← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2263/2017dismissed

Sadhu Ram And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2025-04-25Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal10 pages

  



!

"

#"

$% &

'

!

& 

( ) *+,+- & .

//) -+,+- 0& "

 &

0 ++1122 34

' & + ++1 !

)

5%6 + $"0 !

6

#6  

  

  

 

     

  

 

  !""#$  ""%& ""%'

""%% ""%(

"#('

")&% 

*  *   

 

  !$"&+ ",,'

",$#

")&% 

* -   

  !"%,'!")&%   * 

  .  

 

  !&("'!")&%  / 

  0- 2

 

3

  

  4 "

6

#68 $+ + %/.

. .

 ) & & 5



  3



/ 

&+  3





  

3



*3

   

  & "

 2

   

7

!

 

     

      

            

 

 ! 

     

       "  #  $     ""%  & '     % (''  )  % "!"& ' )('' #  * #  %   +''      )& ' ! ,$    -      # .

/&0 ''1 + '  2     

 

    " /&  *'   

  #  $  45        6''   

 

6

 $$   #   7

1    '

1#5  )  

 

89)

(

1 (, '   1

1    3

' 1  #   ''

5  4 

'

 %:

' (   '

( ; :$

( (   

                  ''    # <%'    45    $  (     (  89)  ' #   ''  5 4  

'

%:

 ' (   '  ( ; :$

( (      



                   ''    # <% '  +  < 

  6  

 <6

 ( ''  

$   ) "

+ (/ 4) " &

3

 2  



 !

   

  



  ,=9<(6  ,=9 4

1 % ,=9%>'#

  ,=9?4  ! ,=9!> 4'

" ,=9" *@( ) ,=9)<7  ,=9>'#  ,=9<( 5  ,=9

'@(  ,=977 

1   ,=9 <(4  % ,=9%/

  ,=9,'@( ! ,=9!>'( " ,=9"@( ) ,=9)@  @(

   

  

    ! 

 "

  ,9 3(4      5 9 ,9 (   % "  % ,9% #     ($1  #

 ,9 (  6 ! ,9) (  6 " ,9 3(4      5 9 ) "  ,9 #      * ''1 @&  + '  # 

  ;  <     , 

   !

,9% 45.*,= $(   #

 % ' #$$* 4        ,= $(     <

   !

,9   45    .* 1

1    *'$(   #  .

 /&  

, " "

8  

 5!&

3

3 

 2  . 9

/ :

   + 94: ) $ & ;

   3



3





/

 



/.

$ "

<   3 / .3

3

 /

 

/ 



!

=<7 *.   

16''1  8'0 & - ''

1      <'

  ,'  ,($  #  & 4,  @4& 4/ $@ 4& ,'5-(> - 5*'

.#   #       89)  & #    3

9

# <4

1#

' 

    A   ' 

  $ ' #   ,=$( #

% ' #  ,=$( ;<  BC=8D<DC>CBDE,%FDE, %$ ,' DE,% $9 

  ' DE,%"DE,%"FDE,%" #   F%

  6    '      0 ''1  2    @' $   45$$'' 

#

DE,%" '

$

  ($   

  G   4 (#'4($$$ 



 (

   (&*'+'       ' 

     #''      '  DE,%"DE,%"FDE,%"  '( ( '

 ( 4 ' ' ' 1   3

9 # <G3

9, '<> '     #'' '



      4  $ '       5  

($4'  +&

1  *1    DE,%"  DE,%"  F DE,%"    $$'5

1    4'      

   (''

 '



 4   H   ' (&*'   '

4(

$$E ('5 ( '  #

' #       ,=$(  <6$ >

- $ $ 8  

 

 9  3  2

?: !$



 



2 

/   





.  

 @<9A 

  /

   ,+ 2;/ &/4/) , & 8   2

2

@?: !$A

   / 

 / 3  3  .

7

 

 

/!6  B



 4 &+"+   ), )+ ")&"



3





9  B



 

/!

6 



!

3 6      C 3 B

 

0 1 7  

/!0 D 2

 3  

/!6 

  

 3    41!%& /     2 

 3  .

B

/3         33    



 3  . 8

   

/3

   

   41!%& 

    

 3  .  41!%&     3  .

   /  

 



 .

  3  . 



  

 3  . , "

3   

 

/

 * -  43 93

1 C.

3

      4

.

/ 

  

7 



 

   .  

7

 , $   3   /

    .

/    





 E !

06 && # &"!& %'

6 & < 0 0+

+ =/>/ 02 

4:> 02 //

/ +  1 

/ + #

! 

060 & $# &&%, !!!!!!!!!!!!

"$ )% ")), & &'#)))E!

&,'"))))E!

"

$# $#0 $""'

!!!!!!!!!!!!

)( )$ ")&& $)))))E!

"(),%())E!

$ $# ,( !!!!!!!!!!!!

"& ), ")&& ()))))E!

&+$#))))E!

#

! 

060 , $' $#;

$#?

&((

!!!!!!!!!!!!!

&) )' ")&& ()))))E!

+#())))E!

'

$#9 "#$ !!!!!!!!!!!!!

&% )' ")&& $)#)))E!

+#())))E!

# $) ,"

"%#'

!!!!!!!!!!!!!

") &" ")&& ',,)))E!

+#())))E!

"(""

!!!!!!!!!!!!!

"" &" ")&& % % $, ,& ,())))E!

+#())))E!

( # "+ $((, !!!!!!!!!!!!!

$& )& ")&"

('")))E!

&+$#))))E!

&,& !!!!!!!!!!!!!

", ), ")&"

+ , $"

,) &"$")))E!

&+$#))))E!

&) ' $$ $( &,'

!!!!!!!!!!!!!

", ), ")&"

,"#)))E!

&+$#))))E!

&& ( $& $+ &+"+ !!!!!!!!!!!!!

), )+ ")&"

$$))))E!

&,'"))))E!

&"

+ "%'$ !!!!!!!!!!!!!

") &" ")&"

((+)))E!

&+$#))))E!

, ,  

    4 ,( $((, &,&

&,' 



        33   3  .   



  



 

  /  $)'( 7 

  

 4 &,& 

 /   G

3

 !!  

7 /3 

3

7    

 

 ",

 3

?



5



 "")

    4 

 



 &+(

 

7   4 ,( $((, &,& &,'

 

 2 &#))  

  & ,#$ .

   

 

/ , '

 2  4 "(""

"%#'



    



   41!%&





 4 &(( 

  



  

 6 

  

 

&%





7 7   &$$  



  

 



 .



7

 4 &+"+ 

  



      

 

$$





7 7   ""))    /

7



  4 &+"+ 

 .

3 .  

7 

7 

 

 





/   8 2



,(,) 7  D 







    



, #  /

 



     



7  50 0



 & () 9  ?: !,$

?: !,,   

/   2 ")&'

C



 ",

@&(+, A 2 



*    

   





7

7  / 3 , % /  

 ",

@&(+, A : 

!

#$%  &       '

        '

  9  >    6  ''    & 



   9

    1    1

5  #

    '       I   '5 5

'

   $ 

 $# '   I  '5 5(1

45 (#

  45 $ *$ #'   $ '

4'  I '5 5(1#

 '

&'54  '     $4'

     '     "45

  

  #

 # ''4$I

'5 5

*' '    '

&'5

 (#

 # ''4$#  I E'5 5

*' '   $ 

'

&'5

 (#

 '   # ''4$I * '5 5'5 ($*(   $' '    ((

(  #    

      6''             $4'

       J 

           49    IJK 1'5 5

*' '  

   4

1$ 5#

  4  45'# $$$4'

$'

5L -+ &//) ' &  3  

   9  



2 3  

 .  

 <9 

 9 ' "

972







? ' $ 

3  

  

2

  

- 1/28 -

6

#6 54

$"& =$&

1G  M ?G  =$4' M ?G   !

+ 1122  1  

0& "

 &

0+

' &

+  !""#,!")&%

4-?

 40

8

66?

1H4 61

98<<?968 D40

 !""#'!")&%

;D;< 861?

66?

1H4

618B-1 98<<?968

D40

 !""##!")&%

14D 861?

66?

1H4

618B-1 98<<?968

D40

 !""#%!")&%

1DC B

66?

1H4 4

 !""#(!")&%

;<54 40 8

66?

1H4 61

98<<?968 D40   !""#+!")&%

40?? 4

66?

1H4

618B-1 98<<?968

D40   !""%)!")&%

;<54 40 8

66?

1H4 61

98<<?968D40   !""%&!")&%

1B< B

861?

66?

1H4

618B-1 98<<?968

D40   !""%,!")&%

 014 40 8

66?

1H4 61

98<<?968D40 40

4   !""%'!")&%

146D 40 8

66?

1H4 61

98<<?968 D40 8

   !""%%!")&%

6 8

66?

1H4 4   !""%(!")&%

4D< B 40

8

66?

1H4 40

4   !",$#!")&%

1?84 0?CD 8

66?

1H4 8

  !",,'!")&%

1?84 0?CD 8

66?

1H4 8

  !"#%$!")&%

 ;< 40 4

66?

1H4 40

4   !"#('!")&%

 014 40 8

66?

1H4 61

98<<?968 D40 40

  4   !$"&+!")&%

1?84 0?CD 8

66?

1H4 8

  !&("'!")&%

B;?

D4-1

66?

1H4 - 1/28 -

6

#6 54   $"&