← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/421/2023allowed

Ram Avtar Gupta v. Haryana State Warehousing Corporation And Another

2025-07-07Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal7 pages

        

!"#$#

"%$&' $!(#(&)* +, +, "-.%"/01%" 2113(!")% 4$/#0# "/5")"6%"%$7"/$8&0#()9&/1&/"%(&)"):")&%8$/2$#1&):$)%# ): 

"-.%"/01%" 2113(!")% 4$/#0# "/5")"6%"%$7"/$8&0#()9&/1&/"%(&)"):")&%8$/2$#1&):$)%#  *  ;<,6 6<  

 

    



 ! !" # 

$  %

 

    &&&  6<= '() *

      #   + +,  +,    -     + ,      +#   

/%  

  "  **'0)    +  1  *220'

3 >> !%4)



 %

 + 



    

 #  # +,     /   % # 6       +#   

  ! ! "   +  

 

 %

 + #!  ..

*8 .8*0+,96 9%  



++,    :     #, , %

  +   

 1 " **  *220 #  ,   % " .* *220 /  

#! (+4.8*0# 





 .8.*# ## ##  +,

 # +   .8.5 / 

  , ++,     1.;') +  % + +

+, % %<   # +

1  1+ +

  ;

:    %     +    #  + 

:           % #  +   1.;')# +     #  +#  

      ! "

#  



  " $  % 

%

  '()*

 +

#

 '() 



 

    

,  

-

     %$ 

   % 

 &  ..

     #

 %$  .#

,

  %   &       .

, & .

&





,

,    

, &  

 ,  &





 &"  /-



 /

!      %$

     /-



 /

!  

%  #  

-"

"

  &

  0

,  % , .

 &"  

 ,  "

 

, &1

 & 

 

  #

, 

#



".

   

,

& 

 #  

2 !

 %$

"  #

, 



%

#

%  -

    %$  

#  

 &"  /-



 /

! 



, 



 %   '()*

 +

  #

  '() 



0

& 

  #

 ,  2 !  /-



/

  %$

 "



 



.  &   

 

 %  . &"  

 %   #   

-"

"

 .   

# 



..

 

, 

& 

&

#



%

& &1

.

  & 

2 !   /-



/

, !      %$ 

 

 "

%  #  

-"



"

,  &

 0

,



,



.

",%  

-"

"

  -# "  

-"

"3 ,   &

 0

, . 

  %

  0

&

.

 /-



/

!     0

   4   5

, '()     .



#

  &  ,

 

 #

2

 

# 





#

%

 





    0

,  % , 

  # ",

..

  

 252 6 , &    

 

&  ,& .

&"

 &"   4   5

, '()  

 27 %

& &1



"  ## .

  & 

##

 8 2

*

  '()      

 

 %    %

 







  



 8 2



'() 

-#



  "  .



# 27 &  %. .



 

"  

   

 

 



,

 

,



&

  #

 %     

.    %

  %

 &" 

#

2 9 !

&   .

 &"    5

, '()

  &

  %

 

&    "



,% 

 4  5

, '()

.#   ##  .

" # ,

& 

 #

&  ##

  #

 %   

2

 !

  .  

& 



    #     # ##

&" 4  5

, '()

&   "



#

&

 .



 &    

  & 

2 !

%    .

-

  2 *  &   .

&

 

 

   

#

 



.  *

#

"2: =

/ #  >  #    *;

*8 .8*;

 /

       

 96  9%   .8*; #! 

..

*8 .8*0  



 96 9% #  % #     /

+ >  #+ 

% % <  96  9%       8;

.8*?

,!> 

 

;2 +  1#  *0 8;

.8.5#   # ##  +,

 # +   /   %  ,      +   

          

  /             #,       :  

%  /

# ,  % :+ #,  :,>  +! +,+  @     1"  ** *220 ,   ?

 1   # +," **'0) *220 

:+,

+ !   +#  

@ A

-@%  1  %  25"7 <1 *57**7 +  2=?888?*.=

+,

"+ !  +#    +!      , >   /  +  > ,#  " *. *220 +   %  *8

/  

 # 

+ +  ..

8= .8.;*888   +,+  **

/+ +   # - " *220  *.

/+  >   %     

" .2  *220 *5

   #+ +,   B B B + +  ,+   +# ++  %+ 

+ *7

 >  % #   ,      +  

@ A

   *;

 %

')

, 

 6<   

+, +, 4 <.

C  %B DB C + DB