High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/421/2016allowed

Praveen Kumar And ORS v. Sarjit And ORS

2018-01-30Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal7 pages

!"#"$%&%'()*

""##!

%& !

!" !

( +,

, !'

&( )* +)& ,-)& &* +

""##&

....

,. / 0 #&&

!""##!& ( #!+ ""#(&! %

( "!! /0 # 1&! ""## 2 !&( %

( +"!! /0 &#2 #&&

! !

& " &% +&!&&( ! & &(& &"!!!!&#&&

! +#&

&" +!!

*) )!, %& &

&#0 &( !##)& " +!!&&!

&3 #/&( 4 46 )& !"+# !

,# 7 #!8&!#+!& &)!"& "!!!!&)!

#& 9)*!&+ ""0)! ! #* *& )!( !# ) /:+ !

/!;

#0+ # &!"& #&&

!! ! + + "#& 3 + 0 ) &+ )! #! +& (&!

< )&! *:+ & ( !##

4 46 )! & <)!

"# 3 #/&( )!

:+# !&) ""0 +3 #/&( + :+ ( !## <)!"# 3 #/&( * -, 2 #&) )! ""0 = &#2 ""+&&( & +&#/# &#* + !

& /0 "#&&

! ) ! # 1&!

""##2 !! &( # &#2 /0(&&(

##)&(!!' <)!&+

/ " "#&&

/& "!!& 3 #/&( (

4 46 + " )& ! !

/ & "!!& 3 #/&( 8: * ##( ( !##*&!" /, !& /, ! / "

+ )=+#2

&!!& !&( "/

"!!!!& "&! 3 #/&( )!& + /) !

+)!) / * * )&&( 4 46 /+ /

# 1<&!" &#

+"& ! 5*

> %&

&& &#0 ? # !/& & & & ( !##!, )#*) !& !

/!;

+ *&)!" # &!/&( !+&/

!, )# < +!& "&& &!2 * ##)&(!

/!&# ;

!& #)&! &&' @ &&!&+

/ " ""

( !##(

/& "!!& :+ "!"+& + "

)&&( &("&:"+ "0 &!

:+ & ( !## @ "#&&

*) +#& ! + & "!!!!& "

( !## ) # !# +!& & ! / "& &!

&# "+ &!"!!!!& +&5

"0 +&" " +

!## <&!& &!"

( !## 4 46 &!& )&&( ? ( !## !/

/ , /03 #/&( " +!!&&! ?"( !## "#&&

!: & (&#)&!! #&( !@ !#! : & !+&/A!& !@6A !)&!!! ! #/&( * ) "

/& "!!& ( !## ! &( +! ( !## < +!& "&& &!2 *& "!+

&+& +*&)!&+

/ " "" ( !##(

/& "!!&+ " )&&( &( "&:" )&&( &("&:"+#0(&0

"&&/! " &!:"&! + "&&&!/& &( 2 ? *!""!&& #)&+/ # +

/ & "!!&>!&( !"&+ # +

& /0 :+ &! #(# &!* & &! /#&(0 "" ( !&( !>

/& "!!&+ " )&&( &("& :"? !&! "0*) &! !&( !

/& "!!&" !&( !

/& "!!& /#( &##

* & "! +! # ( + "#&)& 3 + 0 "& 0!&& 0

3 + 0 # "+ &(! / !& !A 3 + 0*

& &! +& ! & & ( !## 9)*

#()& &! 3 + 0 ++#

& &! * ) ! /+ &! ! ? "+ &(! 3 + 08: &#? "+ &(!

!&( /0 "+ 3 + 0 #( )& !"+/#! &##( ? !"+ &(! /" /0 ! ,! -", 9+* &!;

!& #) &!!) ""## ? !+ ;

!&&! ) "#&&

*) +#& ! + &"!!!!&"

( !##) #!#+!& & !/"& *&!&# "+ &!"!!!!&

+&5 ?!

"0+&"" +

!##

5 <&) &!+ !!& /* &&! +# !## 4 46 )!:+ /0" +!!

!!" ( *&!#+!& &)!"&

"!!!!& )! #& < )! ( !# ) / :+ + #&!"& 0 #& + &!

# ? " +!! "#&&

! "& & !# +!& &<)! " +!! "0 #

( ""0 +

/ +&#&&( (&!& !# < !+&+

!+!* "#&&

!""##!&# "+ &"!!!!&&"" + ( !##& !

+&5 ?!

"0+ + "!"+& "

+ !!&!&# "+ &"!!!!&&!"+& + ) !

& !"+& &+" + !/ 9+*;

!& &!#!!) ""##! = 1&!""##2 ! # 8: &!"(

/,/ & !&+/ & !/"

+ * * !## &!

&!!&/# ? &( # 1&!

""##2 &! ! ? "("" / &&!

## "&+ "" A "&! !+&/ ( !##

!&( ! + "&+ ""&&(&# !/"

+ &#*&+ /&( /0 2 ( /,

) &!"")! !/"

+ ( !##&!++/) "&!* ++ !/ && )&&( !&( /0 "&! 9+* 8: /&( + "#

+ /&( /0 2 = 2 !

# =+#2

&!!&

+ " / "!!!!& /* =+# 2

&!!& ! &0 +& !) &+ "0&!&"!!!!& 9)*=+#2

&!!&) !/""& &!&(

" 2 ++&#0& 2 ) &! "!&& !" :! /0 # 1&!""##2 #/&( & !# )! // &! +)!& -, 2 #&) / < +!& "&& &!2 * &!) & " +! !"0)!" %&, + ! !>+)!) /< + )!0 ""0&! + (++ /9+*"&!(

!# ) /:+ "0 #

# 0)& ( + ( ""0 = 1&! ""## 2 !

&( !## ( & + !/# " "0 )! /0

! < +!& "&& &!2 * &!&!!

)! &!&(/) "&!-&!"

)!) )!0( !##/)

3 #/&( ## #(# &!

&!/ A &! )"#&&

!<)! &%&+! & + ! 5*

>)!"& %&

!&!!

)! /0 2 &!!"+* * &( #

1&!""##2 )) ##0 +!!0 = 1&!""##2 !

&!"

& &0 ""0/0 &( ( !##? 2 ! #

6 ,# 7 #!# ( /!# *) &+ )! !

, )## ) &+ + ! # A &! !" % / & 0 444

* # ) &+ !/ !+&/ & !##!, )#&!

#0& & & &##

* & &0 ""0( /!# &! & &!"

/) "&!&!!

)! /0 2 ! &!

!"+ &##

) #+#+

&!!&&! &##( + &!"

# * ""0)!& & & /0 !"+&"&!9+* &( 2 ( !##&!

( +##0 ! &##

* + + +#& )& ( ""0& &!"

+#& &( !#!/&"!!!!& "!!&( + " &% +&!&&( "#&&

& &(& &"!!!!&9+*&+/! #0++#

& &0 ""0& &!"

)!!

/%+ &!"

/) "&! <&) &!+ !!& /* %

( "!! /0 # 1&!""##2 &!!!& %

( "!! /0 # &#2 &!! 9+ ( #!+ ""#&!##)

, @ ",&(>! ' B!> @ "/# ' B!>