← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2350/2015allowed

Manjit Kaur v. Estate Officer Union Territory Chandigarh And ORS

2016-05-13Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri11 pages

     

  

    



!"

#$%$!& '

)*

 +  



     

  

   

'

 ,- .



/

0.

!   "#$ 

"% & '

# 

  % ! 

"  # ) %

& * 

 +  

,  

)*+  $

,  



 

+,+ "+

, $

- " +



,

 +   

 

  *      +

          

"       .'

'. /    #  )   0



$ #

  1 '. (  #

 ,0

2+ ),3  ,+ 4 56

'. ($ 8    2+"  3$

"

'

9 -,  # 



  #  :



,

 

;      "  



   4 /7.+

((8<    #



.'

   $ 5 /...=8   

>  " .?    5 /..=8$ #  "   : "     /?

"  $    #  "   $  (.         .( 161  

 " $#  #  4

@$, 

"" #"    # /?" $      

   "      ' ''/.=8  2 /?     #  "3  ,

"

  4  A56 /   / 161      "  $   -$

#   ,   4 /7#-4 (('/

'

)    '/?" $$ $

   4   " 

$  "- " /?" 

" "

) 4  ""  

           9  +     



,   ( + #>   4

   '.

.1 161"  >     $   $

>  $ #'5 161$ " "# $  " "

#       'B(C D@ +

<    1A(2  E 1A( F3  

 "    $     

  @$,          

'.

161  $  '5 161   4    "



  " $

 #  4 , ""  .

11. $          

   + .B(C * #2),

3    1/'  2     E  F3   )   4 '  $ 

" 

$   "    

,      #      $  "  ,   

'. '#  4 '

@ 

)   - 

      " '/?$  

4" $ 

 ,          "  /? " $" $    > " #   

$ #9+   

  '.

'..1   " .7 '/.=8   "    "$    '..1 '/? " " $  $   

    

#  

 

   1   

$ " ( '. . ,  #  $  " , 

7 '. '

    

  *   ,,   



   $  " , #  

#

      $    >   $   

 "  >       

 #  #  

 $  

  1 '. ( 

#  $ 8    

+



D    

$  



# 

 #"  "  " '/?"  " "$  #   $  "- "   "- " #      $      $      "   ,   "   "  + "

 "'/?

 

  " #  "    # #  $ > #

   #

  

"

  $ ,  $ 



   # 

D          

     #"     

 #       "#   

-$-$  

    # " #*!8 #+ +  "

$ $"- "# 

 #



*!8 G #+   

 

 4 55A+ 5.8< " ((6> 

$

'5 .'

11.

 $  ""

'/?"     .? "$" " 

"  /?$#  $(.   $   "  /?" $       ,  H *!8'=

$ "   "#          #     #    

 +" )!8 + 

    9     " 

, #    4 /7.+ ((8<    "+"     $ " ""

 

   '/?"  "#  

H *72, 3  "

 " #)!8 $

 # 

> $  #  A/? # "$ " # '.

'..1 "  

#  "     " 

#  

"

   "

 "  

 ,

   $        

 #   "     $   

>    >  "  /?$

$$   >  H"

+ 

# 

  

 # 

#8    # 

!  

      

 +,  + "  +

,            

  #"  

    ,   "

#    ,  - ,$ ,+ 1    #

 

"@I#+ " ) & - $&3) 4%.

 5( &

56 &

7 2!81 & 9)!5$(

5%.

:

;< ...

$7$2 .

D      #"    $,     #     #  /? "  $ >   "$ 

 (.  @ >  H"$  # "

     

$ ,, #  # $  "

+ 

$  "  "# "

@,   #"" #   

  

 

$



   ,$"         -  '



 .? " "$ >  # " #

     .? " ""    $ >    /? " "  $(.     ""  

   "-    "     /?  $        (.  

@$, 

 #"  /? > 

  , #-

4  A56 /  / 161$$

 , #      4     '.

161 "   H " #  #9+   

$ >  $ #'5 161$  "# $  " "

  #       'B(C 1A(   9  

   'B(C 1A( H  #$J8 E 'B(C8 :"  ##  $ #"# ,   " "$   ("  $ $"H  .?

"  : "" $

  "    $  "     $H  .?"     "          #  

 * #,>   , #

,  $  -

 "$  "  $ $"H  .? "    "" $     " " $   " 

 " ,         #"  /?#

"

4 A56 /  / 161 #    '.

.1 161 $>   

   'B(C 1A(  #   ,# - "- "$("   

$ >   "   $ $ "H  .?"  # 

     , 

, 

'

    $  $ -H     

  ,    "

$  

   H " "- " 18  1A(  "#     J8 E1

   = &%$!& !"

8 5$!> 8   



"      H

 (  

 #8 B5C 6     "           -    

" H  .?" 

 

  "

  #,      "-    "

        

 $"

   H 

:   >  $  "

> $" #   >  :# #

,  

""- " "$     "

  #

  "  #    + ,$$-# @I#),< 1.

 &

2$ % $&

7$

&> !) 5% 4%.

) $& &#$ !11$%%$!& 5

&> 5$&#$8  #5 5( !

!7 5&1 & !"

 5( &

&> !) 5%*  ; < 

$7$2 ??@  

 &> &

9>)$5

4%.



!"

 5( &

&> !) 5%*  + ;< ...

$7$2 ?.

 

  

 

 1   $ , H"#





@$,   

  ,$

 # H " -$H   ,     "H *   "" #*!8'8 #+ +  )!8 K+ 

 

  9    )!8  ,

"

 $ #

     '/?"   "#   H *7 :  ",

#" #*!8  )!8 $ 8# $

  

," " # 



 #H " "- "'/?# ""

"  " ,        :   "    , #

  + 1    #$ , ,  + ,$$ -# 8

<   7$

4%.

A %) /91

&> !) 5%*

:;< - + B

1.

) &> 5 &

) $

4%.

)$ "

>1$&$%5 !5* !9%$&3 !

5>  5( &

&>

&!) 5  ;< 

$7$2     5( &

56 &

7 2!81 & 9)!5$( )5!93) $% )$ "

>1$&$%5 !5

&>

&!) 5 4%.

/ >  )

 ;<

 

$7$2 @.

9   $   , "

    #H   # $

 

-"   #  "  :# #H  ""#  

      "#$>  + ,$$-#@I# ),  56$&> 5 $&3)

)$22!&

&>

&!) 5 4%.

&$!&  55$!5(* ) &>$3 5)

&> !) 5%

@

C 

$7$2 ?C.

 

 "

  $ ,  $

 

 , #$ #        "         ,    ,  

,     

 

 # 

 '

'. / ##8 

:,  

" 

 #    ) & - $&3) 2,% # %

%985 $ @I#

H # ,   "

            8 "    8         ,     

$  #  ,

@$, ,$$ $#

 7$

2*

1.

) &> 5 &

) $

&> / >  )

%985     8    #$  ,  ,   

     



  " #  , 

    +

 $

  

  '

'. /  #) 0



 8   

'. (       

 ;/

0<

 

)*  +