High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4070/2016dismissed

Chamkaur Singh & ANR v. Raghbir Singh & ANR

2017-01-13Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi12 pages

! "#$#%& '

()*+ , -.

/0#%1, %! %, 0 22 33 %$ 4$ 1,5#0#%1, %! %, 0 $2%! %$

66

()*+ - %! 27 /0 22 33 % 4$ 1,5#0#%1, %!, 0$ $2%! %$ *& 89**:*97

*:*97;(9+ " ## $

# $

&'('

)'* +

,-

#

. $ %#

#

$

/&/& )'* , . $ %#

#

"

#

# , #, 1,

%2 # # ## , #

## " % + %" # # ##

# #

) # #, 1,

& ) )''*

# #

, # 2

2 #

# $ 5''''67 %#

"# ##

2 # $ /''''67 "#

#

8

# ## % / '/ )''( 9 / '/ )''(

# "

%##2 8 ##

: ## 8 , / '/ )''( / '* )''( 8# :

#

"## # 8#

8

# ## 9 / '* )''( ## 2

"## ,

, %

# #

##

# # / '* )''( ,

2 %#

%

#

8# ; ') )''

# #

2

#

" # % 8

# ##

,

##

,

"## ##

"

2 2

"##

# 2

"## ,

, ## # # # 2 ## ,

, :# <

, #

## , #% ## #

##

# # # , # <

# ,

##

, :# " #

'

# ,

# # 2 , -" 8 ## #

# ## :

,#

#,

# ,

% # #

### %

#

# # # ##

# # "# , ## ,

#,# 2 %1# ## #

# # 2#

, - # "# , 9 ,# # # # , "# # = 8

, & ) )'* ##

# # ## , > 9 ) = ## , # 2

"##

# 2

"## ,

>9 ?

= ## # #1#

2 > 9 & = # #

8 #

# # >9@ /

= ##

, # ,

, "#

# # >9@ *

= ## , ## #

"

> 9@ (

= # 2

1###>9@ ;

$#

<

## %

, 2

"

#

" #

#

## , ##

# 2 # #

# #

# # % # , #

##

2

#2 # # ## ,

, & ) )''* "#

# + ## 8

# ## # #, 1,

) '& )'&

3#

# # "

9

# +

,-

#

# ,

, #,# 3# + # # ,, #, 1,

'( )'*

" ##

# # 1,

A%

, 74#!< % -4$4 #0 = %; >> ('+ ;* %7 /0(!

!+5<9$ 4$ 0#%1, %1, ;

( +6

- %#7 %!

% 4$ ?

.$,-# %!, 0$;

(

+ @;

%,#

##7

#

2

"## ,

!#,

# + %"

,## ,

#

# #

#

# % # #, 1,

,# # 1#

2 #

# #, 1,

6

"# %

, #, #

, 8 %" # & ) )''* #8

/ '/ )''( # 8 / '* )''(

# #

% #

, "# ## $ %#

# # ; ') )''

= 8 ## "# # 8 # # # ## , )( '& )''

9 % #

% # ## 2

##

, B8 8#

B8 ) 2, ,2 $ /''''67

#

"## ,

2 # #, ##

=

8 ,# ,#-

# , # "#

=) - 0, "#

=? %#

# "#

=&

#

, # "#

=/

# 0,

2 %#

=*

#

, % # 2 )''/7'*

B8 (

, % # 2 )''7

B8 ; "#

#"

9

#

#

#

# , ## <

#

/ #, 1,

)/ %- $

# " % -" C #, # " "# # 1### # ##

#, 1,

1, #

#

% # " #

" # 1, ,

%# ###

% < ##

#

#,

8 ,# #

# # %

2#

## 1,

,#, #

## #, , - " #

A%

, !- /$/%!0 %! %, 04$ -#3 !/ %!

, 0$;

('+6'';%#% %!# 4$-0#9 3* %", %!

%!

, 0$; ('+ 6; 0#$$ 4$*!33#< $; ( +

?

$, %4 % $,#9 3; @( +6''

=#

#"

# ##

- %#2 % # ,

D%

,

) # 1, % $,#9 3D # # # # #"

- -0#9 3* %", %!

D

*,!33#< $D # #2 "

7

!

" #

!$

% &

'( )

&

!

&

' (

)

'

(

)"

*

" #

+ ,

(-.- / -

- 0

/( 123-,245)

6

/ 7

7

/(112(2)-,,44)

8

#!

"

9

:

; (1<)

,41=(>;)&

> ;, "

&

8

8

+

8

,

&

9

;

&

&

# 9

;

@

"

9

;

"

-- / ? 0 &(<<2)-,,5= 3&

=,

/ ,

$

8 #

8

! ,

#

&

& "

8

!

&

" #

'

; @

7 ,;? > (1= ,5A5 52)&;0

7 .(

4,%7) B#

& &

* &!

9

#

"B 2 >/

7C

,(15<() 14);

>

( 15%)&B;

$

+ +

B0 &!

- >;? -

(D)(15)*;<2 .( 54% )B/ & & " ;!

9

B

&

>

E

E (15()*;=A5);0

.

( 52 ) B#

"

&

"

B 5,

8

&

=#

;7

.( F ,#&

12-,23<

&

&

(

,G)

# &

&

B B9

"

&

0

"

-6

?

;

0

&(<<4)A-,,5=&

3A%34&

=%3B

"

#

# % " # 3# # %

# % #

7 "#

,# , " #,# <

7 #

#

## # )( '& )''

# 2 # # # ##

#

, # ##

# )' ' )'' # 2 # <

#

# "

# ## # #

# 8 # 2 ## # # %, 2

7

"# %8 2 "

8 # 78 ,# #

#

"# %8

#

2

% # , # )' ' )'' 8 , :

# 2 # 2 # , # - ,

% 7 # , % # % # ## , # # ##

+ %"

# ,

# #2 ,

% # #"

-

# , "# 1,

A%

,

"

+

!"# ! $ !

%&' !

((

)** ) +&, !

+&!

) " ((

) " !'! !'%&

" ((

-!

(

%&

* ) .." # ! $/%&

) (( ."

@#

#

# #

# #2 #2 # #, 1,

+ %" # , #

+ # 8## #

1###

# ''

+ +## 3 :# " , % # :# "

#

%# " ##

< # % #, % # :# # :

##

A%

, < % % ? %!0 % %! %, 04$9 .$,-< 0?#%#

%!, 0$; >(6+

, # +## #

#,

% "#

,# # #"

%

# 2 ,## % ,#

"#

% , #

#

, $ 2 "#

% # % # , %

$

#,#

" "#

A*:*97B ? ' )'(

= -#6 E6 = % E6