Ashok Kumar And Others v. Inder Dev And Others












 

 






 !

"#$

$%&'&()
*$+,$-
.
  '/0
12+"-

#/$-'

33$44"(#'

5$-'2'

(6$-
$*

#/$-'

 $'3(6$(#'

!
 "

#$%&'
() *+!' +*
,&

-$'$(#) -
"&
&(7/
/"2/"(.
6*%"#$.

-
#/$
"33$44"(#' 88888







































 +*
,&-(

33$44"(#934"&(#&'
'27/#
6$%4"-"#&(
*&'9"9*&'
#/$
$'#"#$
 2-&(6$-
"##
(
#/$
,"'&'

#/$
-$7&'#$-$6
:&44
6"#$6
  ;;<.
=/&%/ /"'
,$$(
6$%4&($6
,>
#/$
#-&"4
2-#
"(6
23/$46
,>
#/$
?=$-
33$44"#$ 2-#
#
="'
"44$7$6
#/"#
2-&(6$-
"##
="'
+"--&$6
"(6
/"6
#= 6"27/#$-'
"4-$"6>
+"--&$6
(
#/$
6$+&'$

/&'
=&$.
/$
'#"-#$6
4&*&(7
=&#/ #/$
34"&(#&'
'('

2-2
"##
"'
2-&(6$-
"##
"(6
2-2
"##
=$-$
-$"4 ,-#/$-'
#/
#/$
"##$'#&(7
=&#($''$'

#/$
:&44
/"6
6&$6
"(6
#/$&- %/&46-$(.
"'
3$-
#/$
3-*&'&('

$%#&(
;

#/$
(6&"(
*&6$(%$
%#
- '/-#.
#/$
%#!
=$-$
$@"+&($6
#
#/$
4$"'#.
$*$(
'/0
12+"-
%-&,$
 #/$
:&44.
=/
="'
$@"+&($6
"4'
,-27/#
(
-$%-6
#/$
-$7&'#$-
$'3&#$ #/"#.
#/$

%2-#'
,$4=
&7(-$6
#/$
:&44
"(6
23/$46
#/$
-6$-

#/$

&("(%&"4
++&''&($-
@A.
=/$-$,>
+2#"#&(
(
#/$
6$+&'$.
="' -6$-$6
"'
3$-
#/$
("#2-"4
'2%%$''&(
/$
6$$(6"(#'
/"6
#"0$(
#/$
34$"

((9+"&(#"&(",&4&#>

#/$

 '2&#
"'
#/$
3-$*&2'
'2&#
(
#/$
'"+$
7-2(6
="'
6&'+&''$6
&(
6$"24#
"(6 %/"44$(7$
#
#/$
+2#"#&(
3-%$$6&(7'
="'
23/$46
,>
#/$
&("(%&"4 ++&''&($-
/$-$
="'
(
6&'32#$
,$#=$$(
#/$
#$'#"#-
"(6
#/$
+"--&$6 6"27/#$-'
6&'&(/$-&#$6
-+
#/$
("#2-"4
4&($

'2%%$''&(
/$
#-&"4
2-# 6&'+&''$6
#/$
'2&#
"(6
#/$
"33$"4
4"&6
,$-$
#/$
?=$-
33$44"#$
2-#
"4' +$#
=&#/
#/$
'"+$
"#$ -
"&
&(7/
/"2/"(.

4$"-($6
%2('$4
-$3-$'$(#&(7
#/$ "33$44"(#934"&(#&'
'2,+&##$6
#/"#
#/$
-6$-

#/$
&("(%&"4
++&''&($- ="'
"''"&4$6
,$-$
#/$
#-&"4
2-#
-*&'&('

$%#&(
;

#/$
%#
/"*$ ,$$(
%+34&$6
=&#/
"'
($

#/$
'(

20/
"+
"''
"33$"-$6
"(6 &6$(#&&$6
#/$
'&7("#2-$'

/&'
"#/$-
*$(
#/$
3$-'(
-+
#/$
&%$
 2,
$7&'#-"-
=/$-$
#/$
:&44
="'
-$7&'#$-$6
/"6
,$$(
$@"+&($6
44
#/$ =&#($''$'
&(%426&(7
#/$
%-&,$
/"*$
,$$(
%('&'#$(#
@$%2#&(

#/$
:&44 &'
"
3&(#$-
#
6$*&"#$
-+
#/$
4&($

'2%%$''&(
"(6.
#/$-$-$.
%246
(# ,$
"
7-2(6
-
'2'3&%&2'
%&-%2+'#"(%$' 
/"*$
/$"-6
#/$
4$"-($6
%2('$4
-
#/$
"33$44"(#'.
"33-"&'$6 #/$
3"3$-
,0
"(6

#/$
*&$=
#/"#
#/$-$
&'
(
-%$
"(6
+$-&#
&(
#/$ '2,+&''&('

-
/"2/"(.
-.

"+
"''
"+,"-6"-.
/&'
"#/$-.
/"6
"33$(6$6
#/$
'&7("#2-$'
(
#/$
:&44
&(

-62.
=/$-$"'
/$
6&6
(#
0(=
-62
(
'2%/
%&-%2+'#"(%$'.
3-*&'&('
 $%#&(
;

#/$
%#
-$+"&($6
2(%+34&$6

&("(%&"4
++&''&($-
-$B$%#$6
#/$
34$"

#/$
34"&(#&'
,> -$4>&(7
(
#/$
'#"#$+$(#

'/0
12+"-
34"&(#&
 !.
=/
%"(6&64> "6+&##$6
#/$
-$4"#&('/&3
,$#=$$(
#$'#"#-
"(6
#/$
+"--&$6
6"27/#$-'
#
,$ %-6&"4


-$"'('
/"*$
,$$(
+$(#&($6
&(
#/$
:&44
-
6&'&(/$-&#&(7
#/$ ("#2-"4
4$7"4
/$&-'
/$
34$"
#/"#
2-&(6$-
"##

6&$6
&(
;;A.

=/$-$"'
#/$

 :&44


;;<
%246
/"*$
,$$(
-$*0$6
/"6
#/$-$
,$$(
#/$
$4$+$(#
 '2'3&%&2'.
=246
"4'
(#
'2'#"&(
/$
34"&(#&'
"##$+3#$6
#
#"-7$#
#/$ ("#2-"4
/$&-'
&-'#

,$-$
#/$
-$*$(2$
%2-#
"(6
#/$(
#/$
%&*&4
%2-#
#
&'
(# &(%2+,$(#
"(6
,4&7"#->
23(
#/$
-$*$(2$
"2#/-&#&$'
#
$$%#
#/$ +2#"#&(
(
#/$

,"'&'

#/$
:&44
(
#/$-
=-6'.
#/$>
/"6
"
-&7/#
#
6&'%"-6 #/$
'"+$
'
"(
23'/#

#/$
"-$+$(#&($6
,'$-*"#&('.
#/$
"-72+$(# 
-
/"2/"(
&'
(#
",4$
#
,-&(7
#/$
%"'$
=&#/&(
#/$
-$"4+

3$-*$-'&#> 
7-2(6
-
&(#$-$-$(%$
&'
+"6$
2#.
+2%/
4$''
&(*4*$+$(#
 '2,'#"(#&"4
C2$'#&(

4"=
$'24#"(#4>.
#/$
"33$"4
&'
6&'+&''$6
 ./0-    +*
,&

/12 ()34'

,252167 81

 918

,252
 50"

918