Jagdish Chand v. State Of Haryana
!"# !$%&%"' ( ( )*%&++'* (((((! % %"'!, -!,&.& / !"#,0' ((((( !&1"'*!'
23
(// / ,!&!'
,('4"5, 1/%')+ ''6*7"$ !6 #", +!1! % %"'!,(
,(7!!'8.4,/+!",'6 6,0'( / / 6( 9 3:
( +!1,!&!' 1! % %"'+&;!!'#%5!*.'*!,/!$ %"' "# +!"*!
"#,%4%'5,"$!*.,!#",),' "#' %$%1 ",0;%5 " +!1! % %"'!,%'$&! ;!,%') "(< 6* !* ( (6.'*!,/!$ %"'&= 9 :9:.'>;?$%&! $ 6 < 9,0'4!'*4!' %556:69/!$ %"'& 6 <6 6 =@6
= 6 @ 6 @ '* **!* 5 !,:6 ,!)%& !,!* "5%$! / %"' +'*%4'*%,6'$+A.5,0'( ( %&&.;4% !*;0 +!5!,'!*$".'&!5#", +!1! % %"'!, + +! 1! % %"'!,+&;!!'#5&!50%415%$ !*%' +!1,!&!' $&!&%'$!+!B&'" '4!*%' +! '*+%&'4!+&;!!'&.,#$!*"'50"' +!;&%&"# *%&$5"&.,!& !4!' "#$"$$.&!*6B+%$+%&'" *4%&&%;5!%'!7%*!'$!(! #., +!, &.;4% !* + +! +* )" '" +%') " *" B% + +! 55!)!* 5%C.", ,!$"7!,!*#,"4 +!$' !,'*$"'&%*!,%') +!#",!&%*#$ &6+!40;! $"'&%*!,!*#",),' "#' %$%1 ",0;%5(
( ' +!" +!,+'*6 ,(7!!'8.4,/+!",'65!,'!* 6 ,0' +&#%5!**! %5!*##%*7% "';!+5#"# +!,!&1"'*!' D/ !'* &.;4% !* + % %&$&!B+!,! +!$' !,B&%' !,$!1 !*;0 +!1"5%$!'* +!*,%7!,"# +!$' !,6'4!506,!'*!,8.4,B&5&"11,!+!'*!*;0 +! 1"5%$!6#,"4B+"4 +!,!B&,!$"7!,0"#@;"?!&D$, "'&"#C., !,;" 5!& "#5%C.",B+%$+B&%55!)55%C.",'**.,%') +!%'7!& %) %"'% +&;!!' #".'* + +!5%C.",B&&.115%!*;0 +!1! % %"'!,(!#., +!,&.;4% !* + +!1! % %"'!,B&5&" +!*%,!$ ","#$"41'06'4!506 D&A5/+0!
E%'!&,%7 !3%4% !*'*+!%&+;% .5"##!'*!,'*+!%&5&"4!4;!,"# '%' !,& !)')"#5%C.",&4.))5!,&(!#., +!,&.;4% !* + +!,!,! B" 4",! &)%'& +!1! % %"'!,5 +".)+%' +"&!$&!&&B!55+!B& '"4%' !* +!,!# !,(!5&"&.;4% !* + "'!"# +! "(
* !* ( (6,!)%& !,!* "5%$!/ %"' %6/"'!1 .'*!,/!$ %"'&= 9 :9:"# +!,0'?$%&!$ 66/!$ %"'& 6 =@6 = 6 @ '* 6 +!
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
( +7!+!,* +!5!,'!*$".'&!5&#", +!1, %!&(
( %&$&!B+!,! +!1! % %"'!,B&5 +".)+'" '4!*%' +!
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
4% #% '*1,"1!, "),' +!' %$%1 ",0;%5 " +! 1! % %"'!,("'&!C.!' 506 +!1,!&!' 1! % %"'%&+!,!;0*%&4%&&!*( @( "B!7!,6'0 +%')";&!,7!*+!,!%';"7!&+55'" ;! ,! !*&' !?1,!&&%"'"#"1%'%"'"'4!,% &"# +!$&!'*%&"'504!' #", +!1.,1"&! "#*!$%&%"'"#1,!&!' 1!
+.4%A (E+! +!,&1!A%')D,!&"'!*
!&D" (E+! +!,,!1", ;5!
!&D"