← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2411/2015dismissed

Bal Krishan v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. And ANR.

2017-03-21Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi9 pages

       

!" "#$%$&' (

)  

  

        



 !

"#



$%&'

"



 ! &(() *

 

+

  ' * + ,+-

,  -! .

(  

0000 ,+- +  .  

( 12 3425  )  /

(

   /  

    

      

       (   3428  /          (

  "  )     /   (

    )

(

" // 

(  #

 ) ")  (



//( / (

( )  (

(

 2 /

   

 

 

        &  " (()(

(

  (9

:2361%!*  

  /  "         /     /  ;  "  (    

83:247749   /((



 "(     

      //"(

 -   '  

)   /    /  ((  (



  )    ( ('   "

(  )     //(  /  /  

 3< 3445  "

 )

 (

( 

 "  

    /  /   //"    /"      

//( //  "   



 /

  ) 

' /(  

"

   // ! ( 

//(



 "

 ) / ) 

'  



)   

( )  

 ( ('

- (. 9

1<4147 3445(   

)/ (     /   -   . 3< 3445" ( "(.

36 " 



   /(   (' ;

   //

(   /    "  " .   /   " 

)      /     /   

       ) (  "  /



) /  )   

 /2254:2=.9

35<6 25 344<

 



(      /(

  )       )  

   

  / 21564:=  . 

(

271<34 4:

344:

  /    /"  

    )        

  

 / 1<412=.9

3:12

 

 / 37475= .

13:834 344:



  /    ' //.38 2767/ "      (

(

  )2767"    ( ()

   "   /    )  / " ) "

) /(

  //  /(

( 9

:4: /3446   ( (       (

    "  " "

 ;

      /   

   /235817=.

541:28   //"(

  

  

 /235817= 1:244=."

(   9 331 33824 344:

  

  /(

(

(()  -  "    (

     

       

  55285=

" //   -.   ./ 

 ( / 

 "     

  ) (

> 

  /   (

/   "  ,= ?       //       /   (

 

)/ @>

 ?       //       /     )

(

 )/ @>

?   

      / @ >  ?    //

 )  "

(

(/ /    @>  ?    // 

 =  (  (

 /   @>  < ?     /   



/ () @>  :

?   #

 

(

    )   @>  +/

? ." .  (. (   

 

 

(  )" . (  /   (

/      

  . (

 

(  (

(  (

( 

  // / . ( 9 )"/

  (

'  )    / =

   ((  )       /   (

    )

(

".

( 26  / /// /

" ( 

(   )  /

(

.



(12 - (  (

    

((/  //  - (

/  

   ( /  //=

 "  

  )/

 

("  ) /     /// 



(    

( "        /  /(   

 ( ('   

    3< %&A

?22* ;   

 (

  / /  //=

 ( (' 

3< 3445"

    

(  /  //=

  )     &A( .  &   & (   =;;  

/( ('    / 

// ;

/( ( (' 

"(

  )  // /(  /    

  (     ="  "

    / /  / " 9

1<417 3425 "   "

  ;  

(  "

(.  "/  )"   / (

   )



(

(    .)

 /  

    /  (. "" "

14    " " "

   )

  

= // /(

      (  / (

/ (    / /

25 344:

 /  /   /     //  /  (   "     (  #

 

+   " ( "" "

 //

(  /( 

(  (

" (       // )/ .  ( ) (  (

. ( . (  -.    #

/

 



(    (

  """ "    (

  

 (   .  



  /

(

 / .  (

( 

(

/( " ( / 

(  (  (. #  /  (  )   /

(

 23 21 /

 " ( .  

( 

,= 



          

  



    

       !"#   $           



  %  %  %

    

  &#'

()*

 ( $  +         



 

     

                $       



!

, ($  

    $   





!

, +              

     



  $

$   

           $    !

, 

  - 

 

 !

, 

        $      !

,  

.

   $  ( +         / 



    !"#  $   

 

 



 



     

 + 





  %

&%  % 

  

  0+$

  

-  !"#+

  

   

 









       



  

    $  

  

  

  % (      

  $     





 $ 

$

  %  %     

 

 

   

&

   (        &

 &#'

((    $

  



   $

      +  %    %    &

&#'

()*

+   $   

             

 

$

 

    %    %         

   

    &

      

 $

 

 .

   $  1   

+

 $ 





 $ 

$







   

/2+  34+  $     







   



      

      



  



6

  

2+   



  

   

      $

-2+7  38

   $  %  %

-27  !48  



   $    3  $      



   $    

 

 

 %  % 0 

.

     + +

   *  + 





   $

-2%   %   $         

   ,  +       #



  



 



  , 

    $                 $ 

      

   $

+           

 

   

            $     

 +    

  

   

 

 

  

+



$ (   

       



  $ 



    

 

    $

      +    $  

 

 

 9++2#:+9+/+;2#:+9/+/#:+9-+-#:

 9/2+#:   

    

  $

   <; 

 +  <-/ 

22+  <2/ 

 2 

 </24

 2          

  





  

( +  

            



   

    

     > (     //=

  /       "   "



     / /

 

  . ("

  /  /

  )")



;  (  

(



 . 

 /  

 ;  



/"  //  

  "

    .   ( )    (       (

. ( . (  //



 

 "'

 / (  /  ;



")

  // .   ( - ".   ( //=

 )/

. ( ) (  . ( ;

 ." / 

/ (  /

"  (

 /   //((  )   (

  "  .  



  .."'  ) #

 / 

/  /  "   / -

B !

#

"  #

,= C !

$)   3446%:* !##65%!#* ! / )   9 !  

  3425%8*+#+%(.*578%!#*  C  ( )     

     !  (  !

( !  %( 

    .*   3423%<:*+#+%(.* 783% -* !

 

  !

9 

  3428%17*+#+%(.*2<<% -*    (

 /   (

/  

/  

 

   )     )    .)       /    

  )  (

  "

-



/  )D 

/" (   D 

/"" (  D 

/    (

    / 

#

 " A( 

 (

!(

244 /  #  /#. (  ;

  ((   (

 

 / -

B !

#

  ./ & & 0"&1. & &1 &!2".3%+"4%25/ .0$&$ &1!2".%6

7#$8$9:;  &!%2 < .$3%=.%2!! 5$> .$6

( )7   " #

   ( /( ((  ( / (

 .(

"  

/  

 #

 / 

."  

(

(. / / "

)  (   / 9 (/  / (  



+  )  "     .  .

       (

  "." 

 

,+-

 342: