Balwinder Singh And Another v. Financial Commissioner ,Revenue, Punjab And Othetrs




   
   

 !"

#$% &'()(* + !, &-. !)(/0 !12&!)&!'2(/ 344(--&!'+ 5(/+6+

!&!* &-77 ++ !(/8 (9(!6(8 6!:&;&!)'2(/+ 33 (+4!)(!'+   ,  <

 0
 0
  <

 0
0"


/(+(!',

//6!&!+&-8)9*&'(/'2(&44(--&!'+ ===
   >? 2&--(!1( !'2 + !'/&@*6/'&44(&- +'/)(/)&'()#% 4&++();A'2("/ '6/') +7 ++ !1'2(./ '4(' ' !&+&-+'/)(/)&'() 4&++() !'2(/(9 (.&44- *&' !. '26/'2(/4/&A(//+('' !1 &+ )( /)(/+ !!(B6/( @% )&'() % 4&++() ;A '2( !&!* &- 77 ++ !(/  (9(!6(8 6!:&;8 2&!) 1&/2 6!)(/ 0(*' ! $  '2(

6!:&;&!) (9(!6(*'8/)(/!!(B6/( @#8)&'()#%4&++();A '2( 77 ++ !(/8 4!&1&/  9 + !8 4!&1&/8 /)(/+ !!(B6/( @C )&'() D# &!) !!(B6/( @ )&'() # 4&++() ;A '2( ++ +'&!'--(*'/8 /+'/&)(8&!6/ !'2(7&''(/4&/' ' !-&!) >? 2&--(!1( ;A '2( &44(--&!'+ 2(/( ! ' /)(/+ !!(B6/( @ )&'() # &!) !!(B6/( @C )&'() D# 4&++() ;A '2( ++ +'&!'--(*'/ /+'/&)(8&!6/&+.(--&+/)(/!!(B6/( @#)&'()

 #% 4&++() ;A '2( 77 ++ !(/8 4!&1&/  9 + !8 4!&1&/ .&+) +7 ++()9 )(/)(/!!(B6/( @%)&'()%;A'2( !&!* &- 77 ++ !(/8 (9(!6(8 6!:&; 2&!) 1&/2 ;A '&E !1 !' &**6!' '2&' 7)(4&/' ' !.&++&!*' !();A'2(++ +'&!'--(*'//&)(@
8&!6/ 9 )(/)(/)&'()#!&!&44- *&' !;A;)6-0&'&/ /(+4!)(!' D 2(/( ! / 4&/' ' !  -&!) 7(&+6/ !1  ; 12&+ &!) D ; +.&+ + '6&'() !9 --&1(&!6/8(2+ -(/&;&++ 8 +'/ *'00&1&/&!)
  .&+ +&!*' !() ! D#  (9 (. 4(' ' !  -() &1& !+' '2( &/(7(!' !() '. /)(/+ ;A '2( &44(--&!'+ .&+ ) +7 ++() ;A '2( 77 ++ !(/ 9 )( /)(/ !!(B6/( @# ! #%  2( -(&/!()

&!* &- 77 ++ !(/ .2 -( '&E !1 !'(  &/(7(!' !() 4+ ' ! &-+ *!+ )(/() '2( 4-(&  '2( &44(--&!'+ '2&'
  2&) ;((! +&!*' !() ! D# . '26' *!+ )(/ !1 '2( ;:(*' !+  '2( &44(--&!'+&!)'2(+&7(2&9 !1!';((!4/(4&/() !'(/7+7)( 4&/' ' !+4(/'2(+&!*' !()7)(4&/' ' !84++(++ !'2(4&/' (+ 2&)';(E(4' !'&*'&!) !'2( !+'&!'*&+(8 !
84++(++ ! '2(4&/' (+2&);((!) +'6/;()&!)'2(-&!).2 *2.&+ !4++(++ !'2( &44(--&!'++ !*(7&!AA(&/+2&);((!1 9(!''2(/(+4!)(!'+ >C? (/('2( !&!* &-77 ++ !(/84-(&'2(&44(--&!'+.&+ '2&'&+4(/*-6/()7&48F2&+/&#DG.&++2.! !'2(+2&/('2( &44(--&!'+.2 -(F2&+/&#DG.&++2.! !'2(4++(++ !;)6- 0&'&/ /(+4!)(!'

D;6'&+4(/
 F2&+/&#DG2&);((! ./!1-A+2.! !'2(+2&/(;)6-0&'&/ /(+4!)(!'D&!)F2&+/& #DG. '2'2(&44(--&!'+.(9(/8+'&'(7(!'.&+7&)(;A*6!+(-/ '2(/(+4!)(!'+G*&9(&'/+'2&''2(+&7(.&+)6('&*-(/ *&- 7 +'&E(&!) '2&''2(A2&)!;:(*' ! E2&+/&!67;(/+.(/(&--''()''2(4&/' (+&+ 4(/'2(*-6/()7&4"2 -() +7 ++ !1'2(/(9 + !4(' ' !8'2( !&!



77 ++ !(/2(-)'2&'&+4(/+(''-()-&.4&/' ' !&+.(--&++&!*' !() 7)(4&/' ' !8(9(/A*@+2&/(/.&+(!' '-()'+64(/ /&+.(--&+ !(/ / H6&- 'A-&!) !4/4/' !''2(4&/' (+/(+4(*' 9(+2&/(&!)'2&')6/ !1 4&/' ' !8 *@+2&/(/+ .2 .(/( ! 4++(++ !  +64(/ / H6&- 'A  -&!)

!*-6) !1-&!)&;6'' !1&/&)7/('2&!'2( /(!' '-(7(!'.(/(- &;-(';( ) +'6/;()2( !&!* &-77 ++ !(/2(-)'2&'!4(/6+&-'2(*-6/() 7&4&44(&/()'2&9(;((!/ 12'-A4/(4&/();A&--'' !1-&!)+6 '&;-A''2( &44(--&!'+&!)/(+4!)(!'D;)6-0&'&/8'2(/(/(8'2(/(.&+!7(/ ' ! '2(/(9 + !4(' ' !**/) !1-A8.2 -() +7 ++ !1'2(/(9 + !4(' ' !8 '2(++ +'&!'--(*'//&)(
8&!6/.&+) /(*'()'4/*(()6/'2(/;A &--'' !1F2&+/&!67;(/+''2(4&/' (+&++2.! !'2(*-6/()7&4 

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
!) !1+8 '2( ./ ' 6/' 'E !' &**6!' '2&' '2( !-A &/167(!' ! ;(2&-  '2( &44(--&!'

+G4(' ' !(/+ .&+ '2&' '2( -&!) 1 9(! ' '2( &44(--&!'+G4(' ' !(/+ .&+ !I<+2&4(.2(/(&+ '612''2&9(;((! !&+'/& 12'- !(;6' '.&+ !') +46'()'2&'4&/' ' !2&);((!)!( !&**/)&!*(. '2'2(+&!*' !() 7)(4&/' ' !&!)!'2(;&+ +&E+2&I<4/(4&/() !



+&!*' !() 7)(  4&/' ' ! (9 (. &44- *&' !  -() ;A '2( &44(--&!'+G4(' ' !(/+.&+&-+) +7 ++();A'2(-(&/!()"/ '6/' >$? "(2&9(*!+ )(/()'2(+6;7 ++ !+7&)(;A-(&/!()*6!+(- /'2(&44(--&!'+G4(' ' !(/+
.&+4/(4&/()&**/) !1''2( +&!*' !() 7)(  4&/' ' ! &+ 4(/ .2 *2 (9(/A *@+2&/(/ + (!' '-() ' +64(/ / &+ .(-- &+ !(/ / H6&- 'A  -&!) ! 4/4/' ! ' 2 + +2&/(G(!' '-(7(!'(+ )(+8/!'!/&).&+&-+1 9(!'&--*@+2&/(/+ +4(/'2(*-6/()4&/' ' !7&4 (  8;'2'2(&44(--&!'+&+ .(--&+/(+4!)(!'D@;)6-0&'&/2&9(;((!1 9(!-&!)&;6'' !1'2(/&) .2(/(&+ '2( &44(--&!'+ 2&9( ;((! 1 9(! 7/( -&!) '2&! &+ 4(/ '2( / (!' '-(7(!'8;(+ )(+8'2(A2&9(;((!1 9(!4&++&1(/7'2/((+ )(+ >%? 0 !*( 4&/' ' ! .

&+ )!( ! &**/)&!*( . '2 '2( +&!*' !() 7)(4&/' ' !&!)!'2(;&+ +&E+2&I<4/(4&/() !'(/7+'2( +&!*' !()7)(4&/' ' !&!)'2(&6'2/ ' (+;(-.2&9 !11!( !''2( &/(7(!' !()&+4(*'+'2(7&''(/8.()!' !)&!A/(&+!.2&'+(9(/ ' !'(/(/( . '2 '2( .(--@/(&+!()  !) 1+ /(*/)() ;A '2( -(&/!() "/ ' 6/' 642-) !1 '2( /)(/+  '2( !&!* &- 77 ++ !(/ .2 *2 ! '6/! 642-)'2(/)(/'2(77 ++ !(/ >? **/) !1-A8'2(4/(+(!'&44(&- +) +7 ++()  !"#
$%  
  &%'!    &%'!  &7 ' 
"2('2(/+4(&E !1G/(&+!