High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/225/2015dismissed

Chanan Singh Through Lrs Kashmir Singh v. Bachna & ORS

2015-09-03Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg5 pages

!"# $% %&'(' *

',+$+-.,+/-( 00%11 $( 2%-(.( $+%-( %(0 %$ 3 4/ 5

6+%$+%-%0-$%-( /& 1%7(0 0%-(8 9:% 117% $ (%%$+%;. ,8%$< :%-% %--% $$+%%0-$%-(-$< )6+%$+%-$+%;. ,8%$(+.1 :%-%0-$% '$+%',%($< -%(%$3- , + -',+= 2& $% -$+% $( +'('( 1 '-%&$% :901

(> $( , '($$+% ;. ,8%$ %&-%% $%

@ 0 ((% :9 +-' (0 1 A%-8 = '$' 1'($-'&$. ,%=! +&# ($- &B.-$=(+'

-0.-2' %7+'&+ $+% 10-% %--% :9$+%01

, '($$+%;. ,8%$ %&-%% $%

0 ((% :9 +-' +'11= $+% $+% 1% -% '2'1 . ,% !%'-'2'('#= -+(+ -7 ( '(8'((% -'%

&$( $+%0-%(%$& (% -%$+ $(.'$0-0%-$98 -B% ( (+7'-% &1.-'$+%('$%01 .119 %$ '1% '$+%+% $% '$'(&80-'(% 5+

C#7+'&+'(0 -$ 0 -&%1

5+%7 $

?5+ $ .'

((+7'$+%;

' -$+%9%

**C *? $+%2'11 ,%+ ;;

1 -%2'.(19$+%01

1,7'$++'( :-$+%- 8',+7 ('0((%((' $+%(.'$0-0%-$9 8',+ :-$+%- $+%01

'% '$+%9% - *?*1

=$+%-% -%=&1 '8% $+ $+%'(7'%D&1.('2%0((%((' $+%(.'$0-0%-$9 (4 '- -.('4 +%01

&1 '8($+ $: 9+ ('$%- %--% '$+'(0% &% .1=1 .1

&$'..(0((%(('2%-$+%(.'$0-0%-$9+%01

&1 '8($+ $+% '(% :.

-97 11'$+%(.'$0-0%-$9 ((+7'$+%('$%01 +% % % $(7+ -%($-, 0%-((+ 2%7($ -$% &1 '8',$+ $$+% % % $ (:%&8%7%- $+%(.'$0-0%-$9$+%:

('(

%D&+ ,% %% %&%$+'((.'$ 0$'&% % % $( -% '1% 7-'$$% ($ $%8%$$ B',0-%1'8'

-9:;%&$'(-%, - ',1&.( ($ '$ '1%$+% 0-%(%$(.'$E+ 2',$&8%$$+%&.-$7'$+&1% (E$+%('$%01

'(7-, $+ $$+%%$-'%('$+%-%2%.%-%&- (+7', $+%01

+'(:-$+%-'0((%((' $+%(.'$('$% -%0-'8

&'% 7-, 8%-'$(= '$ '( (.:8'$$% $+ $ 5+ @?

C# 7 ( $+% 7%-(+'0 - 8 $ 2'11 ,%+ ;;

1 +%01

+'( :-$+%- 8',+%2%-+ 9&&%-7'$+$+%( ' B+ .8:%-+% %$-'%((+7',$+%8'0((%((' -%7-, , '($$+%%D'($', 0('$' $$+%(0$+%1 &80-'(% 5+ 7 (17%-'

1%2%11'B%$:

+%- 8 $ 2'11 ,%+ ;;

1&.1 $.(%$+% (.'$('$% (7%-', % % $( %'% $+%- 2%-8%$( 09% - '(8'(( 1 $+%(.'$ @ % % $ ) '1% (%0 $% 7-'$$% ($ $%8%$ $ B', 0-%1'8'

-9:;%&$'( $+ $ $+%01

( 1&.( ($ ' $ '1%$+%

) 0-%(%$(.'$E$+%01

'(%($00% -8 '1',$+%0-%(%$(.'$:9+'(7

&$=& .&$ 8'(('( $+%('$%01

'(&--%&$ (7%-', % % $ %'% $+%- 2%-8%$( 09% - '(8'(( 1

$+%(.'$ %01'& $'( 7%-% '1% -8 $+% 01% ', $+% 0 -$'%(

117','((.%(7%-% 8% 3

+%0 -$'%(+ 2%1% $+%'--%(0%&$'2%%2' %&%$+%

-%( '

'((.%(+%$-'

1.-$

$%- 00- '( 1 $+%%2' %&%2' %;. ,8%$

%&-%% $%

= '(8'((% $+%(.'$

C %%1', ,,-'%2% =$+%01

0-% %--% '-($ 1 +% 1% -% '$' 1'($-'&$. ,%=! +&# ($- &B.-$=(+'

-0.- 2' %;. ,8%$ %&-%% $%

@ '(8'((% $+% 1 $+%

? $'11 %%1', '(( $'( '% 7'$+ $+%

-%( ' ;. ,8%$(

%&-%%( $%

= $+% 0-%(%$ -%,.1 - (%&

1+ (:%% '-%&$% :9$+%01

> $ * +% $'0 ,- 0+ ? $+%,-. ( 1=+ ( 8%$'% $+ $ 117',(.:($ $'

1F.%($'( 1 7+ 2% -'(%'$+% 0-%(%$-%,.1 -(%& 13

# $

% $

& '

2%+% - 1% -% &.(%1 -$+% $ 2%,% $+-.,+$+%& (% '1%7'$++'( :1% (('($ &%

/% -% &.(%1 -$+% $+ ((.:8'$$% $+ $ $ + '1% 001'& $'. %-- %-@ .1%C $+% -01 &', -%&- ;

' -$+%9% - * @ -%0-$ $+%'- 7 -' $% ) C * :9 7 9 '$' 1 %2' %&% $ '( (.:8'$$% $+ $ $+%(% &.8%$(0-2% $+%0((%(('

2%-$+%(.'$0-0%-$9'

$+%-%2%.%-%&- +%01

$+%'-0-% %&%((- '

'$%-%($+ 2%:%% (+7'0((%((' 5+ (.'$

(+.1 + 2% :%% %&-%% :9:$+$+%.-$(:%17 $'( .-$+%-(.:8'$$% $+ $$+% ;. ,8%$( :$+ $+% .-$( :%17 '( $+% -%(.1$ 8'(-% ',

8'('$%-0-%$',$+%%2' %&%$+% '1% +%01

'('0% &% .1

.'$%--.0$% 0((%(('2%-$+%(.'$0-0%-$97'$+.$0 98%$ 1% (%- B$

2%&(' %-% $+%( ' (.:8'((':.$ $ ' 9 -&% '$+ $(.:8'(('

+%-%'($+',$+%-%&- $+ $;. ,8%$( :$+$+% .-$(:%17 -%-%(.1$ 8'(-% 8'('$%-0-%$',$+%%2' %&%$+%

'1%1

& (.&&%% 19'& (%+%'( :1%$0-2%+'(0((%(('

2%-$+%(.'$0-0%-$9+%-%'(&&.--%$ ' ',

&$-%&- % :9:$+ $+%.-$(:%17$+ $$+%01

'1% $0-2%+'(0((%(('2%- $+%(.'$0-0%-$9+ $ ' ',

&$'($$+%-%(.1$ 8'(-% ',

8'('$%-0-%$',$+%%2' %&%$+%-%&-

@ +% 001'& $'. %-%&$'@ -% 7'$+%&$'C $+% 82% :% -%$+'(.-$'(7'$+.$ 98%-'$6'$+ .% '1',%&%= $+(% &.8%$(&.1 + 2%:%%0- .&% :% -%$+%$-'

1.-$-:% -% $+%17%-00%11 $%.-$-%2%-=$+%(% &.8%$(7'11$'80-2%$+% & (% $+% $' 98 %- ($+%0'$''((.%'($+%

0((%((' $$+%$'8% '1',$+%(.'$$+$+%.-$(:%17+ 2%,'2%

' ',$+ $01

'($ :1%$0-2%+'(0((%(('2%-$+%(.'$1 ='$+%(%&'-&.8($ &%($+% 001'& $' (7%11 1 -%7'$+.$ 8%-'$

(%F.%$19=$+% 1'(7'$+.$ 98%-'$ $+%( 8% ($ ( '(8'((%

&09 $+'(;. ,8%$:%(%$$$+%$-'

1.-$ - ($-'&$ &801'