High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/41724/2025dismissed

Dr. Manish Kumar v. U.T .Of Chandigarh And Another

2026-02-16Mr. Justice Surya Partap Singh8 pages

!"# $% &#'()($* + , ,

-. ,/ / /

!"#$%!& '! (! ) "# *"& !&! '!

#$%!& '! (!$!, ------ / /

1!2

. (!'! (/ * "'"$*0 (!1

$! & !!'!.2$ $.3.,,4,2$ &!2,4# 245#256#257#26.#.,4/)!' $ "!$# !"& !&!!8& ''&9 #

, / "" &8 '!8&!$

&8*# ,4,,# (!!$&$ 8"'! 8("!0!'

"$ ;8$< $%$ !1"

!$& *(!(! "&&!$ !&!8("

1 $ !!!

$' $ #

$&"

*$ &!& !' :!

" $ ;8$< 8"0 :)

!= !

" ;8$<# : "!

""$;8$< $:

""$;8$<

$'"!

$ $'!(("0!':(&'& ;>$<#:

$ ?< :! 0(<&&!$ ! "! 1 &!/

&&$

" @ !"$

* 8("!0!':!

$ ;8$< 1

% !!$"=1

!''& "!':!

;8$< $*$ (&!8("

1 "! $*0 (!

1!"$ "0 $ !' &!8("

((!%$A &&($ '

#!!#1 8("!0!':)

!= !

;8$<

% !!$&! &(!

8 "%":!

"$ ;$< B $$! ! *!%# &!8("

"! "" $

(("& !'!8'! (("0 $1'""$*0 (! !1

$1 !*

"'!'&!8("

# $!.3.,,4,,#1 &!8("

1 ((!$!( 0 !0(!CD! *$ !':!

"$ ;8$<# (!(!(!$

1!"$* $''&"'! !&!8(" (!&# '!# $ !$ 8!0 * = &&!!' (!#!

1!"$* (!!!( $(!& 2 &&!$ !&!8("

$ &!/ &&$

$ % $ '

= &( !' : !0 (!< '! 8 !'

.,#44#444A/#

1 $*0 8

&(1 $!

8 8!1!"$* %!!1 "! "" $*0

1!1!=!$$ $B4.,,4,,'!! 0( $ ?1

(("$*0 (!! #

!..4,,4,B(! ""$ &!8("

! "

! &!""& 1!= !$ '! (& '& ;>$ $ =$'!BEF( 08%$( 08 $%&" $ $.44,,4,B E 1 ' $*0

!,B4,,4,B !!'&!8("

8"0 =

=1 & ""$ "

$ 1

=$ ! 1 $ 1!= '! (("0 !' ! & (" ( &!8("

!$!&!%& 8# (!($1!(/ $ '$88! $8!'$ $ *1:)

!= !

";8$<

$&!8( 0!'&!8("

'!(("0!'64F "&!

!"* $ ? &! 0(1 "! "" $*0

!$!1 &!'$&!' (!$ $& >#1! .2#7E#44#444A/ * !4377E5$ $4B46,4,B1 "!$*0 (!#

*!%/8!$ (!& &!8("

( $ 8 !'

.#E2#7E#444A/! (!(&!8("

$(( 08 1!=!$1 $'! ! 8!01 $ 5 & !' (!&!

%1!' *!%/8!$ &!8("

#'!8 "!' & 1 "!$ $ % ! =( 6

$ 7

*&!$$!*

"'!'(!

*'"$! * !''

" $* " "" !( " $&!"'! (!'

& $ "*1 (!1 1 $! $% &8!'"!

$% 1! 8 1! B4#44#444A/ $ BE#44#444A/ 1 @&$

*1 (!

"!*&!$$*0 " $&!"'! (!

( *!%/8!$"!

8 (!&!"$! 8!08# $(!'&%"

*&!%$! &8 "& *0&!!= ( '

"!01

$!$'!(("0!'8$&! *$ !':!

;8$< 3 $$!! *!%# " $&!"'!

"!&!$$

(& 1 '$!$ !& "!#

*'! $ ! (

$ %$ &!8(!8( " $&!"'! (!%1!' *!%/8!$&!8(!8 8!01 ((!$!*$*0 (! ""8*$!

' & "$''&" (!&!"$!( 0 ""8'! 8!

*0@$ *!%/8!$8'!( 08!'

8!0 (!* &&!$$ *'!' " .4 " $ &!"* ((!$*0" $&!"'! (!$ !,

&!!%$ *!%/8!$ 8 &&!$ !" $&!"'! (!$!, (& (! (!

1 !8 "" !!'& !!''

" $!&8 8!' !%8&!8( 0 $ "!!'& &!8("

'! 8!'.2#7E#44#444A/&&!$ !" $&!"'! (!$!,# (! (!#1 !

"! &8 " !0

$ '

& 8"

=$!'% " $''("

&&&!$ !

" $ &!" '! (!$!, % ( (! '!

!0 * " (!

* $ 8 $ &!$! !'

&!8(!8 %$ *'! $ !# '!# !"$'!

"%1#(&%!' &

( !'& $8!0

* $*0 (! .. " $ &!"

&!$$

(& %0(&'& $& !& " "" !

(!> '

$(( $'

"$!&81!=!$ $88! $8!'

$ $ !*

"'!' !%8&!8( 0# $

!$!

!' $!'$! !"!'% ! (!%!"%$ *!%/8!$ &#&!$ "!

!!' (!& 0

"!*&!$$*0" $ &!"

! 1 "! !& "" ! '! &!88! !' !''& (

*"$ &!256#257 $26. # !''&$$!/ &!8(!$ *"# '!#8( 08!' 8!0 ! !* !$'! !' "! (! ., &!$

*($& '""0 .B ( "!'&!$ !1

(& %0 (&'& $& !& " "" ! > '

(!!!"0 $ '! 8!'8!0#* "!(( $'! $ $!&8! &!'$&!' *!%/8!$ &

$&!$&!' (!+'0 &!!!'" $ &!"

!$! ! &!' $!

'$! !"("

0$*0 (! &!88!!'!''&# &!$ "!

!& 0

.2 $$!! *!%# "!"% !!

&!$ !1

! >!'" $&!"'! (!# ( $(1 '$!$ !#1

$ % $ = ! 8!0 ""8! * (!

"$&!8("0 1 *!%/8!$&!$! "! .E = ! &!$ ! *!%/8!$ '

& &&8 & '&& *$ 1

* ("

0 $ $=1 ! "! .5 9 $ ! *' !' !0 * " $ (&("

$$!1# !G*" (8! & !'

: = ( $ 0% !')

,4,2 ; ,7,<#

!*%$

(!1 ! !0 * " @ !$ 0 (!1# $

(&%!' &

8*!'& #

* "$

* "

"#& !H*0 0& !'8 !#* $

" .6 !G*" (8 ! *!%8!$ &

' !*%$

"!' " >!!'+$& "$&! $($ (! '

& $ &&8 & !' & &&!$ !

!G*"(@!#1 & ""$(!!@& *!% $(!1 !&!&$

!*%0& !# !'8(!&!!

&&$!& 8 0" $!8& !'+& $8

8( % ! .7 8"

"0# & !':=

0 "

%% !'

$! (& "; %

!C8 "D!.4,EE!',4,2#$&$$!,.46,4,2<# !G*" (8!!'$

" @&(! "8$0

$! !* $ !8 ( !G*" (8 !# 8 @ ! ! '! @$ $" & !' @ !$ 08$0! (! &&$!' %!''& .3 & !':* = ** &% !' + *.374 C,DE5E<# !G*" (8!!'$ "$

/ CD (!1$ &!2B7#8 " !&$!$#!' @ !$ 0 &

& $ 8 * @&$ ( "0 @&(! "& !"0 CD $$!! "8 !8!$ &!2B6# (!88 =! (& "& '! @&!' (!1! " CD 9 " 8 & '! 8 $!' !''$! (!"&&!$0$ &!.56C,D& *8 $!*0 % &0 ! ! *" &"

8 ! & &8 8 "'!8'!8 !"="0!*&%$ '!8 !''$$ &!,6!' %$&&& * $!# (!1$ &!2B7 !"$!*@&$ ,4 ' & "8 @!' (& #$&$ '! ! ( ( # "0?$ "

!' *!%/8!$(&("!'"

1# (

(& 0 !$1 & % @&!'

+$&!'! !' "#$!!@'

%!!'(! ,. # *0 "$

((!$%!$!'8

$$%$8 " 8 *0$8$# &&!$ "0

,, "" ! ($ (("& !# ' 0# "! $(!$ !''#

&&!$ "0

/ /

, ,

( = A !$ IA!

(! *" IA!