← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/363/2016dismissed

Banwari Lal v. Dev Karan

2019-05-10Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages

 

     



 !""#$%$&' ()*  &+ ,$- .

//".. &!

0",%1% "23 , &  "%/&4"&!



 !" #$ %&" &%'!

,"%"&!'

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

&#">,4%5 ,"+ %"&!","4$&!5"& 9"%"23 , &) &/ ! &4 .:$,+"2",)41,$&65$%.$"!$9"), + ,"=/,"%%"45$%4"%$,"! 4$%!,$:1!"!5"/,/",!(!!5"%&% 98$- . &4 ,- . :,!5", , + ,"A1 ..( &4$&!5"(" ,*@B)  9$.(%"!!."9"&!

  &/ !) .:$, &4"23 , &%& ,- . :,!5",, + ,+1.4 6$2"5 .%5 ,"!!5"/. $&!$ &45$%:,!5",%5"! 9 &44"&  &/ ! &4 .:$,,".$&A1$%5"4!5"$,%5 ,"$& 21,5"! 9 &4 4"&  2$4"  4"#,""%  4 !"4  C*??  &4  C**  ,"%/"#!$2".( +"2",)>?!5 %5 ,"+ %&!,".$&A1$%5"4:("2< , &$& 21,!5" /. $&!$ &4)!5",",")!5"/,"%"&!%1$!+ %$."4 "23 , &#&!"%!"4!5"%1$! &44"&$"4 ..!5" ,"9"&!$&"4  #!%!+ %%! !"4!5 !5"5 4!5"/,"","&!$ .,$65!!%1##""4 %5$% !5",  ,- .+ % .$2" !!5 !!$9" $&#"!5"/ ,!$"%+"," !2 ,$ &#")!5"!,$ .1,!, 9"4!5" ..+$&6$%%1"%';

D 



 





           

   



  







!

" 

#

. $&!$)$&%1//,!!5"/." 4$&6%)"= 9$&"4$2"+$!&"%%"%) & 9".() E; 4 9) E; ,$5 &4 "#,43""/",) E; 319 ,) E;C &6!1 9 &45$9%". //" ,"4 % E;B &4 .%:,165!

&,"#,44#19"&!%= !=  &4= != C)$")91! !$&%) 4"#$%$&!5" &#5 ( !)#",!$$"4#/$"%!5"/. $&!%!$!."4 %F5"! 0",%1% &/ !F &4F5"! 90",%1% .:$,F &!5"!5",5 &4)!5"4""&4 &!5$9%". //" ,"4 %E; 5"!,$ .1,!)+5$." ##"/!$&6!5" 9$.(%"!!."9"&! &4 % +".. %!5" #!19!5"81469"&!% &44"#,""%+5",":(5"! 9 &4 4"&5 4,".$&A1$%5"4!5"%5 ,")4"#,""4!5"%1$!:(,".($&61/&!5" 4"#$%$&!5" &#5 ( !4 !"4@@5"-+",//".. !"1,!

 ,"2",%"4!5"$&4$&6%

, ,%566 ,+ .)." ,&"4#1&%". //" ,$&6&:"5 . !5" //".. &!;/. $&!$%1:9$!!"4!5 !!5"81469"&! &44"#,""!5"-+", //".. !"1,!$%&!%1%! $& :."$&!5""("%. +),)$!$6&,"4!5"  9$.(%"!!."9"&!*@B)+5",":(!+:,!5",%"23 , &)5"! &44 &5 4%1","4 #&%"&!4"#,"":( ##"/!$&6!5"/. $&!$! %1##""4!5"%5 ,", + ,$&"A1 .%5 ,"-+",//".. !"1,!.%! %$65!!5"$&411##"%%$&#!)*B ,%5,!)!5"#!G &44$4&!

//,"#$ !"!5"/,2$%$&%"#!$&!5"#! %!5"%5 ,", + ,+ % !:"4"2.2"41/&!5"4"%#"&4 &!%5$%!+:,!5",% ,- . &4 :$&4 9$&"A1 .%5 ,"%5"4""&4 &! &45$%!+:,!5",% ,"!5" %&% ,- .)+5"," %!5"/. $&!$ &45$%!+:,!5",% ,"!5"6, &4; %&%:$&4 9 &4!5"( ,""&!$!."4!BH%5 ,", + ,5" ," %&$&6 %%$6&"4:(!5"-+",//".. !"1,!:(,".($&61/&!5" /,2$%$&%"#!$&?!5"#!$%+5..( .$"&!!5"%"!!."4. +   9  , $4)  !5"  ,"9"&!$&"4  ,619"&!%  +1.4  &!  :" %1%! $& :."! +1.4:" /!!&!$#"!5 ! 1<5, 9+ %!5"#99& &#"%!,%/",!5"/"4$6,""! :.")5"5 41,%&%)& 9".()3"%5, 9) 2$&4, 9), + , &4 ,. ., + ,4$"41&9 ,,$"4 ,- .+ % .$2" !!5 !!$9"5":,!5",+1.45 2" /,"","&!$ .,$65!!%1##""4 %/", #5"41.""#!$&?!5"#!:"$&6. %%;5"$,5"% 9"," 4!51%';

$ 

%&' (  ( )% & (  (  ) %!& )%*&



%&+ ( ( )% & ( (  ) %!& ( ( )%*& (  (  

 %&,( )% &

( )%!& (  ) %*&

(    $ ( - ( 

) 

$ (  - (   

$ (  - (

 

.( -( 

 .(  -(

 # &%1#5#$,#19%! &#"%)!5"/. $&!$+1.4&!5 2" &(,$65!! %1##""4!!5"%5 ,"!+ % 2.1&! ,( #!5"! 9 &44"&! ,".$&A1$%5!5"$,%5 ,"):1!!5"/. $&!$:(2$,!1"!5"%1$!# &&!$9/.," :( //.($&6!5"% 9", !$1/&"23 , &-+",//".. !"1,!)+5$." ,".($&61/&#5"41.""#!$&?!5"#! !,. %%;5"$,%) 5".4!5 !+5"&:,!5",5 4/,"","&!$ .,$65!)5$%%&%+1.45 2" :"!!", ,$65!!5 &!5 !!5"6, &4;%&2$&4 9):,!5",, + , &4 , - .1#5$&4$&6# &&!:"% $4!:"/",2",%"

,!5"," %&%9"&!$&"4 :2")4&!$&4 &($.."6 .$!(, /",2",%$!($&!5"$&4$&6%1&4",#5 .."&6"6,1&4,$&!",","&#"$% 9 4"  1!)  91#5  ."%%  $&2.2"9"&!    &(  %1:%! &!$ .  A1"%!$&    . +

"%1.! &!.()!5" //" .$%4$%9$%%"4

*(+   , &%'!- ./0 #$12"

'030/45 6/

 7/6

'030 38

7/6