High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2100/2015dismissed

S.P. Goyal v. Hari Dutt Dumra Deceased Th Lrs Arvind Kumar Dumra And ORS.

2018-08-13Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan19 pages

!" "#$ $%& &

" #$

&( $ ")* $ '

&+ $$ ") $

,,,

&-./&-.-01 2$ $ "$ "

$ (" $3 4**$ 4$ $ 4 "

" 2$ $" "

""556-* $$ " $" " $

4 .7

" "

" " $$" $ " 2$'%"$ $

" "

* 8"

4* $ "$" 556& 9:* "

& 559:* " 4 "$ 8 " $ ""*$ $*

4" 4562$

""4*

! "

# "

$% &

() *

+ ) )

) ))

/0"

. 1 2 3 1

()

+ ) )

) ))

, 6

' )) 0 $ ) )

) '

" )

9 & 3+:

3 & &

0 &%& ;# (.,

" /

(

, /0"

)

) 3 <)(3

= , 0-6 !> /1399&90 - 9

6>099! / ?0"937 (, + )

)

) 3 < )

)

) )

) 3 < )

3 <<<<%8

* )

)

@ (',

)

) @<%/ > )

*/)

) -) @ >

)

0' (',

) ) ) ) &

)) '

(',/ '

* )

(',

' '

)

) )

' '

(', *

(*, + )

) '

)

' '

)

) )

)

(A, '

) )

) *

)

) )

)

* )

+ ) ) )

) ) '

2$" " $ "$

$ ""56 $ 8$ 2$ 4 + ;

$<""556

" $- " =)

> +%"$ & 559:?

$ $ $

4 $4:& %"$ 56 * $$4 + ;

$< " "" & +$ $ 8

>$" " "

2$ $

4 $4:& %"$ $"2$

""@5$ $&" $" 8$ ""4* $

$ 2$ $" $$$" ) $ * $$ "$ * 4 "" " "$$$" )"& 9: "-* ""$

$)$$ * & @+$ $< & " "

' ) $$ < * $ $ $" -

"$*"

8 $ $

$ $ $" " " "$ %&

* 4 $ " 2$*

* "4$%"2 3 A 6

* )

) )

C-..

' ) 3 <<<<%8

> ) C-..

@ 6

)

) C-..

) )

C-."

$ 6

)) ) >

) C -..

B -

)$ 8 "B:&* & "C - " =)

> +C$ &"%"$ "B &( $ *

" B 2$ " $ $ $ " 8 "

B: ' " 4$+ 3 ) / * 8 "

)/8 '&"%"$ DB:

) 2$' %"$ $ 56:DB: ) $C$

)$ )

" B:@D + "

" B:7B:E$>* $ >$ " ?

3$ " $* 8 "

)$ "E $" DB:6 + &( $3$$ "* "?

)$ "@7 $ " DB: +(

='9 ( /8

.*$

)

2 +.E55

" 65564$ DB:5 '&1 "

' 3 - "

3$ " $

)" $

2 + /8F: 4

.@@76@

" 4 - "

$ " : DB: C1 . -

.*$

)"$ /8B93$)

""4 $ 3?%3$ " $$

$) &(

B" " $ $

" $$+ *$" 97

"4$8 ""556 "$ & 9:* "

" "

"" * $ /8*$ $* "4 $ "$" &( ". $ **

"$ " *

2$ "4$ "

* "4$ $

*$ $

* $ "4$" $ " $

4 + ;

4 4 & * $4 -

:8 $ "$

"*+ "

(

$" "$

" $

$8 $

" $

$" *$ " "$

"$ 4 + * ))"-* "

$ " *$ $+ 76" 4 $8 /8

* "4* $ " $"$ * $ $ 4

* $

$ "$$$"

$C$ ) 4 $"$$" * $) *

$ "

"$$ $ ()*

" $ $

:8 $ "$$"4 ) $ * $

8 "$$$" "$ "

$ $ $ * " "$ $ $ *

"$$" " + *$ $ 4$ /8: " " + **$ $" 4" "$$" "

+ **$

"$"

/8: -

8 "" 5755$ "$$

"4$" &

$ 8 $ "$&( B$"

* $$" ".C ** "$ "$.C *$" $ - $

"$$* ""&( 4$" $ 8 $ 2$ $ "$$$"+ * $ @

" "$ $$ $

)

" $"4 4 "4$ $ "$ $ " "$ * -* 4

$ -* "4*$$" "

/8 " "$ /8$ " 4 $

$ "$.C * $ *

* * 4$$ *

* 4 $4 " : B&( " "4$8 $ 4$"

".C * "$$ $" "$ $C$ $ B$ $

""$.C * "$" *

"$$" " + **$$""

"$ " "

+ **$$" "$ " " + *$*

$ *

"" "$$ " "*$ $ $"$ "$$ "

& 9: $" " 4 $

"4 "* $ " " + * *$ $

" "

* " 4* $ 4 "

$$* "

" "$$+ * * " @

8 B$" 4 $

"4 $) B2$ " " )

4* B " $ $" + *$ B" "$$ $"4 "

4$ 2$3

$ 4("$ "

" ) " $ "$$$" 4 "" $ * *)

$ $ $ "

)

$"+ $ $*

= ---&!@# "= F---&!#$3" 3 ) " $2 3 $"$$ " 4 "" ""4

8 $$ " 4 $*

2$ $ * $"$)4

)"4$ " 4 8

B: C 1 . -

.*$ *$ "

$ " ) B* $$) "" $"

- $

"$ 4$$) *

44$

$ $ ?-&.5@""@E

@@E6@@6:>-3 ) .7%"$ * ""

$ "$ *

.C * $ " *

*$ - 28%* ""$

E@3 3$$$ *

5E5 "$$$" $ "4B &( "$ +"$ " $ "$$ ) " "$" : " $" " + * "$$"

"" " "" ) " /8G@ 2$2 3 )

"$4(

4 $ ) " 2$" 8 " B@ "" " $

$* " "$ $"4 * $ $ $ " * "

8 * ""$ $ $%3

2$ " 8 " + &( 3$$ "* /8 B6*$ "$$ $ " " * $$" " $" BE>* >$ " ?

%4 (4)$

4$"

4%"$ ?-&.5@""@E

@@E6@6

$ "

"$$"

" $ " " " * $$ " " 2$%"2 3 "$$$$ $"4 "

$ " ) "

$ B6 + 3$$ "* /8 "BE>* $>$ " $"

" $" * $ $ " "

4$$"" 4 8 " $ "* 8

$ $$$$")

" - $ " * "$$ $" )"

""755

8 $( "* /8 "$$" +

$ $ $ 4$ $ $ *

) ") " . 4 " $ " $ $ * )

"" 3 2$ "

5E557 * $/8 .C1 + $ $ "

$ $ $

$" "4 *"4$3 %

""5555

$ "

+$ $ $ * "4$ 2$

") " ""* $$4 )

$" "4 " 554$$" ) $

8 " $ "* 8 " $

8 4 " $ "* 8 * 4 "3 ) &)

$ *$ $* "

%* "

"2$ $) " $ * "

4 ""@ 2$ $ * ") 2$ " : /8$"* $$ 3 * " "2$ * " 67= $ %" "

1"$ " /8 *

" $ *$ $* " " 2$ )"

E6* $ + $ $ " $

* *"4$2 3 ) " ""

62$"

"$ 4 $ 3 2$3 ) &) * *"2$ $2 3 "2$ $ 3 " ) 4 )

$ " $ 2$4 )

$ ""@6

$ $2 3

) )

(

. 1, '

) )

<<@ * )

! *

= )

) )

)

) ) '

) *

2$ ) 4 )

$ ""$)4

8 "4$2 3

A - )

(

1, = )

)

+ )

= )

) )

0 #

)

) )

)

(

. 1, =

)

)) )

))

) B - "" $$ $

"4 "$

) $

8 $$ "* 8

4 $ "

* $

*$ $ "*

4$ $3 $4 )

8 "4)$2 3

" $ *$ $ "4 $ )

$ = $ 4 $$ "

$ 2$2 3 *$ 4

$ 4 "4 )"

$$4 $ $ "

$ * "44$ =$

"4$3 * $$ $" 8 "

$ ) " *$ $

8 $"

* $

)$ $&

$ " D$" 4"4"":* D $ * *

$ '

.C ** 8 "4$ "

$ E@3 3

$$*

$ 8 2$$ *

!B#* $ "$" "$ 2$$"+ * $ $ $ :@ *"4 "" ) $ D$ * ) " $

$" B&( " "$$ *

+ " " " $$ " + "

& 9:D$ " " 8 $ "* /8 "

$3 "$ /8 $) + $ $ $ " 2$2 3 $"$$

)

$ $" 4 "

)$$" $"8"$ ) = $4

$) " "$%"2 3 ""$$ /8$ $"4

) * $$4 + 2$

"$$

4 & 7E9:2$ "" " "$ $ 556*$ $*

"4 " $ 2$ * $* $) 4

" '9

1& )%" "'9 () /

- " /8 5 & E * " " 2$ * "

@752$ * $ " *$* $4 4*

5 "@75 /8 5 & 559:* "4 " $ " $ * * $ & @57 54 < * " " $ "* * $"

* & * "/8:

$< & 9:

"4'9 ()/

- " ) $ 56 /8 :@ )$

$* " & E69: $ '9 ()/

- " 556/8:7)$ ""56 $* " & 9: $ '9 ()/

- "

")$

/8E "/8:6 & * " "$ $ 2$%"2 3 ""$$ "

/8:/8:6 " "$ "4 : " *

4$ + $ & 559: " $ )

$ " *

) " $$ *

"4 " " $ ) 8 " 5$

"4+$ *$ $"

4 " " ? $ $

9:* "

*$ $* $ $

$2 3 ""$ " 4

2$2 3 "$$ "$ *

$" " "$ 2$ *

" * "$"" * $ $" "$"

2$ * "

" 2$%

"%*

3 "

B$ :

$) " ""$$ $" 8 "$

$ !/8:#.$

$ "$"4 "

* 8 :

:$ -*

:8 $$ "$

$"4 "4$" 47" 4 $8 $ 2$

* "4* $ 46:" 4 $ 2$3 $ ") "

$) " $ :B "$ *

"4 4 $$ $ $ $" $"

$ " $)

556 2$3 " $$" $"

" "

$ *$ $* ) 4$ -" " )

$ $ "

$ & 9:

*$ $* )" $ "44 $) $ -$ $"4 "

"4$ " * 8 4 *$ )

$ *

"-* $ $ $$

4 "$"4 "

$ - $*

"$" $ $& 9:* "

=$ "4$%"

3 "* $"* $ * $$$$

4 "$$ *

#$ $" "$*

* $ $ " $ $ $ * * $ 4+ " $ $ 4 $ $ * * $ 79'&"*$ $$ 4

$" 7'&"$"

4 $ $ $"

"" 4+ & 9:

" " 8 $ ":* 8

)$ $" $ "

$$) 4 " "4$ " 2$ * "

$ B BB$"

"$B$" * $$" 556*$ B " " $ $ $" * $ $ " 2$ $" "$$" $"4 $* $$ $ *$ B "$$ " "*$ $ $"$ *$ * ">$$ " $

$ $$* $ "$" "$"

+ * $$ )

-$"$ $ * ) " $"$B "*

2$ "B "B* "4$ $ * $ 2$

$*) 8""$) " B6 + &( $3$$ BE>*

(

$ >$ " B C 1 " $ $

.C * "" E@3 3& B6$ 3 $"$$$" 4 48 $*$$"+ $

$ $ $ $ ) 4 $ $

" 4+

BE$" ) /8BE9 $"

"4%"$ ")

) ?-& .5@ "" @E "

$ "$

:8 " "

$$$" 8 "/8 $< * + $ $ $ BE* $"4

2$ .C * ""

E@3 3* "

"" $ "$ $

4 ) " 4 -" 4 "

4 " $*

.C *$" 4

" "4 " E@ 32$

$" )

4* B B7! + : $" #* " B $" *$

' )

$ "$" $ )

$ $ * )

4 $ 4 "

"2$3 ""$) * $$8 $ ) " $ *$$ 4 $ * " + ") $*+

$" ;

$" 4 4 4 $$

") " $ 2$

"2 3 * "

)

%" 3

$ "$ $%*

3 $"$) " B6 + &( $3$$ BE>* $>$ "B C1 "$ $ .C * "" E@3 3$"4 *

" 4$2 3 "$

3 $"8""$ "

) "

$*$ 4 $ $ 3 * 2$ 4

$%*

3 $ $2 3 $ "$$ 3 4*$)* " $ "<

"$"$$

)" 2$ $ $%" 3

."4$%"%*

3 $"$$2 3 $"* " $) " B6 + &( $3$$ BE>* $>$ "B C1 "$ $ .C * "" E@3 3>*$ 8"

$%*

3 $

"$ $ ) " " $4

"$$ /8:

$ ""

" ) " "

)" 2$ $%"%*

3 $) "4

"4)- $< $ ) " $ 8""

3 $ $ $$ "

4 & $$ 3

*$ "<

4 ""

4 )

$ *

)"4 $ $ *

4 4 2$ "<

! & 9:

& # * " $ "

$ $$ . 4 "$ * $ ?

$)4 ""4$ 4*-$

4 $* $*$ )

$) " ". 4 < *

" $

$ $

"$ $ 4

B$$ + 9& "

B$$ & 4 H 9.