State Of Haryana Through F C & P S To Govt Of Hry Deptt Of Tech Edu & Industrial & ORS v. Kushal Sharma And ORS




    
       Date of Decision: 09.07.2018 State of Haryana and others .....Appellants versus Kushal Sharma and others .....Respondents    !

 "
#
"

$
  "
    !

 "


 
$  Present :

Mr. Deepak Balyan, Additional Advocate General, Haryana, for the appellants.

Mr. Rajneesh Chadwal, Advocate, for respondent No.1. **** #
"

$ %&' ( )  &*+ ,)   Heard. For the reasons mentioned in the applications duly supported with affidavit, delay of 57 days in filing and 130 days in re2filing the appeal is condoned. Both the applications stand disposed of.      



 
 



 


 


 

  
 

  


 

 !

"#
 


 

$ 
 %

%




 
& "
 


 
"  '

  

( 

) *

 
% 
 




+ 
,


-


 

 (
   


 






 

 

( 
'

,,
. *
/ 0 
$ 

%
 


 

 "' "

'

% 
1 

 

 
 
  
 *
 *
 


1  

1

  
%
(



% 
 


 
0
 

  
 
 
 

 %

) *


  (
  
% 





2
/ 
*
334*
%
% 
  

 

  

,,

*
2
+  
*
2  
,

*
2
5 
 *
6
,

*
2
3  
/

*
) 
)  



 7 
& "
 1 *

 
% 


2
+  
*
2  
,


 
2
/ 
*
,  *
  


,,


(
  
 
  

 
1 


 

 

0
 
)



) 
3 

8  9

) 
3 
8 9
% 

 



0
 

 






  

 
 

% 

 
%
(

  
 

% 

 
  

   
1 
 


 





( 
%
  
(

 
 :



;

  

% 
 







+(
6
 
& ;

<


 

% 
 
( (









  

 


% 

  


,,




+  
  
+


%
% 
 
,
% 

 
 
%


(


  
  




3 *
,  
 
3  *

( 
 
0

  

 



 

 

 
%
 % 
 



+


(

 
: <



3 *
,  
 
3  *

 0

  


;
  


 
%
"
 

% 
(



0
   
  7  





 
0

  %
 


0

  

:
,
  



(


+

*






   
  
 %(*
(

 
"  '

 


3 
= *
,  
 
3  *
   *

  
% 
 



  

( 
 
 :

% 
 

!
 

$ 




 




  
 
 





 



 

 71  
% 


2
3  
/

*
) 
)  *


 
(
0 

 
 


 

 
 0


 



 
 
2
3  
/

*
% 




 
%
 

  71  
 
%

 



 

( 
%
 
  >
 
% 

% 

  
(  
%

 
 

$ 



 

 
% 
 
(




  
+



4
 
 


*

 

$ 
 




 

 

 

 0
%

  


 



%



  



,

1 
 


& 
/




 
 
 

 %





 
 0


 
 

 

 

'


 

 
 

 
% 
 

 
"' "

'

 

 
 

0 %




:
%

1

  
%
 (


 
% 
 


% 

< "

'

% 
1 





)

  
 
 (
 

(



 
%
 

 

 
"  '

 

  

#
5







 ?
)@
+







 

      



!

      ""   #

 $%%  &'  ( )  
 
  
) 
":

"

+  

1 
(  


  
 ( 
( 





  






 

    *
 





 *
(




  

 
% 



  *





( 
% 
 *
 

 
    

  

 0
%
  



 
% 

(  (

 
":

"



+  , 
4

 





 


 
 *


 (






 

$ 


%
 
% 
 %

<




 
 



 


 

 

$ 
 
 

 
% 


 *

( 
%
  


  
%

 
 *
 

 
% 
1 

'




 
 

 




 


 

$ 

 



 
  

%


 


 
 
*

 
  


 



 


(  (

) 
":

"

+  
, 

!
" 
,

 



  
%






(%
 


 0
 

 

 
 

    
,
(%


 (
 



 
%
 


 

 


 
  

 

$ 
% 

1 
 
""
) 
 
( 




 
 






8/5,&)
2A5)5,9





+,B-
$A,+B

















8)5A&
),9




$A3=B
' # "<
 (

Whether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No√