Pushpa Devi And ORS v. Sajjan Singh And ORS

1-



   
 













































 

 !"#$!%&'&"()** 


 

 



























   ) +,

* -
 

 , 

  




 

  
 
 


  !!!



 ,.* ,





"




"#
% 
"

% 

&






$


'


($
)

%




*+

,-
&



$
  


& '



./0120.3





  
"#  

.
& 


"






4%0.%.350 2


 
"#

$
&


23..20./ 
"#




7$
8 "
 & 
)





*8 ",-

& % 
&







99 000:%
% 




'



$ 
&

"#
"


$


 %



& $ 

$













%

$
&

"#
"



"


 






'

"

 #

25 8 "





&

&
$%  ; 
.</<0:% =

 


<.5/:%
>
50?

8 

;
)210./@.2- 
002.3:% 
.:5 )

&


@  


- 
<1015:% ) 002.3:54


# 
221.32:% )
002.3:%
%

<1015:%-  

.3 4


 
302912:% )221.32@.34






200000:% )
10000:%
- =


@  
.1000:% 4



.1000:% 4










$

.30000:% )
50000:%
#"









.

58 
7$ 
#"


992192:% )
 99 000:%- 1 
 



"#
 % 
 

 


& 

"


'


 



"# "
4 "


 #




3- = "

 #
20.1
)A@.<-



20.1
)A@.3-
 
20.1
)A@.1-
# 20.1
)A@.5-

20.1
)A@. -
#
)A@.2-

20.1
)A@..- 

$"

20.1
)A@.0-

"

20.1
)A@9-
 $"

20.1
)A@/- +

$"

20.1
)A@<-
 #
20.3
)A@3-
= "

 #
20.3
)A@1- 


20.3
)A@5-
 
20.3
)A@ -

#
20.3
)A@2-
 #
 $ 

A@%
&
'



"

#



4

 

 % 



 "



' 


"

 
20.3
A@%
&

"#
.</<0:%
&



8

 #
&
#

2<
#



#
& '

2<
#
 

$ 
4  
% 
 




A@:5
 #








  20.3
&



"
#


0
#

"


&

.<010:% B

.<01:%
&
&


330:%




 &


220:%
$'
$ #



"

.9//1:% 3 ;

$





"

 %


8


&
"

$


"

"

 #



 



 


$

"




  

 #


$ 
"

 

"





8





$ 

A@:5
& "
 
 '


 





#
$ #



'



.9//1:%
)A@:5-





"




 
  
$
"#
 "
 $

#

&
21 # 

 



50?
.:5

& 



@  








C






$

&


$

$ 

.3
&
 
;

 
#

4-

$ < =

;



8 "



  












& 


 

$



 

$

"


 



 





 








"

 


$






$



#

$



"


&

$ /  :





&




"
 #

.9/ 1:%


% Income Rs.19,885/- per month Rs.19,885/- per month Future Prospects 40% (Rs.19,885+7954) Rs.27,839/- Deduction 1/4 (Rs.27,839-6,959) Rs.20,880/- Multiplier Total loss of dependency 20,880X16X12 Rs.40,08,960/- Loss of Estate Rs.15,000/- Funeral Expenses Rs. 15,000/- Loss of spousal consortium Rs.40,000/- (to claimant No.1) Rs.40,000/- Loss of parental consortium Rs.40,000/-X 2 (to claimant Nos.2 &3) Rs.80,000/- Loss of filial consortium Rs.40,000/-X 2 (to claimant No.4) Rs.40,000/- Total Compensation awarded by the Tribunal Rs.39,92,592/- Total Compensation awarded in appeal Rs.41,98,960/- Enhanced amount of compensation Rs.41,98,960/- (awarded in appeal) - Rs.39,92,592/- (awarded by the Tribunal) Rs.2,06,368/-

59  

&

"

$



"




>
<1?



$ 
8


$

"

 
#


"




& .0   
 )-

#
 
  

 ,

  **