← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21302/2023allowed

Amit Kumari v. Election Tribunal Cum Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), Karnal And ANR.

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma18 pages

 

        

 

!"#$%&&'

 "#"(#) !"#$*&&'

  

     



 

!

  $  +, & --

- .

  +, -& --  -    #$ % &    

%

   

&( #

% ) * !+     %   *   

, -

....

-

- .

 /&   /

  0 "



" #  '0  '   '

1  "

 /2 -3-5 6 7/2 " #   

 

    0  

    

' #   #   '#  

" '''  ' ""   # 

'  #      "

 #      "         

"

"

 "  '   

 '  " # '

1 

 "  32 -3-5 6 7/- 0

"" '

   0  

 #

+  #   

0)1 "213 )0

-

  ''       '  "

 ( #  #!+/99:



'

;  '/99:<

    ( #   #  !+   /98577    



        

'

  " 0  0  /- // -3--    , -0   0 # /8=

  

  "



  $7 >

        !

   ?''   7"  // 

 '

 '  /34=8 0

   )  '0   43/3  

 0 

"

 /: @,?A

>>

      #      "

C  '#    '

 '

  "

 0  0      #

, - #"

  0 

0* '   > 

    "   '         -2 3= -3--   -/ -3--  #  6  7-

>>>

( ' *  # C'#   "

0 

 0 0

    0

  '

  ' &

>

      '        0

   "

   #

, -'   ''     -=  ' "

   

  "

   #    , -     0

'  

 " , 8 ""

*



>   , -   

 "  * 0    0 1

 "

' * 

   " "

 "

#     ' 

>

>  #  '         '     

   ""

  #'

 , -0 #""

   '   0 #    ' 

>>

,  "

0 '

-5 3- -3-5

    -5 // -3--   6

 (     

    !

 ?'' 0

 "

       "   & , -0

 

   ##  '/8= '         -=  

"

  "  < 6"  /:

0

    '"

 #0

  ''# %

9"

D 0

 '  #

  0+  '"

 4- #    '   , - >    

              "

   

  

 #

 0     

>>> ( 0 "

"

  

'      '

     

"

' "" 

    # '  , -    "    ''



  "

 (       ""     7 ''   0  "    "  '     ''  "

     #'!, -= '-3-5     "'

   

          32 3/ -3-5   6

            6"

 #"

  " #

      #  0        

'        " 0 #  , -  '



 "

>E

"   " #   

   6"

       

 '

' 0  

 "    

#    "

#   '#  ' "" '

 ""

  

   #0# '' ""

  , /-/: -3-50

  '  0   -2 3:

-3-5   6     

  ?'' '  

   0' 

'  "

  6  

   

E>

'       6"

   34 3= -3-5 , - ' 0   # "

 # +       # +   0

0"

" '#  '  0   0    

?'' 0  " # " '

       0   0  # , -  0    #  

 '   '

 0     # 6"

  , -    ""    

/82  /99:

:

 0

 # # '  0   

 1 #  

    34 3= -3-5   6 7//      #       

' 6   0

  F  /  "   &    0  # ""     G?

  F       

 /1' "

"

( #  # !+'

 ""  0 

          0    '

   "

 

 "  ' & G?

  F             

   '

  '

  "   &  F "

   '

G?

!

F   7  ' "

G?

!

 F   ""

#  0  '  "

G?

!

 F      0    ""

    ''

  G?

!

 !



=

                 

  *  ""    #               , :      

#   "

 #

 0 

 

  "

  0

   #     0 

  /2 -3-5 #   0

 ""   



''   " #   ""

 "" ' # , - 

*     '  '       '  #  #    "

 #    #      0

#   "

    ""

    "   0 #

   0   # 0   "

"  #

"

   0   "

    +      ?  E>! -  "

 0

'

6 

'

  

     

 

  

   



 

   



    

   !     

" # 

"

!$   %  



!& '

"  $  

 ( '

) 

 !        

" #             !   

   "   

   

    $    # "  !

!  

!    !

"     "  *  "   

   

    

 ! "  

 

    

(+



   6  "

  "

   "

 +  "" '    1    "

'    ' ""

  #

"

"

 0  '#'  >'

    1  #'

 0    *   "  "  /3

(

 

   77

"     "

+    D    "

 "

 #  

0     '       *         "    '! - '? 

E>     #   ''  #    

#' " 

#  +  #    #" "

""

 +   "

'   #  " * '

 #

 #     



#   #  '         0        '  #   + #+   "

      //

>       0

''  " "" ' # , -        '  #      "

 #         1   ''

  0

' '# 1  " 0  

  #   0  '  # >

      #

 

/-

  "

  0            '       0  0  "

   ' 

  /82  '    ( #

 #!+/99:

'

;  '/99:<

B 

0

      '    

"

 

/83  '/99:  +     + "

# 1   0 #"

                   '    !

#  

#     1  0  1  + "

 

  



0    '   "

  + #  +    #     

  

/5

> 1 0'

 0 +   #           #              

 ''  

  0  # ,  #

#  '0   '! - '?  E>  

   #       ""

    ' 

0    #   

" "

#  #''



"    '

   "        '  "  +   #    !

#   

 

  ' "  

 0 1     "

+ #+        '

  

' "    



"

 '

 

0   " # !

#0

" "

 '  '  - '! - '?  E>

   * '"

   "

 0    # #     ' + 0

#'     * "

* ' "

+ #+  

  0  *  + !

 # " "





0   ''

    * ' 0  "

     

 "

+ #+  '



/:

(   

'

"   '

          "   +     0    "  " /-/5  " #     '  +    

""

  #"

    7  - ! - '?  E>  

/=

(

   '

*  "           #   6   "

  

/83  

/82   '/99:



#%# 

 %$       $    ,              %     %  - 

 !

 ,        *    %  !                  .  # 

               "

 %    

 ( /(

  

%     !  01  "1   21

     0  1  "  #     3& # "1  3&1  1   21

 %  !  ,   !        !   ,   %     

,    "

         

  

  "      %  %  $         ! 

 % ! "    

,   ( '

 

 $              4          %           

            !  "              



       "        - !

               ( 5    % 

!&    %    !      %   ,   "

! !

 % ( 6  

   

,   %  

 "             

!&  7  



                      ,         

   ! ( 8 

  

,   #%#  

&           ,   !-      !  $-   

  "      " ! 

!

      !                           !           

  !    "

$   %      %   %  !     &     %         %        #     

  "       

 "  

 

!   

  ! (-9 !



"    '8

  

     " %      !    "  

 

      %    % 

 "   

  %   ! %%    % "  %!   4 1 %  

   "  ", 

%   

  !      %    ! "  % 

!     ! %%  

  %!%  %  

  "  

 !"!     $ 

   ( 7  

!  %    &    %  %  %   

 %%  %   "



%     % !   " 

      %  "  

   $     -  !

 " %                     ! "

  %     % !           %        

$     -                        " %  %

   % 

   %                  "    !               (+ /2

 # , :  0

'  

  , -         '  "   "

     

 #  

/83

/82  '/99:

  0  #H "



/82    '/99:0



    '+  #    +

"

#1   #0  0

'  #   #' #0  ""



# '# *   #   #

      0  "     '# 

 /8

(                  "

   "  7        7""   '  

   

/83  '/99:



   '+    " 

  #    (    #

''

 # #    #



   0  0 H 0       ""  

/4

'   '

    '

 '            "

      "  "     

    # , - 0    ""    "   '       '  # "       

 

" 0 1   

/83  '/99:#       #    ""  0

  0 *  # 1    

   

                "

         " '  #''

 

 0  '

%

   "     #  '     '  '  

     #'  "





#  "

  #    

' "      '+  #    +    

/83  '/99:

>"

 #

         '      

  '   "

+ #+  #   

 

 0



 " "

  ' " "   

 # , -

!

 #      +            #     "

     0  

   "           "

        + 

#       # 7

"



/9

I  # '     #              '   

  "

    *  "

    "

        

/82  '/99:

-3

, 0  #    0 "    "    77 "

>#     

      " 6"

  ""     "

  

, - !

#

  #1  #

' +  #"     #    "

( 0  +  #  "          "            1 #     *

"    0  

  "

              '         

    "

0  0  7 

 -/

    

"

'    '/99:  " 

 "

#'

' '""  ?  /!

/3  

#    '

* "   '+"

"   "

(    " #'#  '

  7"" '      

'  /99:

                  

       

"   "   '  '

 #"

    '

 1 " "

,    0  # #'0

#   "

 "  

  '           

    " # 6

--

 6"

  "       /99:

!

 #"

 #0 1 * '  '

"

  '/99:

   '

 #"

   

  '  

   * '  "



 '

      ' 



 '"

   "

 * '  '

"

 

      '/99:

> 1    ""

  "   '+  #"     0     "

  

# ' '""  ?  /! /3 

 -5

     '    "

  !"  # $ %& ' '( ) #  *

( < "

6  0

 

1   

     #"

   '

 # ' "

' 

43  '      '  /99:  0              

!



" 

"

  #  "      

  

0      '*    "

    0 *  "

0

#0   '7  -

'! - '?  E>   "

0    

-:

( +  ""

'  !



"  '

 # "  0         ' "

   '/99:

   #0 '

 "     '/99:  "      0        #     "

        ' "

  

 "

'# 6  '  

   "   " "

 !

#  

#  

 0      

0  ' ""

# 

*"   +"

"   "

    ""  ?  /! /3     " 

"

    7 

            "  '#  

4#05 !

"2134 "(1 -=  >'  

  0 "

0      

-2

>  1       







   "

'  # 0

0  1    ' 1  

   1 

    '

*'

      "

'



-8

  

  ""    '  #  D   "

    -

- .

    -  - 

  ) */'

 135

3  094#:;

"# !

$

;"

3  8"1075

$

;"