Union Of India And Others v. No 291193 Ex Mwo Joginder Singh And Another
!"#$%$$%
!"!&"'
!"#%$$%
!
"# (# )*( % ++
+ ,
)*( +% ++ + ( $ #%&'
() *+*(# *()(,#-.( , /* "
0
()( *1*(,#-.( , / "# +
+ ,
-%
!*$** (3"
,* "
* 0 /#(,"(&/* $(# /* # #( # 4 4 5 6 07, ( "( # %& * 8 ( # ) # .
!%(8 ..
#,3* %&* .8()/ "# /* $(/ #(%8&"
3((883
.'/&.0.'12 !&"
"# 1 #.
4 4 9:(/ ( /* (8* $. /* ,* . ##(%8&/ ;.*( ). ( 5 &.(#(8/(.7<(#3(#.*($
/) 4 9 * ) /#.*($ ,*#(%8&3( ( #=4>/3& (%&* -(8#$
#.(8?(#
!* #(%8& ) .8() / * "# 3( . +)"
*&,** $#*(* "( #(%8&3( * (%(%8 % $($$(-( #%& # /)8(&
@
/ (8(" /& (,.
#( /#.*($ /) , "# /8 # ,% / 8 ( #) #.
!%(8..
#,3* %&* .((.*(88 $ * (/ (# . # !* (# , % .() (883 # -# # #( 4 4 !* "
(- "( / * (# # 6(. * (/
! "
$ %
&' ($ )$ ) * +, -.!
!/01 2* !!
,3
.40)5 )
-
6
8$($$ - #/)* (/ (## ("( #" 5"(7,%&* 8 ( #) #.
!%(8..
#,* "
0/#(*(/8 #* ($(* (3"
/ *+
"3
"'
!3/45 !& /%
?
/ ".
#$)(B ( // .- (#1#.(" " 3"
, ( /8((.
/# )$3* /(88) /(&# -0C0-(&) )% /* # / "
8,%"*% $ 88 #* ()&,# " (* (8 ($ ,"*% .)$ 8 #,(() )% /* .)%(( / (%8*) ,(* * () )($# . #,& * ("" ",*" 8) * $.(%8 %
* .$ (8% $.(%8 % ($$(-( #% $ (%(%8 )8(& ,*(.D #,/),* "."8 /** 1#$) E%8 "
6+,.( 8 (
, " # ! "
!* -( "(($("* / * (# - #. ( 6(. * (/
!* $ $ 7
8 9:;
$
$
$
<
$
!
3
=$
$
$ >
2$
) $ ?
* -!@ * #<0092 $ A : 9:*
$ $ $
0
$
=$
$
$ $
B2$ %. 2$ ,9:C
9:4$
9
:
$
<
*
$
92$ : 9:0
$
$
$
$
$
B2$ ,9:C 9:0
$ D
$ D
B ,9:C 9:0
$
#
$
E F =$
B ,9:CG 9:0
E F
$
)
<00
@H$ E 9E ?
: !
! I @>
8 H ?
@ $ A-
J
=$
$
:
.- (#$57/* (%- 6(. #"."8 , *$*" #8&# .8( ,*(3* (#(%8&% (8 #" (&) )% /* .)%((# / (%8*) ,(#3*.* 6 /4>- ,* ",*$*(&.*#(%8 #) )% -(8# #/)* )&,%& * ($ #* //#(%8&"
,* ($) /#(%8&"
(& ) )% /* .)%((# / (%8*) ,3*% (8 3* ( #(%8& (D() / 4> ) , % )"
(- 8& ( # .8(( /) *
#.(8 ?(#, (* .(##8& ".$*(* (#(( ##(%8&% $(%(%8 .)$($$(-( #%&)8(&
!* (## .8((%
1 >
2$
) $ ?
* -!@* #<0092 $ A : * ) ,*$** (" )"($ -0C0-* #"*&.(8(#) (8* (8*/(&) )% /* / (%8*) ..
#, "
.(88&3* (* ($ /* .)$ 88 #,* .#(%*% .)$% 3*(&#
- ,*$** * (8(/* " )", *( 3* (& # ( * , * .. % 8&, * %& * (# *(""
$ / # (57 $/(&# ,(* % " ) ( 8/* $ ( ( ) )% / * # / (%8*)
)"
(- 8&,* /"-$* #3) D(% / 5"(7-0C0-* ..
#,% #* )"8& ,(# .( ,* (# )(0#.*($ #,* ",* .8()( 8 # .
- #(%8&"
- ,(88* /(. (# ..)(.
( #( * # / %& * ..
#,( % .8 8&.G #,*/# .8($3* * /(&# -0C0-* ..
#,( 8D( #
"
/ )8(& (#H * () % $ ($$(-( # %& % $ (%(%8 )8(&
4 ?
*(()(&,* % (8 /*(/* "."8 57*(& * .(% # (8/#(%8&"
* ..
#,%8&"'
(7* ) /(..
"(.
/* ..
#)8(& ,) $% .)$ .#
#.(8 ?(# -0(0- * % $ % 3* ( # 3*.* *3 - ,% ..8# & $*) /% 8
%7 & /* # ( * /, )(& (8 % 8&% ..8#
#.(8?(#, ( /) # / )8(& % $ (%(%8 )8(& ,(* * () $( .$ (8#
* ,/* ) #.(8"*8#*(* # .8# *(-
# . #) #.(8 6()(/* ..
#% $ )(# ,*"*% .)$ 8 # ,* ",* () 388% #
) #*(- ( #$ ,& * (5"(7,*
#.(8?(# #( (/ ..8#$
- ,(8# .8( #"(,*()(#(& /*
#.(8?(#/883* $# 8 8(##3+*(" 0 /* I #
#.(85 8(&
7,44JI8 ) '
(8 ."8 I
!
!* / ,*(% 3# ) #3* )/ (%- "."8 ,3* (* ) / 8) /* " "# * )&,*(/ (" 8)(&) #.(8 6()( $)(# -0(0-** (8*,*( .() .# #(% ) # % $ *) (#H 3* ) % .() (""
#*(* (## 3((#)(($
- , (8 # ) #,/)* /(.(*(#,3* * (.((8 6 0 "/* # ,(#H* $ /,*"
,*"* 88) /* " "# (B$ "8(.
, -0(0- * (.- # %& *) / )8(& ,3* %&,*+)(&..8# *(* / # %(* 3(( 8/* $ * )& (#(.*3((%(%8 % .() ($$(-( #%&* $ )8(&
@ (##,(8 $(* #/)* .#,3* *
#.(8?(#,##(88&".
#)(B ( (8 #.- ( .
(8.* .B,"(.8(8&(""
($* (#- /* # ,*$* )"8&) / ( /) #.(8 .*D , * - 8$ * %8.B .*( $ . . ., 3* /),(* * # .() .
- ,/* (#
)"8&) /(8 8(8&,* %&)(&% ..8# #D(
"* /,*% * ("" 8) (B$ "8(.
,(* 3(.$ (8%3 #$ #/ )8(& # % $(%(%8 % .)$($$(-( %&"
/)(.
/)8(&
+(8&,/* "( )"8&
.*D (* ($ /("" 8) (B$"8(.
,*%&*
#.(8?(#..
#,8 (#(..8,*(* ( (* #)(.# /(&# ,%& * (##)(# "*%$* 8) /(&"
8* ()&,(-&( /.
8(8&* % (.- # .H "* /, #$* . / #/)8(& ,%38#((88& (#(3 88..8%&*
#.(8?(#,*((.- " % % .() .
# /) ( // .- .((8 $ . . . 3* %&* 38#% # (8/#(%8&"
A
3 - ,3* (# (-,*+ % 6(.$* . /* ",(% .() .# ) #.(8%(#
"/*
#.(8?(# #* #(%8 6% / $ K
5(7 "
./ (.*#(%8&*
#.(8?(#* -# / 388 6" - 3(3* 57(%(%8 #$"
(.
# / 8# .#' 57*(%
($$(-( #* %&(# )(' 57. . #3*
(%8& ?
+ 5 L + M +!@4 09:
5%7 "
./ (.*#(%8&*3((%(%8 # ,* ?(#*8#( /88&,* "
./..#(#"
# 3*.*.( #* #(%8& H 5.757 "
./ (.*#(%8&*3(($$(-( ## ?,* ?(#*8#( /88&'* "
./..#(#"
# 3*.*($$(-( #* #(%8& H 57 * * // ./.*($$(-(88"
H 57/* (3 57* (//)(- ,3* // ./($$(-( 388"
/()( (8"
# H 5#7* .( /(#(%8&# +,* ?(#*8#( 3*(
6(.8&* "* .( /
!* #(%8&.(8( ,* . . #3*
9
(#$/* .# - (8*((* ) /* ("" 8) (B$"8(.
(* .() )(# ) /* "."8 5"(7# .8( E%8 "
6+.( 8 #(
$% %&*
#.(8 ?(#,*() # 3*.**3 - ,##/%#* " "# ,% 8 #* )&,##)(B " 8)(& $ / , * # .8(( / 8(3 1#$) 5"(7 *( %&* (" )"*(* .$/* (## 3(( 8/ #/ , /(-(%8&
#3 #-0(0-* "# !*$** (#" )" %(%8 %* 8 (# -# %* (#" )" .() .( " * "
3 - , * (# .( -# (##.$#.*($$-0(0-* "# ,(* /.$ 8& %$* (#" )",%((88&(8##.(( #&(8"*
#.(8?(#, $($ 8/* (-/ (*$, *$* )"8&) / * ( / %8.B .*( $ . .((8 . . .*D 57, 3* %& )(& % .() (- #*(* $/* # * ()&"
8, .() .
#/)( .
(8$ ./()8&*& - , %&3((8 ( #* ) #.(8",*( # %/(3 88/) # ((* 3((.$ (8# (#% .() * ($$(-( #%&% .() (%(%8 )8(&
:
3 - ,( (#$/"5"(7,#.8 *(*(
.# # ( &"
# /) (# ( *(- %
.# #* 6 5"(7 ( #8&,.
-# % " )"5"(7*(%
8 "
,* %&,* +.( #$- 3 $*($ * "/* ) #.(8 %(#,( 6(. #5"(7 +".8&,* %&. .(% ($ #* "(88/) # (,% # * %&* $ /* # .(% (#% ( 8/( .
(8$ .
/()8&*& +(8&, # .8( #( /) #/)8(&
(##, # .8( # (%(%8 % .)$($$(-( #%& #/)8(& %&* " "# F * ,.
)/* 1#$) "
6+,.( 8 #(&
' ()D
*+, !"- 3* ,(# .8(()(# *
6 ,*(* //#$//,(* *(% #3 * ..
8(8&(8* # (# / (%8 $* .() - # * " "# / *
B$ D( * ("" #$//% $)(# */(- - * 3 .
* # .8(( / 8(3 )(# - #.5"(7)(B * (## .8((% ( 6"8(/8(3 ),* %&,* 6"8(/8(3 ),()(# - #. 5"(7(8)(B * # ./ #% /-0(0-* / "
8 ..
#, , , (8 8 * ..
#,*((&)
B* $($/* #3) (
)(# # ,(#*(,* /88 .)"8 ) ,("
8 # ,% # "
.- /* %(,/(&,/# 8(&(#8(.* !* / , * $($ / * % / / * ("" #$//, )/* - #.5"(7 !%(8 ..
#,(8# // /)(&88 $(8&(# "* 8#
5".0
!3/45 !& /%
(/ )(*,*+/#) * 3"
(#3*% -((%- ,* () #)
!* )"$ ## ,("( 8 ( #!%(8 ..
#,)(( #(#(//) @
" #/(8$3*(88"
#$(""8.(57,/(&
6+
+ ,
6+ + (7 %$$% # * 4 /4
.15"29
.
!"
9!
4 /4
8!
/.:0
9!