Gurpartap Singh v. Ranjit Singh And ANR


   
 
   
 
   
 
   
 
 
 
 


 

 

 

  !"# #$%&%'(   ) !"# #$%&%'(   ) !"# #$%&%'(   ) !"# #$%&%'(   ) *+,!+"!,%'-.

*+,!+"!,%'-.

*+,!+"!,%'-.

*+,!+"!,%'-.

,,#//!'"

,,#//!'"

,,#//!'"

,,#//!'"

0#+&*& 0#+&*& 0#+&*& 0#+&*&
!'1##"%'-.!'2!'".#+
!'1##"%'-.!'2!'".#+
!'1##"%'-.!'2!'".#+
!'1##"%'-.!'2!'".#+ 
#&,'2#'"& 
#&,'2#'"& 
#&,'2#'"& 
#&,'2#'"& 
( 
( 
( 
( 3 4
  
 454 3 4
  
 454 3 4
  
 454 3 4
  
 454  5.#".#+
#,+"#+& ".#/$!/,!,#+&6!78# !//9#2"&##".#1*2-6#'":

 8#+# #++#2"".#
#,+"#+&+'":

 5.#".#+".#1*2-6#'"&.*/28#+#,+"#2%'".# %-#&":

+#&#'"( + !+6%'2#+%'-.;2<$!"# +".#!,,#//!'" ===

!+!61##"%'-..!/%9!/; +!/

!+!61##"%'-..!/%9!/; +!/

!+!61##"%'-..!/%9!/; +!/

!+!61##"%'-..!/%9!/; +!/ .%&+#-*/!+&#$'2!,,#!/

%&2%+#$"#2 !-!%'&"".#1*2-6#'"!'22#$+##2!"#2   ,!&&#287 /#!+'#2  22%"%'!/  %<%/  *2-#  #'%+  %<%&%';  &&!'2.;

9.#+#87  &*%"  +  2#$/!+!"%'  9%".  $'&#>*#'"%!/  +#/%#  

,#+6!'#'"  %'1*'$"%'  .!&  8##'  2%&6%&&#2  !'2  !-!%'&"  ".# 1*2-6#'"  !'2  2#$+##  2!"#2  ?    ,!&&#2  87  /#!+'#2 22/%&"+%$" *2-#;@!+'!/9.#+#87!,,#!/ %/#287".#,/!%'"%

.!&8##'2%&6%&&#2 +  $'<#'%#'$#  &!A#;  .#+#%'!

"#+;  +# #+#'$#  " ,!+"%#&%&8#%'-6!2#!&,#+".#%+&"!"*&%'".#,/!%'"

 .#2#"!%/#2 !$"&!+#!/+#!27+#$!,%"*/!"#2%'".# 1*2-6#'"&    ".#  $*+"&  8#/9  !'2  !+#  '"  +#>*%+#2  "  8# +#,+2*$#2   '  8+%# ;  ".#  !$"  +#/#<!'"  +  2%&,&!/    ".%& &#$'2!,,#!/!+#"".##

#$"".!"".#,/!%'"%

%/#2&*%" + 2#$/!+!"%'9%".$'&#>*#'"%!/+#/%# ,#+6!'#'"%'1*'$"%'

9%".".#!<#+6#'"&".!".#%&9'#+  ?&.!+#!'2.!& 8*%/"!.*&#'.%&/!'2!'2.!&8*%/"'#+6;8*'2!+79!// !'2 *'2!"%' ".#+.*&#9%". %<# ##".%-.9!//#.!& 8##'  /%<%'-  %'  ".#  &!%2  .*&#  !/'-  9%".  .%&  !6%/7   .# 2# #'2!'"&87"!A%'-!2<!'"!-# ".#9+'-+#<#'*##'"+%#& %'".#'!6# ".#%+,+#2#$#&&+C%'C%'"#+#&";+!%&#2!$/!%6<#+ ".#/!'2

;.9#<#+;".#7!+#'"%',&&#&&%'

#<#'%'$. ".#/!'2%'>*#&"%'#'$#;&*%"9!& %/#2 ,''"%$#;".#2# #'2!'"&+#&%&"#2".#&*%"!'2

%/#29+%""#'&"!"#6#'""!A%'-<!+%*&,+#/%6%'!+781#$"%'&" 9!&  &*86%""#2  ".!"  ".#7  9#+#  9'#+  %'  ,&&#&&%'    /!'2 6#!&*+%'-A!'!/ 6!+/!&%"*!"#2%'A%/!B C;A%//!  )C "9!& *+".#+&*86%""#2".!"".#,&&#&&%'

".#2# #'2!'"&%&,#!$# */!'29%".*"!'7%'"#++*,"%' +".# /!&"!8*"?

7#!+&!'2".#%+#'"%"/#6#'"<#+".#,%#$# /!'2 %&'".#8!&%& $%<%/$*+"2#$+##".#+!<#+6#'"&%',/!%'" 9#+#2#'%#2!'22%&6%&&!/ &*%"9!&,+!7#2 + '".#8!&%& ,/#!2%'-& ,!+"%#&;".#*+" %+&"

%'&"!'$# +!6#2 //9%'-%&&*#&(

 D 5.#".#+".#,/!%'"%

%&#'"%"/#2 +2#$+##

2#$/!+!"%'!&,+!7#2 +:

  5.#".#+".#,/!%'"%

%&#'"%"/#2 +2#$+##

,#+6!'#'"%'1*'$"%'!&,+!7#2 +:

 5.#".#+".#&*%"

%&8!++#287 ,+%'$%,/#    +#&C1*2%$!"!  %'  <%#9    ".# 1*2-6#'"  %'  $%<%/  &*%" 
!'1%"  %'-.  #"$   0& @+%&.!'@*6!+#"$:

? 5.#".#+,/!%'"%

.!&'$!*&# !$"%'!'2 /$*&C&"!'2%" %/#".#,+#&#'"&*%":   5.#".#+&*%"

%&'"6!%'"!%'!8/# %'".#,+#&#'" +6:  ) 5.#".#+".#&*%"

%&8!2 +6%&C 1%'2#+!'2''C1%'2#+ ,!+"%#&:  E 5.#".#+".#,/!%'"%

.!&'"$6#"".#*+"

9%".$/#!'.!'2&;% &"9.!"#

#$":  F
#/%#  "#+!,,+#$%!"%'-".##<%2#'$#;".#*+" %+&"

%'&"!'$#2%&6%&&#2".#&*%"<%2#1*2-6#'"!'22#$+##2!"#2

     ##/%'-  !--+%#<#2;  ".#  ,/!%'"%

 ,+# #++#2  !'

!,,#!/8# +#/#!+'#222%"%'!/%&"+%$" *2-#;@!+'!/9.%$.

.!&8##'2%&6%&&#2<%2#%6,*-'#2+2#+2!"#2 ?    #'$#;".%&+#-*/!+&#$'2!,,#!/ .!<#.#!+2/#!+'#2$*'&#/ +".#!,,#//!'"!'2 ,#+*&#2".#+#$+2 4#!+'#2 $*'&#/ +".#!,,#//!'".!&+# #++#2"

//9%'-  &*8&"!'"%!/  >*#&"%'&    /!9  +6*/!"#2  %'  ".# -+*'2& !,,#!/ +$'&%2#+!"%'87".%&*+"( % 5.#".#+ %'2%'- 8".".#$*+"&8#/9%'

,#+<#+&%"7    ".#  +!/  #<%2#'$#  9.#+#  ".# #H$/*&%<#,&&#&&%'

.!&8##'

!26%""#2;%&#<#+&*&"!%'!8/#%'".##7#&

/!9 %% 5.#".#+  ".#  ,/!%'"%

 8#%'-  %'  #H$/*&%<# ,&&#&&%' ".#,+,#+"7%&#'"%"/#2"$/!%6 +%-."!'2"%"/#!-!%'&"".#$C&.!+#+%'".##7#&  /!9!'2".#,+"#$"%'&*-." + ".#&!%2 ,+"%'%&#<#+/#-!//7,#+6%&&%8/#%'".##7#&  /!9:

%%% 5.#".#+87<%+"*# #$"%'?  ".#/!'2 +#<#'*#  !$"  &*%"  "  6!2#  $.!//#'-#  %'  ".# 9+'- #'"+%#&  ".#+#$+2  +%-."%&#<#+ &*&"!%'!8/#%'".##7#& /!9:

.!<#.#!+2/#!+'#2$*'&#/ +".#!,,#//!'"!'2 ,#+*&#2".#+#$+2 4#!+'#2  $*'&#/  +  ".#  !,,#//!'"  $'"#'2&  ".!"

8".  ".#  *+"&  8#/9  .!<#  '"  ,+,#+/7  !,,+#$%!"#2  ".# #<%2#'$#!'2".#+#%&6%&+#!2%'- 2$*6#'"!+7#<%2#'$#87 ".#  $*+"&  8#/9  .#  $*'&#/  .!&  &.9'  ".#  2$*6#'"!+7 #<%2#'$# %# H    !'2 H  ;  1!6!8!'2%#&  + ".#  7#!+  )FC ) ;H 1!6!8!'2% +".#7#!+

EC

F;H?

!'2  H   ;  1!6!8!'2%#&  +  ".#  7#!+  

C

;  H  );

1!6!8!'2%  +  ".#  7#!+  

EC

F;  A.!&+!  %+2!9!+%  +6  EFC !'21*2-6#'"!'22#$+##2!"#2E F

E;H

 .!<#$'&%2#+#2".#$'"#'"%'& /#!+'#2$*'&#/

+".#!,,#//!'" +6".#,#+*&!/ ".#&#2$*6#'"&;%"+#<#!/&".!"

".#'!6# *+,!+"!,&' 
%$.,!/%'-.%&6#'"%'#2;'"

 &'   ##"  %'-.   .#+#  %&  $!"#-+%$!/  %'2%'-  ".!"  ".# !,,#//!'"B,/!%'"%

 %&  '"  ".#  &'   
%$.,!/  %'-.  !&  ' #<%2#'$#.!&8##'8+*-."87".#*+"&8#/9 .#*+"& 8#/9.!<#+#$+2#2".# %'2%'-&".!"!*1!%'-. !".#+ ".# 2# #'2!'"&9!&%'#H$/*&%<#,&&#&&%' ".#2%&,*"#2A.!&+!

'*68#+  .#+#!

"#+  2# #'2!'"&  !+#  %'  ,&&#&&%'  !&  ,#+ +#<#'*#+#$+2 .# %'2%'-9%".+#-!+2",&&#&&%'%&!

%'2%'- !$"  ".*+"&8#/9.!<#+#$+2#2$'$*++#'"

%'2%'-& !$" 4#!+'#2$*'&#/ +".#!,,#//!'".!& !%/#2"&.9 ".!" %'2%'-&+#$+2#28# +#".#$*+"&8#/9!+#,#+<#+&#+ %//#-!/+8!&#2'6%&+#!2%'-;''C+#!2%'-+6%&C!,,+#$%!"%'  ".#2$*6#'"!+7#<%2#'$#'+#$+2 '&#>*#'"/7;".# $'$*++#'"  %'2%'-&  +#$+2#2  87  ".#  $*+"&  8#/9  2  '" 9!++!'"%'"#+ #+#'$#%'+#-*/!+&#$'2!,,#!/>*#&"%'

/!9;6*$./#&&&*8&"!'"%!/>*#&"%' /!9;!&!//#-#2;!+%&#& + !21*2%$!"%'%'".%&&#$'2!,,#!/ ".#+,%'".!&8##'*+-#2 %&6%&&#2%'/%6%'# #8+*!+7 ; ) #8+*!+7 ; ) #8+*!+7 ; ) #8+*!+7 ; )  
 454  
 454  
 454  
 454 A!'$.!'