High Court of Punjab and HaryanaTA/133/2013dismissed

Harvinder Kaur v. Jagdish Pal Singh Bindra

2015-05-04Mr. Justice J.C. Verma9 pages

!"#$%&& '() "!

(*'+(

( - (.+.

/,0

,! '1! .2 '03 "12 "!('

", # 5/

3 3 3

",#$

(3+" 0*+6'( 2('7!)',

(,2 (

( 3 '"!2'8'7!)',

(,2 ",

- !

,2 . '440 ', "7 '440 '",$8 36, '() "!

( *'+(

9.,('". ('4 , , "+"!

(3 , ",2 "!+ '(( '1 ,7 :&&2 "', (6 ", "

!'.,2 , 0 !;<( ",$2+.;'"!/, 0

,! '1! .2 '03 "12 "!('(6 ',2'"9,,',2 "!'",2

1(+"!,2',.2 .( . ! "1', '64+(' 2+0 .,( ,',2 "!'

'"!! .,'"

',2'"9, .6( ,2'"*6.82 '.',2 "!' ."0<','! .,'"

'(+"!*6.(6 '64+(' 2+0, .6 ", "

!,2',4 "!

"< , , "', ',2'"9,'+.

.2 ( 6;'(('..6 ",'"!2'('..6 ",',,2 2'"!.

,2 2+.;'"! 2 .4 , , "2'.;

".,("10<", ., ",$ 2+.;'"!3 ( +.0<", ., "12 (40 ',2',.2 .4 ",0<0 ) "1',

'64+(' 2+07 , .0' 6 !,2',7 "',7,2 .'(

"'(!20!

('"!

. .,'< "1 " '0, 6( '(<0'"!

7 3 82 .2 . 640< ! " '

2.4 ,'0 '"! "0< '. "'00< ) . ,. "! ' , 6

, 2 ( 0! ',2 ( '"!

<+"1 (;(,2 (.', '64+(' 2+0, .+(1 !,2',2 (40 '4 ", . !

', '64+(' 2+02'.;

! " ",2 4(

! "1.+"!

, " & ( 82 2 8 4 "! "1 ;

( 3+;$ ) . "'0 +! '0

'1 .,(', 7 2+0782 ,2 ! !",4(!+ 2 (4'..4(, ".+44(, (0' 6) "!

.4 , 2') "1;

"1('", !0'.,44(,+" ,<7,2 2'!

", 4+, " '44 '('"

;

( ,2 .' ! +(, ( .+0, "1 " ' . "

'!=+("6 ",2 (4 , , "+"!

(3 , "&( ('440 ', "( ,( )'0 ,2 '440 ', " 8'. !

'0, 8 ,2 ;< 3+;$ ) . "'0 +! '0

'1 .,(', '"!3 .. ".+!1 7',2 "!'(!

(.82 2'+,2( , .'(

+"!

(2'00 "1 ",2 .+(,;<8'<( 6 "'0 .&& , .0' 6 ",$2+.;'"!,2',2 2'.4' ! .> 0'.7 .:7?$ '"! .&7?$ '. 6' ", "'"

, ,2 8 " ,2(

'. ".!+( "1,2 4(

! "1.2 (4 , , "+"!

(3 , "&( "2 2'!+"!

(,'9 ",4'<,2 '6+",'(( '(.6' ", "'"

7 '"<74 "! "1'1' ".,2 6 %

(6,2 (!7 ,,('".4 ( .,2', " ('440 ', "( ,('". (,2 , , "8'.6) 82 28'.! .6 ..

) "( 84 , , " 0 !'1' ".,,2 .' !(!

(! .6 ..'07 2'!'0.6 ,,2 ', ": & +".

0(,2 4'(, .2') ;

"2 '(!82 0 1 "1,2(+12,2

4'4 (;9 @ , ,2 +,.

,7 +".

0 ( ,2 ( ",$2+.;'"! 2'.

A+ ., "

!6' ",' "'; 0 ,<,2 ",4 , , "782 0 (( "1,(!

!', !4'..

!;<,2 .+(, "%B

+( "1

! "1.,2 .' ! (,('". ('440 ', "70' 6,2 2+.;'"!'.

. ",2 ",4 , , "78'.,2',,2 8'.",( . ! "1', '64+('

2+07'.8'.0' 6 !;<2 ( 4, "140 ',2 2+.;'"!'"! "! "1,2

'440 ', ",2 ,;

) !'"<6 ( ,7,2 8'.! .6 ..

008 "10 "

.(!

(!', !,2 .+(,'( ", 8(,2<7 82 2(( '!<( 7'( '44 "!

!'.;

08# !" #$%&

( (

( ( )

* (

(( % (

+ ) ( ( , (D > ) "( 84 , , "4( A+'.' !(!

(!', 8'.! .6 ..

!":82 "0 ;

(,<28 (8'.1 ) ,,2 , 0 '( .24 , , "7 '"<1(+"!(,('". (8'. E ., ", B ",4 , , " .=+.,,2 , , ",2 (4 , , "7 82 2'.", ! (78'.! .6 ..

!"6 ( ,.,"0<') (6 ",. "

4'('.,&,2 .4 , , "'( E',0<,2 '.,2 8 ",2

(4 ;+, "1(+"!.(,('". (,2 '.2') ;

"1 ) "4'(':'0"18 ,2.+;$4'('.,2 , , "7'( '0.,2 ( .2 1(+"! ', ( ! .6 ..'0 ,2 ( '440 ', " ( ,('". (7 2'. ;

! ( .,';0 .2 ! " ( 40< , ,2 4( ", '440 ', "7 40 ' ,2

2+.;'"! "4'(',2 .'.+"!

(# C (

.( ( (

&.( % /

% % (

(( % %

(D : ."( 4+! ', ",2 .0' 6,2 ",$2+.;'"! , . ) !

",,2',,2 ",4 , , " .",2 "1;+, "'("', ",2 "

8 ,2+,'"<"

8'+.

', "

82 24 , , "8'.! .6 ..

( ,.) !

,' 0 !(!

(,2 .+(," +".

0(,2 ($8 2'.+(1 !,2',") .,;

"3+44(,2'.;

".+12,(6

!" #$% &# 3+44(,2'.

'0. ;

" .+12, (6 ' (

)

* (

% '#' # $ & # +(1 "1 ,2', 82 8 8'.

640< !'"!2'!'.6'002 0!0 ) "18 ,22 (( , ( !4'( ",.7.+ , 0 ;<,2 2+.;'"! "2 ""' 12+(,0' 6 "1 .&0'.('+. "1

6, "'04' "'"!.+ ( "1 ,78'.,('". !8 ,2 ",2 =+( .! , " '0+,,' 12+(,", "1,2 ',,2',+(,2 ('.

",2

4'(, .8 '0.4 "! "18 ,2 ",2 =+( .! , "'0+,,' 12+(,'"!

",$2+.;'"!2'!'0.;

",('". !(62 ""' , +6;' 3+44(,2'.'0.;

".+12,(6 + &

' , & & -"'#'#"

&# 82 ($8 2'!,86 "(!'+12, (.'"!,2 8'."6'0 6 6;

,'64'"<2 (,',, "!4(

! "1.+"!

(3 , ">,2 34 '0

'(( '1 ,7:&%,('". (82 24(

! "1.(6 02 ,,2 +(,',

'"29+0'2'!;

".+12,('". (2'!;

"'008 !7 ", ('0 '7",2

1(+"!,2',"

>6",2.0!!'+12, (8'.( . ! "18 ,2,2 '"!,2

"!"

8'.'0.6 "(3+44(,2'.'0.;

".+12,(6 &

, & ( +

/0' #!%$ & # 82 '.

8'.,('". !(6 2'(, 02 '.,2 8'.

8(9 "1'"!,2 8'.""

,.+44(,2 (', 2'(

2'.'0. ;

"6'!

,/ (

( $'#'# 12

',.,2 '.

"2'"!'( ", ( 0<! ",'.64'( !, ',.,2 , !'+,2( , .",2 ",'.

7') (6 ",.,2

",$2+.;'"! "2 .( 40<,,2 ",'440 ', "2') 6' "

+"",() (, !2 '( '.+"!

(# 2 ($8 .'4 ",( . !

", 3'"! .

1' "+00< 640< !,2 2 ($8 ..28",;

.6 ,2 (,2'",2

",2 "F ,2!'+12, (.,2 +40 2 "'( 6'(( ! " 3'"!'(

0 ) "1,2 '. 3 , G ".F % 2 4 ($8 2'! 0 ! ' 4 , , " +"!

( 3 , " & ( .

9 "1 6' ", "'"

(6 ( ",$2+.;'"! "

::@- !

(!', !B>,2 +(,"

!7 .' !4 , , "8'.. "

". 1"

!,,2 (!(6'.

8'.",4(.

+, ($8 (!

( B>4'..

+! '0 '1 .,(', .,0'..7',2 "!'

.( 4(!+ !'.;

08# 0+/ 1+

(

, 2 (

(

$%-&

$%/4

$ %

( (

(

2 *

(

$ #26

71 +% D & H ,2+, .

9 "1 ( .,(', " . "

'!=+("

, , "+"!

(3 , "&( 7,2 ($8 2'!

0 !< ,'",2 (4 , , "+"!

(3 , "&( "

> (!

(.4'..

3+;$ ) . "'0+! '0

'1 .,(', 7',2 "!''"!3 .. ".+!1 7',2 "!'A+'

,2', '( +"!

( 2'00 "1 ', ,2 ".,'"

",$2+.;'"! " ,2 . +(, ) !

( 6 "'0

00'"

+.&&?F @ 2 ( ", 2'. ", ;

" "

, "1 4'<6 ", 6' ", "'"

'6+", 4' ! .>0'.7 .:7?$ '"! .&7?$'.6' ", "'"

,,2 ('"!2'!

.28"2 .( '! "

..'"!8 00 "1"

..,4'< ",2

6' " "1 '6+", 6' ", "'"

7 '"<7 , ,2

.', .', ",2 (F'"!7 > '(0 (,('". ('440 ', "%B4( !;< ($8 ",2 '+.

', "'. .,2

4( ", "

7 8'. ! .6 ..

! " '"! 84 , , "'1' ".,,2',8'.! .6 ..

!": ") 8 ", ( 0<! ",',+'06',( E7"2 04(6,2

, !'+,2( , . .')' 0';0 ,,2 ($8 % 6., 64(,'", '.4 , . '. , 82 ( ,2 8 2'.

'44('2 !,2 .+(,8 ,20 '"2'"!.'"!2'.;

"' ( ""!+, "1'"!

'0 "18 ,2,2 ",4(

! "1.I. .;

"1 E40' "

!2 ', (7,2

'".8 ( .; 1, .';+"!'",0<0 '(,2',,2 ",'440 ', "( ,('". ( ..+;.,'", '00<,2 , , "82 28'.! .6 ..

!"6 ( ,."

'"! "( 8'440 ', "'1' ".,,2 2'!;

"! .6 ..

": & .""

81(+"!6'!

+,=+., < "1,('". (,2

! )( , , " 0 2+.;'"!', ',2'"9,,',2 "!'4'(, +0'(0< "".'6 40 '.,2 7'.", ! (7,('". ('440 ', "8'.

! .6 ..

!2 .",2 "1"( (!,.+44(,,2 ",4 , , "" ,.

8"6 ( ,7 .4 '00< ",2 8'9 ! .6 ..'0 (4 , , ",2

",2 1(+"!. @ H2 ",2 2+.;'"!". ., ",0< .,'9 "1+4'40 ',2',,2

.'(

"'(!20!

('"! .4 ",0<( . ! "1 " 3782 .2 .

1' "+00< 640< !','0, 6( '(<0'"!

7 3 "'2.4 ,'0'"!) . ,.

"! '"0<'"!",.

2 (0!',2 ('"!<+"1 (;(,2 (.', '64+('

2+07,2 +0!2') ;+,, !,2 .0' 6,2 2+.;'"!;<'""

E "1 4<2 (4'..4(,32 +0!2') 4() !2 (;"' !

.;<4(!+, " (', "'(!7, 42"

; 007 ,( ,<; 00 , "2 ("'6 ',2 ('00 . !

', '64+(' 2+0.28 "12 (0' 6 !", "+ !( . !

"! ' > ",2 ",('(<7,2 2+.;'"!2'.,'9 "4' ".,( (,4< (!

(.4'..

+(,.', '64+(' 2+02 (!

(4'..

3+;$ ) . "'0+! '0 '1 .,(', 7 '64+(' 2+0 .'.+"!

(# 8 "" %+

"9""%+ 9 *

!"+:" ( !"

( (

(

+ (

( &

(

D B .4 , ,2 . 0 '( (!

(7 " 640 '"

8'. 6'!

&2 +(,2'!4 ", !0<", !,2',,2 '440 '",$8 8'.", ", ., !,4'(,8 ,22 (4'..4(,2 (!

(!', !&,2 .' !

+(, .( 4(!+ !'.;

08# 8 3

" ( &

(( "'

;)"<=%3+"

"<71%3D : ) " ",2 ",4(

! "1.'.2'.'0( '!<;

"", !7 4<,2 4'..4(,8 ,2( )'", ",( .) . ,., 3(,"! '72'.

",;

"'""

! /'8 .",' , .'( "!( "! "!

!2 ." "

$+46'".2 4 "( "!.2 4/'8 .",;

!8'( !;<'0 , 1'",/'8 +(,..2+0!",;

4<16 .

!'0 , 1'",8'",.,,'9 +"!+ ;

,70'8 ! .",4 (6 , ,/'8',2 .+48 ,2,2 ) 0',(/'81 ) .;'06 "1 .+44(,'"!.+., "'"

,,2.

82.+;6 ,, ,'0 , 1'",.

9 "1.+( '"!.,( "1,2(60'87;',, (.'"!;(+ .

. , "., '!70'8! .",,'9 , 9 "!0<F"

(,2 0'8+(,.8+0!

($8 2'.,( !,) '2,2 0'8(682 2 , 2'!.+12,2 04,2(+12,2 .+(,2 , , " .0 '(0<'1(') 6 .+.

4( ..,2 +(,H2 ",2 ( .4 ",( . !

", 3 '"! .( . ! "1,2 '"!) . ,."! '"0<'. "'00<'"!;,2!'+12, (. ,2 .6'(( '1 '( .

,,0 ! " 3'. ,. , G ".'"!'( 6'(( !,2 7 ", (

! ,2 , , " .6 .+"!

! *

4 "1 ") 8"!+,,2 "! .0. "10 ..'"!

'0 "16( ,2 64(,'",',.782 "', (! .6 ..'02 ( '440 ', ""'"!( 8'440 ', "":7"( .2 1(+"! .6'!

+,7,2 .,('". ('440 ', " .! .6 ..

5'1+,,5 H2 (

4(, (.0'04'4 (.6'<;

'008 !,.

,2 =+!16 ",I . H2 (,;

!,,2

4(, (.(",I H2 (,2 =+!16 ",.2+0!;

4(, ! ",2 1 .,I .