Joginder Singh And ANR v. Gurpreet Singh And ORS

 
 
  
 


  !

 "#$ %$&'(')* *  +')%$,')+-")%")#-$, ..$//")#( 0$,(1( 1,.,$$#')+-")%#-$,( 
$(.)%$)#( 
 2345
6
 7-$#-$,
$.,#$,( 5&"/$8(.".$,(9":;$"//8$%# ($$#-$<1%+9$)#= :$( ;$,$ $,,$%##-$
$.,#$,(,)#=:$( 7-$#-$,#-$<1%+9$)#(-1/%;$,$.,#$%')#-$ '+$(#=:$( ,$($)#2 ,-19")>%0&"#$ ,#-$"..$//")#
   

   ,#-$,$"()(9$)#')$%')#-$"../'&"#')>%$/":   

%":(  ')  ,$3 '/')+  #-$  "..$"/  (#")%(  &)%)$%    (#")%(  %'(.($%  

"&&,%')+/:

  -'('(")"..$"/%',$&#$% ;:./"')#'

?"..$//")#("+"')(##-$ <1%+9$)#")%%$&,$$%"#$%   @."(($%;:-,'

"'>%%'#')"/

'(#,'&#1%+$>1,%"(.1,0'%$8-'&-#-$"..$"/.,$ $,,$%;:#-$%$ $)%")#( "+"')(##-$<1%+9$)#")%%$&,$$%"#$%  A ."(($%;:9#9")%$$.

6"1,-"1-")>#-$#-$)/$",)$%'0'/1%+$ 1)', '0'(')!>1,%"(.1,

 8"("&&$.#$%")%#-$(1'#

(8"(%'(9'(($%  ,'$  "&#( #-$.,$($)#&"($",$#-"##-$./"')#'

(-"0$ #-$(1'#"+"')(##-$%$ $)%")#(8'#-#-$"0$,9$)#(#-"##-$./"')#'

(",$') .-:('&"/&1/#'0"#')+.(($((') #-$/")%9$"(1,')+6")"/("( 1//:

%$#"'/$%")%%$(&,';$%')#-$-$"%)#$ #-$./"')# ,#-$/"(#9,$#-")  :$",(")%.,$0'1(/:/")%')(1'#8"(/8/:')+",$"")%./"')#'

(9"%$ '# '# ,&1/#'0"#')(.$)%')+-1+$"91)#")%-",%/";1,")%#-$/")%') (1'#'(('#1"#$%8'#-')#-$/"//"B', 0'//"+$>$-('/")% '(#,'&#1,%"(.1, -$,$'(""&,$ /")%8'#-')#-$5"/5"B', #-$0'//"+$9",+",-")% /"')#'

(",$.,.,'$#,( #-$0'//"+$")%/")%')(1'#&"9$')##-$(-",$ 

(') "9'/:($##/$9$)#;$#8$$)#-$.,.,'$#,( #-$0'//"+$ ")%#-$,.,.,'$#,(",$"/(').(($((') #-$,/")%  ,9#-$/")% 9$"(1,')+ "&,$9$)#')$%";0$8-'&-&"9$##-$',(-",$') "9'/:

($##/$9$)#")%%$ $)%")#(",$').(($((') "&,$ /")% ,9#-$/")% 9$"(1,')+"&,$9$)#')$%";0$8-'&-'(#-$,#-")#-$(1'#/")%-$ %$ $)%")#(-"0$),'+-#>#'#/$,')#$,$(#8'#-#-$(1'#/")%-$,$'(".",#:

"&#')')#-$0'//"+$")%./"')#'

(;$/)+(#)+,$((.",#:>8-$,$"(#-$ %$ $)%")#(;$/)+##-$B"/' "/,1/')+.",#:-$:')&))'0")&$8'#- #-$./'#'&"//$"%$,",$#-,$"#$)')+#-$./"')#'

#%'(.(($((#-$./"')#'

,9#-$(1'#/")%'//$+"//:")% ,&';/:-$./"')#'

-"0$(8)8-$"#&,.

')#-$(1'#/")%")%$0$),"9")&-":"# 0'//"+$9",+",-+'0$)') 8,'#')+)@

*#-"#./"')#'

",$').-:('&"/&1/#'0"#')+.(($((')

#-$(1'#/")%")%,"9")&-":"#."(($%,$(/1#'),$+",%')+#-$("9$-$

,$C1$(#$%#-$%$ $)%")#()19;$, #'9$(#"%9'##-$&/"'9

;1##-$%$ $)%")#(",$"%"9")#")% ')"//:,$ 1($%#%($)&$ #-'((1'#   .))#'&$%$ $)%")#("..$",$%#-,1+-&1)($/")% 8,'##$)  (#"#$9$)#  ;:  #"B')+  .,$/'9')",:  ;<$&#')(  ,$+",%')+  )) 9"')#"')";/$>-"0')+)&"1($ "&#')")%/&1(3(#")%'>-"0')+)#&9$ .,$($)###-$&1,#8'#-&/$")-")%()9$,'#(>'#-"(;$$)./$"%$%#-"##-$

( ",$)#$0$) ')".(($((')0$,")')&- (1'#/")%-$

(",$)##-$.,.,'$#,( #-$0'//"+$>,"#-$,#-$:-"0$9'+,"#$%# 0'//"+$9",+",-" $8:$",(;"&B>(#-$:",$)##-$.,.,'$#,( 0'//"+$ $ $)%")#) 8"(",.")&- #-$0'//"+$")% '/$%(1'# , $<$&#9$)#  ;$ ,$  #-$ 

>  1,%"(.1,  "+"')(#  '/'.  ')+-  "#-$,  

",.")&- "/8')%$, ')+- ;$&"1($ -$8"( ')  '//$+"/ ")%  1)"1#-,'D$% .(($((') #-$.")&-":"#/")%) #-$("'% "/'.')+-'(",.")&-

0'//"+$")%./"')#'

-"0$;$$))1,'(-')+"+,1%+$"+"')(##-$%$ $)%")#(

, '/')+$<$&#9$)#&"($"+"')(# "/'.')+-7'

$

+')%$, ')+-'("/(9$9;$, .")&-":"# 0'//"+$")%(1..,#$, #-$",.")&-> (#-$./"')#'

(-"0$ '/$%" "/($&"($"+"')(##-$%$ $)%")#(-$,'9')"/ &"($;$#8$$)%$ $)%")#)")%./"')#'

('("/(.$)%')+")%#-$.,$($)# (1'#'("&1)#$,;/"(###-$&,'9')"/&"($-$./"')#'

(;$')+.",#:9$) ")%,$/"#'0$ ",.")&-9'+-#-"0$.,&1,$%(9$8,)+8,'#')+')#-$',

"01,8-'&-",$)#;')%')+)#-$%$ $)%")#(-$%$ $)%")#(-"0$(8) 6-",'

&,.')#-$(1'#/")%#-$,"0$,9$)#(-"0$;$$)%$)'$%")%')/"(# .,":$,-"(;$$)9"%$ ,%'(9'(("/

@  
$./'&"#')8"()# '/$%,9#-$./$"%')+ #-$.",#'$(

//8')+'((1$(8$,$ ,"9$%23  


 


   



 

  

 


  


 






 


 





 


 

 





 
 




 


 
 

 

 










 
 


! 


 
 





"


 






 





 
 

 





 

 

 
#


$
%

 A -$.",#'$(-"0$/$%#-$',,$(.$&#'0$$0'%$)&$)#-$" ,$("'% '((1$(-$#,'"/1,#"

#$,"..,"'("/ #-$$0'%$)&$%$&,$$%#-$(1'#

0'%$<1%+9$)#")%%$&,$$%"#$%  A 

 $$/')+"++,'$0$%>#-$%$ $)%")#(.,$ $,,$%',(#"..$"/-$ /$",)$%%%'#')"/ '(#,'&#1%+$>1,%"(.1,0'%$ <1%+9$)#")%%$&,$$ %"#$%   @"&&$.#$%#-$"..$"/ #-$%$ $)%")#(")%%'(9'(($%#-$ (1'#

( * $$/')+%'(("#'( '$%8'#-#-$"

,$("'%<1%+9$)#")%%$&,$$ %"#$%   @>#-$.,$($)#,$+1/",($&)%"..$"/-"(;$$)%',$&#$%;: #-$./"')#'

(?"..$//")#(

 -$"..$//")#(').","+,".- #-$+,1)%( "..$"/> -"0$9$)#')$%#-"# //8')+(1;(#")#'"/C1$(#')( /"8-"0$",'($)') #-$.,$($)#,$+1/",($&)%"..$"/23

 & '











(
) 


#


 
 &

'






(
) 


#
 

  


 * 



  




'''!7-$#-$,#-$5%..$//"#$1,#8"()##%$&'%$#-$ &"($'((1$38'($=

'0!7-$#-$,#-$ ')%')+(,$&,%$%;:#-$5%,'"/1,#",$ )##;$"

',9$%=

0! 7-$#-$,#-$5%..$//"#$1,#&")($#"('%$#-$8$// ,$"()$% ')%')+( #-$5%,'"/1,#8'#-1# "(('+)')+"):,$"()(=

0'!

7-$#-$,'#'()#" '#&"($ ,,$9")% ,%$&'%')+ "

,$(-')#-$ "&#(")%&',&19(#")&$( #-$&"($=  -"0$-$",%/$",)$%&1)($/ ,#-$"..$//")#")%-"0$+)$ #-,1+-#-$&"($ '/$8'#--$,";/$"(('(#")&$  5$",)$%&1)($/ ,#-$"..$//")#-"((1;9'##$%#-"#..$//"#$ 1,#-"(8,)+/:"&&$.#$%#-$"..$"/-$ ')%')+ #-$#,'"/1,#-"( ;$$)($#"('%$8,)+/:8'#-1#+'0')+"):,$"()')+-$',(#..$//"#$ 1,# -"( 9'(,$"% ")% 9'(3"..,$&'"#$%  #-$ $0'%$)&$ ) #-$ '/$ -$ ..$//"#$1,#-"()#%$&'%$%#-$"..$"/'((1$38'($   -"0$&",$ 1//:&)('%$,$%#-$("'%(1;9'((');1#%)# ')% "): ,&$')#-"#(1;9'((') @ -$  ./"')#'

(  &/"'9 #-$9($/0$(  # ;$ ')  .(($((')    #-$ .,.$,#: ,#-$/"(#9,$#-") :$",(-$.,$($)#(1'#'("&/$0$,%$0'&$ #  $)&,"&-  1.)  #-$  /")%    #-$  0'//"+$  ")&-":"#    )  #-$  &,((3 $E"9')"#')73-"(&"#$+,'&"//:(#"#$%#-"#-$&"))##$//8'#-8-'&- .'$&$ /")%>-$'(').(($((')73 ",.")&- #-$0'//"+$'(#-$(#", 8'#)$(( ,#-$./"')#'

(7'

$ 73+')%$,')+-'(")&-')#-$

0'//"+$")%#-'(8'#)$(('(#-$",.")&- #-$0'//"+$#-"(;$$)"%9'##$% ;: #-$  ./"')#'

(4 8'#)$(($( #-"#  8'

$   +')%$, ')+-  ./"')#'

 '(  "

(1..,#$, #-$"/8')%$,')+-73 "/8')%$,')+-73 %1,')+-'( &,((3$E"9')"#')-"("%9'##$%#-"#/")%')%'(.1#$'((-"9'/"#3%$-#'( 0$,:1) ,#1)"#$#-"#"",.")&- #-$0'//"+$-"(&9$ ,8",%#(1..,# #-$ "/($&/"'9

(>8-'( ))$3/$((;1#'(#-$-1(;")%

9$9;$,.")&-":"#-$/")% #-$")&-":"# &"))#;$"//8$%#;$ $)&,"&-$%1.);:#-$./"')#'

("(-$)$'#-$,";/$#.,0$),8"(') .(($((')    #-$  (1'#  .,.$,#:   -$,$  '(  )#-')+  )  #-$  ,$&,%  #-"# <1%+9$)#")%%$&,$$ #-$',(#..$//"#$1,#'(#-$,$(1/# 9'(,$"%')+ ")%9'(')#$,.,$#')+#-$$0'%$)&$/$%;:#-$./"')#'

(#-"(&9$)#-$ ,$&,%#-"#%$ $)%")# 8"(",.")&- #-$0'//"+$")%-$-"% "../'&"#') ,$<$&#9$)#;$ ,$#-$

"+"')(# ",(-")')+- "#-$,

(",.")&-"B',')+-8--"..$)$%#;$73 >#-$",.")&-'),%$, #9"')#"')#-$$)&,"&-9$)# -'( "#-$,-"(&9$ ,8",%#(1..,#

"/($&/"'9

(> -"0$)-$('#"#')')-/%')+#-"#) (1;(#")#'"/C1$(#') /"8-"(",'($)')#-$.,$($)#"..$"/)($C1$)#/:> #-$"..$"/'(8'#-1#"):9$,'#")%#-$("9$(#")%(%'(9'(($%  &.: #-'(<1%+9$)#;$($)###-$#,'"/1,# , (#,'&# &9./'")&$ 
 

  

 !  "

#