Ashish Tyagi v. Rajiv Kumar
"#$
$%&'& ()** '+&'+,"-& .$#&#& ($/ 0$/'1'
"2&3415"/ *** $'6 (7$(#
/$'$(#) /*"3$$( &(-+"(8"/973 %"#$9
/#+$6$#&#& ($/* /*(:1/,"-&973 %"#$9
/#+$% 56;"&("(#* <<<<< =$"/($7% 1('$;
/#+$6$#&#& ($/'1>5&#'#+"##+ 1-+( 7 1># "'#+$7&'%/$#&
#+$;$"/($7#/&";% 1/## 7&'5&''#+$"66;&%"#& ( 1(7$/ $%#&
#+$/***9"'+"7>$$( &;$78$;;"
#$/ 3$5>$/9 ?9&*$*5 /$#+"(,$"/'"
#$/#+$% 56;"&("(#'@%/ ''$A"5&("#& (+"7 >$$( &(&#&";;, % (71%#$79 + 8$3$/9 #+$ /$"'
(
/ #+"# 8"' #+"# #+$ % 56;"&("(# 8"' >$&(- '
1-+# # >$ '155 ($7
/ 1/#+$/ %/ '' $A"5&("#& ( >$%"1'$ &( #+$ 5$"(8+&;$ +$ +"7 '$(# " 5$''"-$ ( BC+"#'"66D9";;$-$7;,'#"#&(-#+"#+$+"7 &;$7" ";'$%"'$"-"&('##+$ 6$#&#& ($/"(7#+"#+$8 1;78&#+7/"8&# ( *** + 1-+ #+$ 7"#$
#+$ '"&7 5$''"-$ &' ( # -&3$( &( #+$ "66;&%"#& &;$7>,#+$6$#&#& ($/1(7$/ $%#&
#+$/***% 6, (($A1/$?9";'
1(7"#$7!9;$"/($7% 1('$;'1>5&#'#+"##+$5$''"-$8"'
'$(# ( **E* #&%$
5 #& (*
##+&''#"-$9/*(:1/,"-&973 %"#$9"66$"/'"(7"%%$6#'
( #&%$ (>$+";
#+$/$'6 (7$(#"(7+"' &;$7"6 8$/
"## /($,98+&%+ &' /7$/$7# >$#":$( (/$% /7* $ '1>5&#' #+"# #+$ "66;&%"#& ( '$$:&(- # /$%";; #+$ /$'6 (7$(#% 56;"&("(#&' (;,"7$;",&(-#"%#&%"(7#+$/$
/$#+$/$8 1;7 >$( %"1'$
/#+&'% 1/## &(#$/ $/$8&#+#+$&561-($7 /7$/* "3&(-% ('&7$/$7#+$"
/$'"&7"/-15$(#9$3$(:$$6&(-&( 3&$8#+$ "%##+"##+$"66;&%"#& (1(7$/ $%#&
#+$/***8"'
"75&##$7;, &;$75 /$#+"( F,$"/'"
#$/#+$/$'6 (7$(#% 56;"&("(#+"7 >$$(%/ ''$A"5&($79;$"/($7% 1('$;
/#+$6$#&#& ($/ 1/#+$/'1>5&#'#+"# "'"5"##$/
"%##+$/$'6 (7$(#+"7";'
"75&##$7&(+&'/$6;,# #+$'"&7 "66;&%"#& ("% 6,
'1%+/$6;,+"3&(->$$("(($A$7"'(($A1/$G!9 #+"# B8+$( #+$ ";;$-$7 5$''"-$' 8$/$ '+ 8( # >$ '$(7 #+/ 1-+ 8+"#'"66H#$A# 5$''"-$'9 "# #+"# #&5$9 #+$ /$'6 (7$(#H% 56;"&("(# 8"'
-&3&(-$A"51(7$/&(+"(7&-"/+"(7+&'5 >&;$8"';,&(-&(#+$%"/
#+$>/ #+$/
#+$"66;&%"(#H"%%1'$798+&%+8"'61#>,0&3$:,"-& 73 %"#$&(#+"#%"/"'#+$/$'6 (7$(#H% 56;"&("(#%"(( #%"//,+&'5 >&;$ &(#+$$A"5&("#& (%$(#/$*
+$+"(7$7 3$/+&'5 >&;$# 0&3$:,"-& 73 %"#$61#+&'5 >&;$&(#+$%"/
#+$>/ #+$/
#+$"66;&%"(#H"%%1'$7 "(7 / 5#+$6/$'$(#"66;&%"#& (9&#&'51%+%;$"/#+"##+$'"&7";;$-$7 5$''"-$'8$/$'$(7>,#+$>/ #+$/
#+$"66;&%"(#H"%%1'$7("5$;,(:&# ,"-&D* &'% (#$(#& (#+$/$
/$&'#+"##+$/$'6 (7$(#+$/$&("75&##$7
#+"#5$''"-$8"''$(# / 5+&'#+$/$'6 (7$(#'@!5 >&;$6+ ($9#+ 1-++$ 7$(&$7+"3&(-'$(#&#* C&#+ 1# 5":&(- "(, % 55$(# ( #+$ "%#1"; 5$/&#'
#+$ % (#$(#& (/"&'$7>$
/$#+&'% 1/#"'/$-"/7'8+$#+$/ /( ##+$5$''"-$'
8$/$'$(#>,#+$/$'6 (7$(#98+&%+("#1/";;,8 1;7>$"5"##$/# >$ 6/ 3$7H7&'6/ 3$7>$
/$#+$#/&";% 1/#9#+$6$#&#& (&'";;
8$798&#+#+$ &561-($7 /7$/ '$# "'&7$* +$ #/&"; % 1/# &' 7&/$%#$7 # /$%";; #+$ /$'6 (7$(#% 56;"&("(#
/ 1/#+$/ %/ ''$A"5&("#& (9 8&#+ "7$I1"#$
/#1(&#,# >$-/"(#$7# #+$6$#&#& ($/H+&'% 1('$;# %/ ''$A"5&($#+$ % 56;"&("(#* 9# % 1(#$/8+"##+$6$#&#& ($/+"'% (#$(7$79#+$/$'6 (7$(# % 56;"&("(# &;$'"(,"66;&%"#&
/;$"7&(-"(, 1/#+$/$3&7$(%$9#+"# 1;7>$% ('&7$/$7 (&#' 8(5$/&#'>,#+$#/&";% 1/#"(7"("66/ 6/&"#$
/7$/6"''$7#+$/$ (*
3%-"/-H7&($'+