Wasawa Singh v. Dharam Paul And ANR
!"# $#%&'&()
* + ,!'!-!&(./ 00#11!(" 2#3'4' /!3!5!41!($!("/#3 #'0($#("'
3#'#(") 35#'/645!36!(-!37$8%!"# 3"/#!00#11!(" 99999
/#!00#11!(":01!&("&
&'!..3#$ ;4$.5#("!($$#%3##$!"#$ +<
0!''#$ =>&8&14$.# #(&3&8&'&( 7!?&1@!!' -#11 !'"/# ;4$.5#("!($$#%3##$!"#$
0!''#$=>$$&"&(!1&'"3&%"4$.#7 !?&1@!-/#3#=>/&'!00#!1/!'!1'=##($&'5&''#$ /#!00#11!(":01!&("&
&1#$!'4&"'##@&(.!$#%3## 3$#%1!3!"&( ""/##
#%""/!"/#&'-(#3&(0''#''&( 1!($5#!'43&(. 6!(!1'A !31!''&"4!"#$!"2&11!.#&/!16/#3!7#/'&1!?&1@!7&'"3&%"#3?#043=> -!> !$8#3'# 0''#''&( ( "/# =!'&' 0-#3 !""3(#> $!"#$ * A+< !($ !
&$!8&" $!"#$ <
AA #B#%4"#$ => 3#'0($#(" -!3(!!5&(/&' !843"-!' 43"/#303!>#$"/!"'!1#$##$ #B#%4"#$=>3#'0($#(" &( !843 3#'0($#(" &'&11#.!17(41178&$ !($ 1&!=1# " =# '#" !'&$# (" =&($&(. 40( "/# 3&./"' "/# !00#11!(" 4$.5#(" !($ $#%3## $!"#$ A A 0!''#$ => 1#!3(#$ &8&1 4$.#7 !?&1@!-!'!1'"/#'4=;#%"5!""#3 %/!11#(.#
" -!' '0#%& &%!11> 01#!$#$ => "/# !00#11!(" "/!" 0-#3 !""3(#> $!"#$ * A+< -!' #B#%4"#$ &( /&' !843 => 3#'0($#(" -/-!'!$5&""#$1>"/#-(#3 "/#'4&"030#3">
&$!8&"$!"#$ + &( "/&' 3#.!3$ -!' "/#3#!
"#3 #B#%4"#$ => 3#'0($#(" !
"#3 3#%#&0" ' 7:C 35 "/# !00#11!(" !' /# '1$ "/# 1!($ &( D4#'"&( " "/# !00#11!(" /# !00#11!(" !''#3"#$ "/!" /# -!' &( !%"4!17 0/>'&%!1 !($ %41"&8!"&(.0''#''&( "/#'4&"1!($"-!'!8#33#$"/!"0''#''&( !00#11!(" 8#3 "/# '4&" 1!($ &' %("&(44'7 /'"&1#7 4(&("#3340"#$ !($ -&"/&( "/#@(-1#$.# "/#$# #($!("'/#!=8#'!&$0-#3 !""3(#>7&"-!' 01#!$#$7 -!' (#8#3 %!(%#11#$ => 3#'0($#(" #8&%"&( 3$#3 /!' =##(0!''#$!.!&('""/#!00#11!("-#8#373#'0($#(" 7-!3(!!5 &11#.!11>"3!('
#33#$"/#1!($&(D4#'"&(8&$#'!1#$##$$!"#$ &(
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
!'-#11!' * #'0($#(" -!'03%##$#$!.!&('"#B0!3"# 11-&(.&''4#'-#3# 3!5#$=>"/#1#!3(#$"3&!143")C
,/#"/#3"/#01!&("&
&'#("&"1#$"3#1&# $#%1!3!"&(!'03!>#$ 3F
,/#"/#3"/#01!&("&
&'#("&"1#$"3#1&# 0#35!(#("&(;4(%"&(!' 03!>#$ 3F ,/#"/#3"/#01!&("&
/!'("%5#""/#%43"-&"/%1#!(/!($'7& '&"'#
#%"F
,/#"/#3 "/# '4&" &' (" 030#31> 8!14#$ 3 "/# 0430'# %43"
##'F < ,/#"/#3"/#'4&"&'=!33#$4($#3#%"&(
!($ *F ,/#"/#3"/#01!&("&
/!'."(%!4'# !%"&(31%4''"!($&"
&1#"/#03#'#("'4&"F * ,/#"/#3"/#'4&"&'("5!&("!&(!=1#F + #1&# G 8&$#(%# -!' 1#$ => "/# !00#11!(" !($ 3#'0($#(" H#!3(#$"3&!143"(%('&$#3&(."/# !%"'!($%&3%45'"!(%#' "/#%!'#!' -#11 !' "/# #8&$#(%# ( 3#%3$ /#1$ "/!" "/# !00#11!("C01!&("&
-!' (" #("&"1#$ " "/# $#%3## !' %1!&5#$7 "/#3# 3#7 $&'5&''#$ /&' '4&" " -!' '0#%& &%!11>='#38#$"/!""/#!00#11!("/!$ !&1#$"038#"/##B#%4"&( "/#0-#3 !""3(#>!'-#11!'"/#!
&$!8&"&(/&' !84330!''&(. %('&$#3!"&( ' 7:C"3#'0($#(" "-!' 43"/#3='#38#$"/!" "/#!00#11!("-!'8#3>-#11!-!3# "/#'!1#$##$$!"#$ #-!' ! 0!3"> " "/# '4&" &1#$ => 3#'0($#(" ( *
/# '4&" -!' $#%3##$&( !843 3#'0($#(" (A A-#8#37"/#03#'#(" '4&"-!' &1#$(
A(#!31>(&(#>#!3'!
"#3"/##B#%4"&( "/#'!1# $##$ $!"#$ ++ $%45#(" -!' 01!%#$ ( 3#%3$ " 038# "/# 0''#''&( "/# !00#11!(" 8#3 "/# '4&" 030#3"> 1#! !$8#3'# 0''#''&( 3!&'#$ => "/# !00#11!(" -!' (#.!"#$ 00#!1 03# #33#$ => "/# !00#11!(" -!' !1' $&'5&''#$ => $$&"&(!1 &'"3&%" 4$.#7 !?&1@! (
#(%#!..3#$7"/#03#'#("!00#!1/!'=##( &1#$
H#!3(#$ %4('#1 3 "/# !00#11!(" /!' 8#/#5#("1> !3.4#$ "/!" 0''#''&( "/#!00#11!("8#3"/#'4&"030#3">/!'=##($41>038#$( "/&' 3#.!3$7 3# #3#(%# &' 5!$# " 3$#3 $!"#$ A+ 0!''#$ => &8&'&(!1 !(!1
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
/!'1!&$"/# 4($!"&( /&'%!'#("/#=!'&' 0-#3 !""3(#> $!"#$ * A+< !($ !
&$!8&" $!"#$ + #B#%4"#$ => -!3(!!5"-!'01#!$#$"/!"' 7:C-!'/!($#$8#3"-!3(! !5/#1!($-!''1$"!00#11!("C01!&("&
-/&'&(!%"4!170/>'&%!1!($ %41"&8!"&(.0''#''&( "/#'!5#'&(%# A+</#3# 3#7'!1#$##$$!"#$
&"-!'%("#($#$7/!'=##(-3(.1>#B#%4"#$=>-!3(!!5&(
!843 3#'0($#(" !($ $#%3## $!"#$ A A 0!''#$ => &8&1 4$.# 4(&3&8&'&( 7!?&1@!/!'(#
#%"("/#3&./"' "/#!00#11!("
#34'!1 "/# &1# 3#8#!1' "/!" &($##$7 "/#3# &' (" !( &"! #8&$#(%# " 038# "/!" 0-#3 !""3(#> $!"#$ * A+< B A 3 !
&$!8&" $!"#$ <
AA B -!' #B#%4"#$ &( !843 "/# !00#11!(":01!&("&
=> 3#'0($#(":$# #($!(" "/ "/# '!&$ $%45#("' -#3##B#%4"#$54%/03&3""/# &1&(. "/#'4&"&("/#>#!3 A/#3#&' ("/&(.(3#%3$"&($&%!"#"/!""/#!00#11!("C01!&("&
#8#3"@!(>'"#0' 043'4!("""/##B#%4"&( '!&$ $%45#("'"&' 43"/#3("$&'04"#$"/!" 3#'0($#(" /!3!5 !41 &1#$ ! %&8&1 '4&" 3 0#35!(#(" &(;4(%"&( %1!&5&(. 0''#''&( "/# 1!($ ( "/# =!'&' '!1# $##$ #B#%4"#$ => 3#'0($#(" -!3(!!5&(/&' !843/#'!&$'4&"-!'$#%3##$( A A/#03#'#("!00#11!("%/!11#(.#$"/#'!&$;4$.5#("!($$#%3## $!"#$ A A => 03# #33&(. !( !00#!1 -/&%/ -!' $&'5&''#$ ( < A B /# 03#'#(" '4&" -!' &1#$ => "/# 01!&("&
C!00#11!(" (
A %1!&5&(. -(#3'/&0 "/# 1!($ &( D4#'"&( ( "/# =!'&' "/# '!&$0-#3 !""3(#>$!"#$* A+<!($!
&$!8&"$!"#$ <
AA H#!3(#$ %4('#1 3 "/# !00#11!(" 01!%#$ '"3(. 3#1&!(%# ( 3$#3$!"#$ A+ B 0!''#$=>&8&'&(!1!(!1
&%#3"43.# "/!""/#!00#11!("-!'&(%41"&8!"&(.0''#''&( "/#1!($&(D4#'"&(/# '!&$3$#30#3"!&('""/#"43( -!"#3-/&%/%!(("=#3#1&#$("038#"/# -(#3'/&0!($0''#''&( "/#!00#11!("8#3"/#'4&"1!($# #3#(%#&( "/&' 3#'0#%" %!( =# .!&( 411> 5!$# " "/# $#%&'&( "/&' 43" &( /#"!( &(./2'!3(!&1&(./!($"/#3'7
&8&1 *+7-/&%/$#!1'-&"/ "/# #8&$#("&!3> 8!14# "/# (#/3& .&3$!-!3&#' 03#0!3#$ => "/# %!(!1 !4"/3&"&#' #1&!(%# &' 01!%#$ ( "/# 3!1 "#'"&5(&#' , " , " %#5#(""/#%!'# "/#!00#11!(""/!"/#-!'&(%41"&8!"&(.0''#''&( '4&"1!($"/!'=##(3&./"1>/#1$=>"/#1#!3(#$%43"'=#1-"/!""/#3!1 <
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
&$!8&"#B#%4"#$=> "/#-(#3-!3(!!5!($("/#"/#37&'%1!&5&(."/!8#=#%5#-(#3 => -!> !$8#3'# 0''#''&( /# '!&$ '"!($ &' %1#!31> %("3!$&%"3>7 0!3!$B&%!1&(!'4&" &1#$=>/&5'##@&(.!$#%1!3!"&(""/##
#%""/!"/#&' "/#-(#3 "/#'4&"030#3">/#!00#11!("/!'%1#!31> !&1#$"#'"!=1&'//&' "&"1#""/#030#3">&(D4#'"&(=>-!> !(>'0#%& &%$%45#("!3>#8&$#(%# -#3 !""3(#>!($!(!
&$!8&"!3#("&('"345#("'%( #33&(."&"1#40( "/#!00#11!(" 3#8#37'4&" &1#$=>3#'0($#("/!3!5!41-!'$#%3##$ &(/&' !843(A A00#!103# #33#$=>"/#03#'#("!00#11!("-!' $&'5&''#$ ( < A => 1#!3(#$ $$&"&(!1 &'"3&%" 4$.#7 #3?#043
BI /#03#'#("'4&"-!' &1#$(
A=>"/#!00#11!("H#!3(#$ 43"' =#1- /!8# 3&./"1> $&'5&''#$ "/# '4&" 03# #33#$ => "/# !00#11!(":01!&("&
"/#30&("/!'=##(3!&'#$:!3.4#$ ( 5> %('&$#3#$ 0&(&(7 ( '4='"!("&!1 D4#'"&( 1!- &' &(818#$&("/&'!00#!1 3"/#%('&$#3!"&( "/&'43"
* H#!3(#$ %4('#1 3 "/# !00#11!(" &' 4(!=1# " 0&(" 4" !(> &11#.!1&">7&( &35&">30#38#3'&">&("/#&504.(#$;4$.5#("!($$#%3##$!"#$ +<
0!''#$ => &8&1 4$.# #(&3 &8&'&( 7 !?&1@! !($ ;4$.5#(" !($$#%3##$!"#$
0!''#$=>$$&"&(!1&'"3&%"4$.#7!?&1@! 00#!1&'!%%3$&(.1>$&'5&''#$-&"/(3$#3!'"%'"'
'/-!3 !"#!"$%&"'()*+,$"'%-*"./0"%, - !"#!"$$"&-$#'1"/0"%, -