← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2212/2015dismissed

Balwanti Th Lr Rohtas v. Simru

2016-01-08Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal12 pages

 

      

   

 !"#$!%! && '"# ("# &



 !"#

 "$ )" "#*!!!#+,-,

"!&& "#!.#(",-

"!"&/-"  

 

         

   

   

   

     " % & )

   !      #  "  &"( +#  ""$     ("#,  !"  !#*,  "( "

"$    & #  &    +1(    !# ,  2   3,  "  3/4,  4!$"!    #"!"

""$!( "($#,$,("$$$,$# "" ""$!#&"&"11("  )

$! !$1    

 5"(""$ &"

"($*2"$ 5#""(,(1,!! #$!",(1,."!2*"! "(! 2 !

!("(""!-!"  (!!-$

 !!&

"!(11"! ! &&#&&"$!"!"$)

2&$!"

! (1! "!#, !!(* + 5#  (1 &"&"1   )

!      #"

    4")4  $  !   ,    !!

(    6/&"(! $" 77  !"  *1!"#"  5# &   , ($ (  ! #  ,

6/&"(!)

#"!"$!!# &"&"1 &#"!*1!&"# !"-$ + #,!#$!(" #!( ! &

*$! ! (1)

 -$!# &"&"1(" $"$!,!-$&!""$ !&"&"1 !$#1 ! &"- !"    ("(  !#   8$  &&"!    / &,!&"#(*  3  !## 9! *  (  !  !  &

   $1       

 ,(1,!!#$!", (1,."!2*"! "(! 2 ! !!!&&#&&"$!&

"! (11"! !1!!"-$ !! &

 8#( &"&"1*$+5# (1&"&"1 !*8$ &#"  4")4

  !5#&!-* (!#    6/&"(! ( 5 -",&#"  !5# &          (     $  !  !  #  &"&"1           

: 7 -("3 7 646%4/*14!$"!

("#"!%$ ;( "-4!$"!!(, 7:79!*! !#&"&"1 &#"!# + # ! (1 9  !    *    !  !     !-  -"

!"-!&

"(!#&""   !  (,  (   36    "  3/4, 4!$"!!*!  (!1" 

6/<#- "1!"!"$ ""(, !!!-*( !(" :

 =  !"" # "& "& #&"&"1$!!, !&

 # "  !2 & !#&"&"1 "(!! !!  -"((*" ! (1#! !-$!  &" (1#$!  ,!"(!" ;!  -$"!#,-!#$!! "

!#&"&"1;!&"#&"&"1 #"

= !  %$    ;(        "-   4!$"!!(, 7:7# !#

,.#(!"

41," ,4!$"!!!, !&

, ">#  *1!&

- !! (1! !# !!"(*!-$ !! ,  # "& $&#*! &&"($!!!  #"!"*""!( "(!"$!&"&"11 (" ""-$$!!,! #

"& ;"4#""!# =

"

&    !#    >#   !!  "( ## #    "  &&,  !!    (     

    

7  *1!!, !!    (    77

7  9  !  1,  !!

"(  ## #      #  "  &    *1  "& !#>#

 ;"  4#"  "(  #    !" ",  *!  ! &"-#&&" !"

 #"$!&1 #,&

 

7

   !!    *"#$!    ""    $ "&"-  -""=3

7 : ;"4#"!!  !>#"$!" !"("(!#,""&- ! !!!# !( !"!#* $!  

"-"&"&"1 "(!!&"+#$( =

!*" ! *1 1 1$ (;"4#"*"-!&

  1, !" ",  !#  -#$$  1!$  -//-  !  &  

" =

,# ",!"*1""$ !  "("

"$!&+1(    "(!#&! !     7

   !!    #1  *"#$!    ""   =3

7,  ((    &"1      (  !  &$ +#$(" : =

 &!+#$(" : = &*1!4-?#$ ?"-,4!$"! -#"

&

 ,&&  * " "&& 4#"!"#$!!!!$"#!!#$!!"4#" !  "  !  #    ,  !  !  "1  * #*#*1!"$!"!!,*#!"4#"!  "(!" >#  1>#!"$!" 9 1!!&#!$"#! +# !#!-*$"! -#"&"#"1 !!  *"#$!""$"&"-    #"$&1  # !!&"1  " ! "   $"!"$&

,($!( *((*"

! (1,!" ",! !!"! !#, !! *14!$"!("

!  (1#% "&&4#"!! "  +# &"" $"   !"!!(*&-"!"$ "&"-&1!!, !!!$ # "& *1 ("#, !! #&! #&   ! $   $#" &&     

 77

7*1!4#";!&& ( !-+#$(" =

5, !&"&& 7 9!-!""# "*!!&"

 @!!( ,"-&"-

!!("& (1#"##"/ A8(1#B( (1$ &", !  &#,  !"    !"  "-  & #&"$ !!(#"$ #$!" """"$*- !  $     1 ,  !  *  "     &" (1#&"-!#!&" -$&"+!#$$B  4( !!!*#1"*1! 4#"!""!1#&!4#"# "&  *1("#$!("& !-"1!# # "

&!"1*"$!!9! "( !&"*1! ,

:

$"    ! *  2  &" =    !  " (!! !"" # "&  !!#$ !&

!!, !!  *1!4-?#$ ?"-4!$"! =

, "$!# -#" &" !  !2& !(>#

"(! !&

!! ! !!!!! !!#&"-!&$! !&

, !",! !!! -"! ((*" ! (1# ! ! !-$!    &"  (1 #$  !   ,  !"    (!"

  !! (*"$37 .!#  %!",  4!$"!  #"  !    !(   &" = !!(,!#*" $"!" &" !& !("! ,*#!! !#""(- 1! ()"!(% "#(   ,

6/ !# &"( !(&#!"1- ! "# !!(;!" ", "$1&$ !   (,  !  !    #""  (-      $"* &"&"1 ! !"!"#$!  #&!( #"!&"<!  !!&&"""

 =

,# "&,!*!!  2& &"(

"(!!9!*&"-! "&"$ !!( (" ! 3  !!(""""$*-!$   !*" (1#&"-!#! &"    -$      &"  +!#$   ;!     ! & 1&!&"!!!*- 1"  $!-$!  (1!" -$ &"1+!#$#!*"* ((*"  (1#  %"# "!&&!"#& '

(  $ )*( ) (  (&+,- .))/&01!# "+# *1

 * # &"#" !!*$$!"&"#" !"%"# 2

*(  33./  (&++4 *)

 ((501 .1/./!# "&"(+#, # ! &

,$"&"-!-"$! #!##!"$!*"*&" !"" ("1  "267 *((((

22((  %  "

2 &+++  .&/  *) 

  ((  &&+ .' 7/("&"& !*1!5$!4#";! &"&      !  

  !    "  "  +# **1!&

!- ! &

!

"  *  *1  !(    *  #  *1  !  $ "&"-#!"$! +# !! ! &

;!#($+# !#" *!! &

# #"-- !$"&"-, !(& !&"&"1 &# 3 <(  A  &"  ("#"  (  &"B   "$!    #    "&      !"  +#"    #"$ &1 !(# &"&"1@!!""$! #  #"--    !  $  "&"-    !     "&    (    #        !    !   

"(-*1!- !  2  (*(

2 )  (&+0-  8-, = ;! #("<--! " 1

"!!--!&" "

(<(A&"("#"(&"B",  , (*!

!,$"&"-!-!"$!""1  !!(&

 9!&",  #$!+#$! !#**$$1    #!"$!&#"1 &""$!*!"*1!"$ !(

!"  !  "1  *  "    &  "(  ! (&4#"!"!"1*#&!*1

!  4#"   9  #!    #,           $ "&"- !/#(/ !( !!*$(""("! 1" $

    !  $"1   (1  #           ( !!!!"1#"- ! "#!!&"!$-$!( >#&"#"1 !!""$!(& *1!(&4#"# "&;!&

+#1!

!&"*! &(1*/&##"   ##"  "1<$! "( " "

&  $  !!,  !" ",  *1  1  "!  

($!"*1+# -#" !!, !2*  !+#$(!< !+#&"!""9!&", # *1   "& "  &"#" *$  $1         ("#  ,  !" ",  ! &", !! $"  *< !! ! #"!$"1 (1#*1 1"! ($*$("! 1" $ &"(*"$37.!#%!", 4!$"!, !!!!)"!(% "#(    ,

6/  !#  &"(    !  (&  #!"1 ;!" ",  !  "$#(  "  *1  "  #  "  !

&&";! *$

!$"&"-,!"$!!&"&"1!  &1*$ *$$"&"-

  !!#>#C-, ,!!

(&$"&"-    ! "$! 1 &#"#!$ ( 1!$&"#"(*1!(9!&&, &! !"4#""!#  , !"  "    !  &&,  !!  !  -"#1  #$! ""1  "  !  !  *  $"  "    &"( +#    !  &1   $  "&"-     &! !"# "&"1 <$$!(;!"4#"!$!

!# "!"!(&"# "+#

*1  2$""$!"!#* "( *$&;!$"&"- 1  &#"#!#*!   ;!"$! !!

!-"1*"(*1!(&4#"#

"& *1! !";!" ","  +# !&" "#( !  1&"" $"!"!"!!( *&-"!$"&"-!!, ! !"1$!(&4#"

 9"& !4#"!+#$(

 "&*1! "&&4#"">#" 1"

"*1!4#"#1,!&& #   *  1  -    ("    !  (    "$1 ( . "$/  !9$

  40%14&8