Koshilya v. Union Of India And Others
!"#$%%
!"!&"'
!"#%(%
)# *+) ,,
, -
*+) , ,, , )
!"
# # $
% &&&& ,
, -
. ' ( )
*+*,,*'-./%'0
1"(
"" )
"
/'0&/1/'23 !&"
, (
)
*2'*'-345 "
) ")
6$ #7(876 )
""
!
!
" ,3*''-3+ (
) 9+*:
4 ) ! " " !
) "
(
!
. 0
;)! "
) "
.0 <
!
" + (
/ ,4*2,*'3 ( ) "
) *='*,*'3 "
)
;)! ) >" !
,2'*,*'3
5 "" 2 1
!
1"(
""
,4*2,*'3( !
*+*,,*'-( ! / "
!
"
#$ % &' ( % % &'
)
*
+
(
,
, - +
)
*
3 1
% % !
) $ "4
"'
!4056 !& 0 = 8/
)
!
"" "
!
<
"
) " 9+*:
;)!
"
!
" ? (
!""
"
" !
)
""
(
"" " "" / %' / ) " " !
( !
/%' ) ""
. 0
"/ "
' //// , @ ! "
) > ) "
A >
1 A / B
" *+*,34BC
$
;
;
,*
.' ,* 340 4
< ,
D
> 1"E
!
$
++++
++++
++++ .
/
0
)
1
)
2)3
4 - ( " F4 /%' ) /
;)!
. 0 " / %'
!
) (
!""
" ! "
'0 ( "
) 8
" F4 ! )
""
"
8
" F4 )
)
,0 $<
!
" ) "" " F4 8
"
8
" F4
)
'* ( "< " "
"
8
$ F4/%' ) ""
" " '' F)
"
"
) " "" " F4/%'
"
" F,/%'
) )
)
!
. 0 " F4 " )
', #
$ F4 < )""
"
) )
) " / !(
!
) !< " )
) !
;)!
!
! >
( !
" . 0 " F4 )
!
) !!
) ) )
)
!
""" "
8
" F4 )
) !
" 8
)
" " ) ! ! '4 $<
) " )!
"
"
+*: ) "
"
"
. 0 %!
" F4
""
%
'+ (
" " ) "
'2 ;)! " )
!
%G%!
"
"
"
"
" "
"
"
"
!
" "< "
>
;6
/$ "
"# $% & '
(
)
! ( !
! " / " #& 5 (
0 6 24
#%7
" /
8
9 . :
5 &;#<
+ 29 ='4 245
/
>9 39 $2 4?
24@
2
4
5
29 &4 24
>9 $24?
24
A
A
> $2 4?
24
+
, -
/
> $2 4?B 24 , -
.
<C , 2, :
4 #%%# D <8
6 C
:
<
=; &
'%
/
'3 "
! .0
!/ " "
"
)
"
"
"
) " / ,* : ! "
< !
<
'= F
"
"
) "
< ,*: !
< "
# "
"
!
"( "
" >
8
9 .:
5 &;#< 5
+ 29 ='4 '? 1
%G%!
"
"" "
)
"
!
) "" <
.0 < !
" "
!
!
)< . 0!
%G%!
"" % "
"
" " !
!
"
"
" " !
"
"" "
" H "
) !
%G%!
"" < <
!
" B
!
" '- #
"
"
.0 "
""
0 "" " ""
!
" "
# !
% %!
) ) )! """
"
0
<
"""
#
!
"
!
" "
,* 1
" ! "
/ ""
!
" )
! !
" . 0
# < ""
,' !
"
#
)
) $ % I@
.
0 ,**,JI8
@
"
I ,, ( ) )
! "
)
/
!
% %!
"
B) )
!
<
" ) "
/
% B
" % %!
" !
!
" )
$
""
) <
!
" " )
!
" ,4
<
" )
#
" D
"
! "
" "D "
!
" < !
"D "
" "" ) " !
"""
< <
" ) "
)
!
"
"
!
"$
" <
"
# "" ""
"
"
"
< " !" B "
!
" )
)
""
# " !
" " ! "
" "" )
)
,+ ;)! ) ! $ < / " " "
*+ ,-.
3 +
EF # 4++++ 4++++ 4++++ 4
. +
/+ 0 $# 1# - - - ,2
! !
"
)
;)! " "
" )
,3 F " "
" )
)
) %/
$""
) "
!
"$<
""
"
)
" " )
!
"
,= "<" "
/
)"
;6
/$ "
"# $% & '
( +) "
"
. 0
# ) " )!
"
D
"
) > . 0
" ) < !
" < !
)!
% %!
(
!
" "
;)! "
!
" "
"
% %!
"
"
#
!
"D"
""
"" " <.0 )
! " "
"
!
)
<
)
) "
!
" ,? ;)! ) . 0 "
"
#
>
"
" ). 0
!
" $ "
) !
" F,/%' ) )
6"/1
!4056 !& 0 ,- $ ) !
!
) 4* ( ./%'0 <
) " "" "
"
" >
;6
/$ "
2& '
% 3 4#A * 1 " "
4' (
!/"
)
4, " "
) " ! "
/$ #4++ 5
(4 $ 6()5
& '
*% / $ #4++5 (4 $ 6(#)5
!) #"% & '
*1-
1
44
.0
7,
, -
7, , )8 %(% !
5
/26"3:
/ !"
#
:!
5
9!
0/;1
#
:!