! 9 & (+)&&)+,!(# "& &&"""& ""##- &

& & ( ) # # !() %& 5& &) 5!(& && # ""##)(+)&&& + & ) ! 9#+& &

8+ &

=4 & %& # %" -$(#%&

*)", $(#%&

& #* !

"#(!# &9#+&&

7 &&

&!(# ) % ""##!& ,

& !& & 9#+& &

=4 % #& " - $(#% &

*)", $(#% &

"" + "# (!# & 9#+& &

% ! & 5)& & #&

) & & " %& ) % & & + ## (## &!"

-9 &

< 9 & &-9 &

9 )+#:)" ""& !( )( ! ""##&- &

9 & & +#:& )""" "#&&

% &!

)## +""7 & !5)&& "#&&

&%& & ! &-9 &

9 % & !!& "#&&

& %&%& &-9 &

9 & &7

& !&!()! ""## ! & , & !& ) !#&!&&!5)&& 1%&

9#+&&

#% &!

%!&+ +, '()&

9# !=46&! !()&

4%& &&&

&!(#!!" %&!)&&!)"# !!(!,%& "!& &4 #& !, &! +& "!& &+% #&&#) (#

& &:#& ) + "" +#: & ( &#+#)"""3 ""## )& )""" % &!

) + %"(!

+, &) (

& & )%"(!

:& "#&&

7 )" "" % "(!

+, &)#

), + :& "#&&

+""(+, ""## &+#:& (%+&+,-9 &

9 & & !( ! & &) #& & +#& #,@ ) , # !& ""## ) # +""+#:& ( &

#,+!+, *()&& !+, &*(

/ ""## %(# ( ""## *( & !

?( " +, &# *( &)&& ""#&!& )) %&)&&# &!(# ( ) &""##*(%(# # &&# ! (+)&&)+,!(# ""## *( ) 7 ( ""# + &*( (!

!& +& !(# ""## + & ""## *( ) , (+)&& &# " & )&!##( ""#&!& +( *()&: #%& )",), & &( ( &# ! +( (# ( "(& !( &

""##!+ , ( )!"+, &""##*(&#&+#+ && &% &(+)&& ))&! ""##*( !&& 3 &" !&,&!

*( "!& (# ## & )# & (+& +& )&# ! 7 & &% ) 7 &,)&&!& ""##&"!

&&)&& &""#&!& (

#, (" # & "! % ""#&!& &&# &! % &)& 2&#, &?(!, # !&&& ( & # #!#, &&&

&!(# !)" %!()%& #!&&(# )&#!%& #!& (5 # !+(,% &))&) +(,"",

"&! &4B4 & % &&

#,"#!7 & &% ) ""## ! & , & !& ) # ) "&!(##, & ""#&!& (!& &&# &! % &)& +, &# *( !

+"+ &""## *(#,@ ), # &)(!

#" &,& !& *( %& & & 2( ) """#&?(& #%)(!

# (+&# ?(&)&&& (#!""# 7 &% % +&!( &+ )& ""# &# & !!& #, &)& %& ! ""# +!&)& ""#&!& !& #,&

&#& 4 &#& ""# !)&!# !#, C0'(#&D = ":& - ,- = "+# ,-