← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2456/2015dismissed

Panna Lal (Since Deceased) Through His Lr v. Budhram @ Budhu (Deceased) Through His Lrs And ORS

2016-04-08Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh7 pages



      

 



 !"#$!! %%  &"# '#(!")*'#(!#!"#$!!(!"%(      !"  #!$%

"

"(% "+!,!!"-(.-

"!%% /%%    #!$%&

!'! !"

 (()*+,-./0 0") !"("((1 1 -!"%" !  ))"23/4 "! "(,#"4 5-!43( 5!!%"%%  %%  5(6! "("%"+""( 3#"/!$"#( %% 

# -)10,-./1  6!%%   (47!% 

#5!!5("( ! .#"47! "((( ,. 8#($".8!99"-.(! 9#($)(("(( 

:-5!!9#($)(("- !5."-(("."(47! "((( "8#($- 8!99"-! "%%   (47!"%(!"( (! #  6! -!.4+ ")!9#($) ! "( ,. 8#($-"!!%% /% 

!" "" ""(!

  #$!    ( "  (  ;#  %")  9#

 !" "-$!"%(/( (!" "" ""( ( (-!

!!% 

!5"%    )#"$

;7"(-#(! 8)9(-8!99"- ("4(    (    !  % -  5!!  !  % 

  )(    !. %#"!(

::

-%#4 #- "

</- "5!!! ")(5"% !(%  05 $(!!% 

4$ (%""($5!

 7!5 -!( (5""7$(%!) ")!( % -!#$!!7!("5!!%"%"7,;# 7-!# 5  ( = >%    4$  #(-  !  ( (   (  !"  5" )  #4)$  !  !  "  ( (-  '#(!")-   $5!  ! 4"!" ! $!(# )-5"5"% !# #)4"(.#%"%"7 -)#"$1 ;7"(-5!!!( 4%#"!(47!).( ((((  :

- ")'#(!

. '!$5-5!4)!5"!" !4   " #(47!!4 %")  :

 05 #"!" )(47!( (-!!% (%# 5%" %"%"7  !5"(??)$!9#($)

!,. 8#($4# " ")!9#($) ! "( "%%  ,#"@-5 )(!!% 

!(!$(5!! (%#(% (!!!(3(5"$% 5!!%  0  5  #"!"  #4)(  47  !  ( (    !  5" )-!" ",. #  ::- ( # )&

 -!% 

!%"#%"%% !%%  !(%"(#(% 23/!" "#5!!!!5(! (%#(  %     4  !  %"%"7    %"  "%(/( (   '#(!")(! 4"!" ! $!(# ) @-5

= % ((!!% 

5%%( ")+$5! 7"("7 (!#5  (47!)   >%!4.% ($-!  5$#5" ")(47 "((( ,. 8#($

 A!!"!% 

5"% #  %     ( (    %"/    !  %   ( (%(5! "',"( #"! % !(!"5!B

 A!!"!( (" $ 7"

"$ !  % #  5"!%  (  %    !

." !  (%#(  %  47 57   "$ "#!""7!")"5!# !.$  7  "$!-     "  "  5!." !"5!B

 A!!"!% 

! #/(  ! %"#B  . A!!"!#)4 !%"

")B  . A!!"  !  % 

   %%(  ")   $  ! %"#47!5((#B  . A!!"!% 

!#    !%"#B  . A!!"!( (" (%  B  .     6!% 

3)(55(("(.(- 5(#)5!"!( (3)(15   >%(" !.(4 "!)(!% ($ (!"$#)"(-! "(,. 8#($ #(!( ( '#(!")!(()(!"3)!%   4 $ !% 

(!!!"5!!) A/-,!# - !5."-()(!!#%"%"754$#(47!( ( 5!!!7!("(5 

,;# 7! "(,. 8#($! (!!( ( !("$!"

"   5!!4 $!% 

@- !5( "(4!5" %   )#"$

;7"(( !( (5"""( ")"

"$ ")!#%"%"77 )"6!#!#  (47!%"%% /% 

5("( ! .#" 1 0  !  %%   (  47  !  %"  "%(  4 "  ! "(  ((  "  8#($-  8!99"-  !  "(  ((  " 8#($(!-!"/3)-!% 

!(()(! !((+5!() !(%#(% (!(()(! !"3    45! ((!(%#(%  @

#"!"(!! ( 5"(!"( !(%#( ( (!! ((+55!!"  %#"!(47'#(!.

:

-5 (47!('#(!.'#(!"): (!! " !% 51 ;7"( 6!% 

!( ()(!!!(  (%  !"#%($45!)(# )-"$"($%  - !#$!!(!!(%#( (3(5"(!5"(

!(%     #$!)7 A/-,!# -! "( 5"

%% ,#"(!!#$!,!# !((%(!! ( ;#55((%(47!% 

 "!!(%#"!(  : ::

-!5."-!()(!!((+5!()  !(%#( (6!5 ()(!3  (? 5"(!"( !(%#( (- "5!!!!#

/  53$

A  #"!"  ()(  !  !  !#  3$  5"(  ! 5"( !(%# (5%#"!(47'#(!.: (

" (47!)'#(!"):

(!!#)4" !(!#   6!5 #"!"()(!!(%#( (54$ #(474!'#(!")(# )-!#$!? "4 7?@ ()( !3 5 ."!(%#( ( 6!5-!()-5 #(4!4"!"

!% 

/   6!" "-  !  "(  "  %%   ,#"  (#(  ! .( (47!( ((  : @.$  (#(  !  .(  (  4 "  !  "(  ,. 8#($-! "%% ,#" #(!! 7;#55!!"! #%"%"75%" %   5(47!% 

-"%" #%"%"75(47!( (6!" "-%%"!4.- ! "( "%% ,#")%"(!% -23 =#4)(47 !% 

!?#""#?-5!!% " "#4)(47!)- 23/=!#  ($!% 

47# ) C"))%" !)-! "(,#" #(! "% 23/=!% 

!(()(!! 

 ! $!

(# ) #((!(%#(%"%"7(!!"!(-! # (%".!!"5!!!!5(4!(%#(%"%"7 23 =-# 7 ")(%" %   %#"!(47!)!7"

:

    #"!"-5!! "  %"%"7  23/ -!5(!!"5 (    

5"(!"( %  6!3 ! !(  4()(47 A/6!" "- " 7$! "(.(- ! "( "%% ,#"- #(!! 



     %"%"7 (#!-!(%#(%"%"75%" +!"

 ( -!% 

!(!5!3 !  45+!" (   @-%%"  !.(4.( #"!"$.$ ))"( -! "( "%% ,#"(!9#($) (  ("    !  ((  ,.  8#($  (  ()(  !  #    !

 A!!)")#%4 "!"$ "! ") 1 1 -!#  "!% 

!(4("(% ""( !%% -!"%" !  ))"-23/ 6!("%"!54% (""(-%"# 

5!!!5!!%" 4!%" "% #)4"  ( (5)#"(-5!!5 #(4""%"!%  (  !  )#")    5!!  5       "(  5!  !    " #("% !(% -!5$4 "

;7"( 6!     "   %"(#(  47  !  % 

-  !5$  %    4

;D"("-5 #(4)!$5!7

!% !%  % ".( ")!""( !6! ("

  !%") !4  @-  "  %"%"  ()"    %     -  !   ))""))((!!E

  !# (4$%"%"( = "(% "+!,!!"- "(#  "!%% /

 5  "%"(  !"#$!  !  -  #4)(  !  !   ))"?"%" ")( #.(#!-"  !# (!.4% (#%47! "( 5"%% ,#" ;#"7-!5."- "(# # ((7!!% -23/= %"(#(47!( ( !## 5!!! (%% "-5!)% !(4%"(#(47!% 

23/

-!#  ($!)47# )-4"!" ( ( 6! # %4$(%#-0(!5 !%% # (!.#"("#(!#4;##!5! (%#( (4  $5!(

"4#("!#4;# #   %"#  !9#($) ! 5"%% ,#"!5 !  !  ,#"  !  $    (     !  4    ."#    %  %"(#(4 "- !  ))"?"%"-)  #!!(%#( (   %   5(47 ! %% /% 

-4#%  5(47!"%(/( ( 04$5! 7 ($ !4 (#)"7-  " .( (4 "!,#"4 5-0 ("5!."

$! ($-5!!!4!54%"."7 )" ,;# 7-!%% ()(  -5!"(" 



2  #!$%3 !   4$