← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1321/2020dismissed

Manoj Kumar v. Hawa Singh (Deceased) Through His Lrs And Others

2025-09-11Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal8 pages



      RSA-1321-2020 

  

"# $ &'(

)

'(*+

+         ,

 -( .

&

/)0

  ( 0,

&'(/)0

/

 111    

 234323 ,

 

) )

 &   2,2

) ) 5

!'

! $



) 

/ %((  )!5 

) 75 ) 0

  )  8(   ) 5 

!'

! ) 8( !

9

)'

))

: 2

))! 

;)'

/;( 

/) '

!!

)'

))

)4<

 2

 20! ;)'

 &  0/ ;( 

/ 0)  %(( 



)) !

% ) ) 

.

 0  )!

5/

( !!7

' !

 4    

 



!! )

) 

33 $ &'(

)

!

))

4< ) <:< )  

) < )  20! &  =   <       %

 

7)' '( /% '( 4   

  / %

 =  $ &'(% %

!

!!

#4< ((

:.

!

!

)!!5)  7 ) 

)% (



"!!

;( 

/8 (! ) 

;( 

(

? !

)@ 4

= 

!!% (

!

)

!

+//#3   ,   

 ) !0

!!&

)%

)% (

(



 44

 ( !% 5 7

)5 %!!'

 (

 7  =  .

5' 4B * !

)4%   !!'  )  = 

 '

) % (

( 4

 = /

5/

= 

0)

'

)

))

)4<

/ (



 = < 0) !!0

)< )

0)

'

)

))

)<:</(

!

=  )A !

!!



 %

   %  

)75

343 4<  ,!



)20!& = 4 <:

/  !

) ( )'

)

%  B:/

0' 

>

 

) 

)  / 7

)   

! !

)    20! +  = <   %  !

/7 %

%

% (!7

( 4

/( 

:

C

'

'

)

!!

) / 7

  !  D)

 

B

 = /  )  )) 

) %



)'!5/

8(

') 

 = 

!



8(

!!)

)%

)$



  )  )   A

 (

) 

  % ( )  = / %(( %

) ) 

) 

( 0'7

)/

%A

(

)

% !!A

)



% % ( '( /%(

B 20!& = 4)

)<:( 0'7

)%

%/%

)6!'



/ ) !/)

)!'

/%

B4

= 

!

 

  (

3B3  !

)

 BB

 = < !

 

 %(

/

!!)

)% )  )20!2

) < % 

)  !!

 %



'



7  B

 = :  !

 

!5 

'

)

))

)<:<!!

%

 )8( !'

!/

/ ) !/)

)!' 0!

/%

B< +

 !

)/  %((

%







)'

%'   %

!2

3             

 

  " #$  %%#     &

 

'     !



'    '



'))    &  # )  * +    ,#    ) -      *

 ,# .# /  # *   )/  #   # *  # )   *       # 1       # *

 # ))/ 1.# * 2 < ,

 !

0)  8(

! 2

 )

33

! !

) 75

 ) 2

))! 

;)'

/;( 

/!

)'

!'

'!

!  A(

)!

)  !

: *

)  !

7

(2

(

)  ) '  !

) 75   $  7

 )

 5( )7

'

$'(2

(   

%((/ )7

!

)*

) 

))

'

  A(

7  

75!

)  !

/7 )

 -

)0

!)7

% ! 8(  !!5

)20!& = 4

<: 3.4#    

.'

 /



!!)

$

)

% B:

20!;)'

;

 0/;( 

/%(( %'

3  5    $ 6% 7                      / )         #      4%  )/  #       8)  6# 91 + !



( ,%:#;: *% < :.. + !

(@  



 ( %

   

8(

 7 !

!5

5

 0'7

8(

0'7

75 7

/)  

0'7

.

)

)!5/

 !

)

3<3   -



5/

.

5

5

 )  %

! 4  =

!5 (/ (

)/0) %((%

)/



) 8(

   >

3=

5

 

A

) 7



 !C

) 0

( )

! !C

B: /(

.

 2

 )

 !  !C

/ %(

 ' 

8(



) 8(



!

7!

! 2

'(/

 

 )% (

.8(

( %

 %

!

0) 8(

))

.



$

!2

)

%

%75 % ((

%!!6

)

 ( ) 

7!

) 7

 B 

) )0)

  >

 34/ '(/  !!5 )

)

7! 5  D)

 

 !

7

'2+3<3/%((%

%75 (!7

!

0! A

/ %'

3 =#         )/% # *       )/ >   

42,2)

!% (%

)

 

33 ) ) %  

 4 +!

 4/



 %

% % ( !7

( 7 '

!5  !

$



!

/

( 7 !

) < 

!7

5'

)

- (/!

 ! (  

7!

 ( %

) !7

5 %  

( 

  E(

 

) 

   - ( 

 

 %

% 

.' !7

 !

(     D)



/



( E(

!)(

/

(2

 ) !)

 (  

) / %(  %

%

% (  !7

5= 2

'

!7

%((  

)  !

%    % '

( )%

5'



7 ''

'

)!7

!

(

 % ) 7'

)

( '



   

)'!5/7

(2

'( !5( !)

7!

 '(/

7!



'



( 

%

/

!!%

8(

) % (

( 

 

=

 4 /

F5

!!A

!

)(

)5 7

)  G0

/ (  

  <:7 

%75( B:8(

3:3    /

/ %  

 44/ %(( %  !

!5

)75!

8( '(/

' )7

(2

5

' )!



%((( ' (

)   A

 ( 2

/ ( 

!

(7 



'   

!  )

) 



)'!5) )

 , )'

/ 5/( !!

)) 

       !"#$%% &'&( 0'

Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No E(

7!

 #=